Chapter 10 - What Monica Was Afraid Of

Grace would not take Monica home.
They sat on a bench outside the pharmacy, where shoppers passed with paper bags and neither woman could pretend this was a private family conference. Grace texted Nina their location. Monica watched her do it without objecting.
"How long?" Grace asked.
Monica stared at her wedding ring.
"About eighteen months."
The answer landed with a strange softness. Grace had expected a revelation to feel larger than the suspicion that preceded it. Instead, it felt like a door closing on the last place her mind could hide.
"Blake was twenty-six?"
"Twenty-five when it started. We were both adults."
"He's your husband's son."
"I know who he is."
"Then don't answer as though I asked you for a technical defense."
Monica flinched. A shopper maneuvered a stroller past their knees. Both women moved aside automatically, performing a tiny courtesy in the middle of something monstrous.
"Was any of it real?" Grace asked. "The dinners? The birthday cards? Asking whether I'd eaten when I worked late?"
"Yes."
"You can lie while caring about someone?"
Monica gave a tired, unpleasant laugh. "People do it every day. Your family has made an art of it."
"You're part of my family. You don't get to stand outside it now."
That silenced her.
Monica described the beginning in plain terms. A long day at the office. An argument with Andrew over an acquisition she had negotiated and he had presented as his own work. Blake staying behind. Two people discovering that resentment sounded like understanding when spoken back to them.
Grace stopped her before the story could become tender.
"I'm not asking for reasons it felt good."
"You asked whether anything was real."
"Sarah was real. You watched him point a gun at her."
Monica's eyes filled. "I didn't think he'd shoot."
"Neither did she."
For a moment, the sounds of traffic and shopping carts seemed unbearably cheerful.
Monica said she had married Andrew because she wanted security. Her father had lost a small business when she was young; creditors had called through dinner, and her mother had hidden overdue notices inside cookbooks. Monica had sworn she would never again have to make a home look peaceful while waiting for it to disappear.
"So you married money," Grace said.
"I married a man who made security sound like love. I also worked. I learned his projects. I saved deals he was too proud to renegotiate. I thought eventually being useful would make me safe."
"Did it?"
Monica shook her head.
Grace wanted to dismiss the story. She also remembered Andrew telling Sarah to remain standing because she was working, telling Blake he should be grateful, telling Grace she was too emotional to understand an account statement.
Understanding Monica did not require trusting her. Grace held on to that distinction.
"Did you request the report about Sarah?"
Monica looked sharply at her.
"Nina has it," Grace said.
"I asked Julian what he knew about her. I knew she'd been asking questions."
"You wanted Dad to think she was a liar before she opened the envelope."
"I wanted time."
"For what?"
Monica's gaze went to the pharmacy doors.
"The sale. There were things that needed to be completed before you got the shares."
"Because I might object?"
"Because your father had already put the company in trouble, and everyone was trying to get out without being the person left holding it."
"Who is everyone?"
Monica did not answer.
Grace stood. "Then this isn't a confession. It's another negotiation."
"Sit down. Please."
She remained standing.
"I have records," Monica said. "Things about the company, Julian's arrangements. I can help you recover money."
"Tell your lawyer. Give them to the investigators."
"You have influence with Sarah."
The sentence made Grace cold.
"No."
"I'm not asking her to lie. I'm asking whether she'd consider—"
"You don't get to purchase a smaller version of what happened to her. And I don't get to sell it."
Monica looked down at the ring again. Grace saw the pale indentation beneath it when she turned it around her finger.
"I thought if I had enough money of my own, nobody could make me afraid," Monica said.
"You had enough power to frighten someone else. You used it."
A silence followed that Monica did not try to fill.
Grace sat again, not because she had forgiven her, but because the conversation was not finished.
"Did you know about the four trust transfers?"
"Yes. Andrew called them temporary."
"Did you know my consent was forged?"
Monica closed her eyes.
"You need to ask Julian how that document was produced."
"That's not what I asked."
"I knew you hadn't attended the review meeting he described."
Grace felt the last small sympathy inside her change shape. It remained, but it would no longer be permitted to interfere with the facts.
She took out her phone and wrote the words down while Monica watched.
"I'm giving Nina a record of this conversation. She'll decide what needs verifying."
"You sound like Sarah."
"I'm trying."
Monica stood this time. At the corner she stopped, as though there were one last thing she could say that might rearrange how Grace judged her.
"Your mother wasn't naive about Andrew."
Grace's hands went still.
"Don't use her."
May you like
"I'm not. Look at the trust restrictions. Ask why a woman who loved her husband put so many warnings around what he could do with her money."
Then Monica walked away, leaving Grace with the confession she had wanted and a question she had spent six years refusing to ask.