Chapter 3 - The Shot at the Table

Sarah placed the envelope on the dining table between a water ring and the silver sugar bowl.
"Before you look," she said, "I need you to understand where these came from. I took the photographs myself. The printed messages came from a company expense submission. I haven't examined anyone's private phone."
Andrew did not open the envelope.
"How long have you been working for my daughter?"
"Nearly three years."
"And how much does she pay you?"
Sarah felt the room change around her. "That doesn't affect what I saw."
"It affects why you're here."
She slid the first photograph onto the table. In it, Blake sat opposite Monica with both her hands between his. The second showed the embrace beside the cafe window. A hanging lamp reflected in the glass, but their faces were clear.
Andrew studied the pictures. His hand moved toward his coffee, stopped, and closed instead around the edge of the table.
"Where?"
"Larch Street Cafe. Tuesday afternoon."
She laid out the printed conversation.
"I believe they're having a relationship. I'm sorry. I wouldn't have brought this to you without seeing them myself."
The apology seemed to make him angrier.
Monica appeared in the doorway before he answered. Blake followed her, still wearing the charcoal shirt he had worn at dinner.
"What's happening?" she asked.
Then she saw the photographs.
The pause lasted less than a second, but Sarah noticed it. So did Andrew.
Monica seized the nearest print. "This isn't real."
"Monica," Andrew said.
"No. Look at it. Anyone can make photographs now. Anyone."
Blake stepped closer. "Where did you get these?"
"I took them," Sarah said.
"You expect us to believe you've been following us?" Monica's voice rose. "Or did Grace pay someone and ask you to deliver them?"
Upstairs, a voice still murmured through Grace's laptop. The ceiling carried ordinary footsteps. Sarah suddenly wished she had waited on the stairs until Grace was beside her.
"Nobody manufactured these photographs."
Monica turned toward Andrew. "She's resented me from the day I married you. You know that. She couldn't forgive me for being alive when Evelyn wasn't."
"Don't bring her mother into this," Blake said, but he did not say the photographs were true.
Andrew looked at him.
"Then tell me what I'm looking at."
"We had lunch. She was upset."
"About what?"
"The Mercer deal."
Sarah touched the message printout. "That isn't how these read."
Monica slapped it away. "You have no right to be in this house doing this."
Grace appeared in the doorway, cream blouse untucked at one side, her dark-brown hair falling over her shoulder. She had heard the raised voices and left the call unfinished.
"I asked her to investigate."
Every face turned toward her.
"There," Monica said. Her voice broke into something close to a sob. "She admits it. A conspiracy, Andrew. In our own home."
"It wasn't a conspiracy," Grace said. "I asked her to find out whether I was wrong."
"You should have come to me," Andrew said.
"Would you have listened?"
"I am listening now."
But he wasn't. His eyes moved between Monica, Blake, the prints, Sarah. Grace had seen that expression during arguments with contractors: the moment when a disagreement stopped being about facts and became a challenge to his right to decide them.
Sarah raised the source sheet.
"I can show you the camera files. The originals haven't been edited."
Andrew pushed back his chair.
The sound scraped across the floor, sharp enough to silence everyone.
"You people," he said quietly.
"Dad."
"In my house. With my money."
He walked past Grace toward the glass cabinet.
For an instant she believed he meant to steady himself against it. Then she saw his hand close around the small brass handle.
"No."
The cabinet door opened.
Grace remembered the Christmas guest's uncertain laugh. Her aunt leaving early. Her own remark a week before: That doesn't make it furniture.
Andrew took the handgun out.
"Dad, put it down."
Monica stepped back into Blake. He caught her elbow, then released it as though the gesture itself had accused them.
Sarah did not move. Her eyes went to the weapon and stayed there.
"Mr. Pierce," she said, "we can leave. We can talk another time."
Andrew turned toward her.
"Who paid you to destroy my family?"
"Nobody paid me to lie."
"Andrew," Monica whispered.
The weapon rose.
Sarah lifted both hands slowly, palms visible, the source sheet slipping from her fingers.
"Please. I'm telling the truth."
Grace moved before she understood that she was moving.
"DAD, STOP!"
The gunshot erased the room.
Later, she would remember separate things rather than a sequence: a flash, Sarah's cry, the photograph turning in the air, the shocking weight of a body that could no longer hold itself upright.
Sarah struck the side of a chair and fell.
Grace dropped beside her. Blood spread through the navy fabric high on Sarah's left shoulder, darkening it almost black. Her right hand searched the floor without finding anything to hold.
Grace caught it.
"Look at me. Sarah, look at me."
Sarah's eyes were open. Her breathing came in frightened, shallow bursts.
"My arm," she said. "Grace, my arm."
"Don't try to move it. I'm here."
Andrew stood beside the cabinet with the handgun lowered. His face had emptied of rage so completely that he looked like a stranger discovering what another man had done.
But there was no other man.
"Call an ambulance," he whispered.
Grace looked up. "Put the gun down."
He stared at the blood.
"Put it down!"
He laid it on the sideboard and stepped away.
Monica's hand covered her mouth. Blake stood rigid beside her, his eyes fixed on the scattered photographs.
Grace pulled a folded linen napkin from the table and pressed it where Sarah was bleeding. With her free hand, she reached for her phone. One photograph had landed beside Sarah's cheek. Monica and Blake were still holding each other inside it, trapped in a sunlit afternoon that now seemed obscenely far away.
"Stay with me," Grace said.
Sarah's fingers tightened faintly around hers.
May you like
Grace looked across the room at her stepmother and brother. Her tears made their faces blur, but not enough to soften them.
"I will prove the truth."