Chapter 4 - Behind the Glass Office Door

Headmistress Mercer’s office smelled of coffee, old books, and rain-damp
wool. Evie sat between Thomas and Julia while Ms. Hale occupied a chair
across from them.
Mercer began carefully. “Our goal is to understand what occurred.”
Thomas placed his phone on the table. “Then start with whether a teacher
struck my daughter.”
Ms. Hale’s jaw tightened. “I made brief physical contact while
redirecting her.”
Evie stared at her.
“A slap is not redirection,” Julia said.
“I reject that characterization.”
Evie’s hands began to shake.
Thomas noticed. “Evie, tell Ms. Mercer what happened.”
Evie did.
She described Lily’s bottle falling. She described Ms. Hale entering.
She described the slap.
Ms. Hale waited until she finished.
“Evelyn was already highly agitated,” she said. “Her memory may be
colored by embarrassment.”
“My memory isn’t colored,” Evie said.
Mercer raised a hand. “Evie—”
“No. She keeps changing my words.”
Silence.
Ms. Hale’s face remained composed, but her eyes sharpened.
Thomas produced the photograph of the bottle cap.
Ms. Hale dismissed it exactly as she had the day before.
Mercer asked whether classroom cameras existed.
“No video surveillance inside instructional rooms,” she said. “Only
hallways and entrances.”
“Then check the hallway,” Julia said. “You’ll see when Ms. Hale entered.
You may see Lily near the door before that.”
Mercer agreed.
Then Evie asked a question no adult had considered.
“Can you see the classroom door in the hallway camera?”
“Yes,” Mercer said.
“Is there glass in the door?”
A narrow vertical window ran down every classroom door.
Mercer understood first.
The hallway camera might not show the entire classroom, but depending on
its angle, it could show a thin slice through the glass.
Ms. Hale leaned back.
For the first time, Evie saw uncertainty in her face.
Mercer called the school’s technology director and requested the footage
be preserved immediately.
Ms. Hale spoke quickly. “Before we turn this into a spectacle, may I
remind everyone that Lily provided a statement?”
“An eight-year-old provided a statement after being questioned by the
teacher she may have feared,” Julia replied.
Ms. Hale’s expression hardened. “That is speculation.”
“So is calling Evie’s memory unreliable.”
Mercer ended the meeting pending review.
In the hallway, Evie saw Lily waiting with her mother, Catherine Cross.
Lily’s eyes widened when she noticed Evie.
Catherine guided her daughter away.
But as Lily passed, something slipped from her hand and landed near
Evie’s shoe.
A folded scrap of paper.
Evie picked it up after they disappeared around the corner.
May you like
Three words were written in shaky pencil.
I am sorry.