Chapter 5 - Lily’s First Confession

Evie showed the note to Thomas in the car.
He read it, then passed it to Julia.
“Photograph it,” Julia said.
Evie hated that everything now had to become evidence.
At school the next day, Ms. Hale was temporarily assigned administrative
duties while the incident was reviewed. A substitute teacher took Room
3B.
Without Ms. Hale present, the room felt physically larger.
At recess, Lily found Evie near the library doors.
“You showed them the note?”
“Yes.”
Lily’s face drained. “Why?”
“Because you lied.”
“I said I was sorry.”
“That doesn’t tell them the truth.”
Lily pressed her palms together. “I can’t.”
“Why not?”
Lily looked toward the corridor.
“Ms. Hale told me if I changed my story, everyone would know I lied.”
“You did lie.”
“She said my parents would be called. She said I could lose my student
leadership badge. She said good schools remember dishonest children.”
Evie stared at her.
“When did she tell you that?”
“After class. Before I wrote the statement.”
“Did she tell you what to write?”
Lily’s eyes filled.
“She said, ‘Think carefully about what you actually saw.’ Then she kept
asking if maybe you knocked it over. I kept saying no. Then she said I
was making a serious accusation against a teacher by supporting your
story.”
Evie’s heartbeat quickened. “What accusation?”
Lily swallowed. “The slap.”
“You saw it?”
Lily nodded.
“Then why did you say I spilled the water?”
“Because if I admitted the bottle was mine, she said people might think
I was saying anything to escape punishment.”
Evie felt anger rise, but Lily looked so frightened that it could not
stay simple.
“You could have told the truth.”
“I know.”
“You watched me cry.”
“I know.”
“And you let her call me a liar.”
Lily wiped her face. “I know.”
Evie stepped back. “Sorry isn’t enough.”
Lily nodded as if she had expected that.
That afternoon, Lily asked to speak with Headmistress Mercer. Her mother
attended.
For nearly twenty minutes, Lily said nothing.
Then Mercer placed the handwritten apology note on the table.
Lily began to cry.
“The bottle was mine,” she whispered.
Catherine Cross went still.
Lily continued.
“I spilled the water. Evie didn’t.”
Mercer asked the next question gently.
“Did you see Ms. Hale strike Evie?”
Lily closed her eyes.
“Yes.”
Outside the office, Evie waited with Thomas.
When the door opened, Lily walked out looking smaller than before.
May you like
But Ms. Hale was standing at the far end of the corridor.
And judging by her face, she already knew Lily had changed her story.