Chapter 2 - THREE UNREAD MESSAGES

Caroline did not call Andrew over right away.
She read all three messages first.
That was partly because she wanted to understand them before he saw her face, and partly because some defensive part of her still hoped the first email had sounded worse than it was.
It did not.
The second message was from Milo's homeroom teacher, Mrs. Patrice Holloway, sent four weeks earlier.
Milo is doing well academically and is kind with classmates. I do want to mention that he often minimizes when he is disappointed. Today his group changed partners unexpectedly, and he said, "It's fine, I can be alone," before asking to use the restroom. When I checked in later, he said he did not want anyone to think something was wrong at home.
The third message had been sent nine days earlier.
With Ben's move approaching, Milo seems more emotional than usual. I asked whether he would like support from our school counselor. He said, "My parents are busy, and I don't want this to become a family problem." I wanted you to be aware of that wording.
Caroline read the final sentence twice.
Then a third time.
Andrew came into the kitchen carrying two mugs of tea.
"You disappeared," he said.
She turned the laptop toward him.
He set the mugs down.
For several seconds he did not speak.
Then he pointed to the dates.
"You didn't see these?"
"No."
"How?"
The question irritated her because she already felt accused by the screen.
"The school sends everything through the same portal. Lunch notices, fundraising, attendance, club forms. I miss things."
"Three things about Milo?"
Caroline snapped the laptop shut.
"Don't do that."
"Do what?"
"Turn this into me being a bad mother because I missed emails."
Andrew leaned back against the counter. "I didn't say that."
"You didn't have to."
They stood in a silence that felt familiar. Their arguments often started this way: one person made a small observation, the other heard a larger accusation, and within minutes both of them were defending themselves against words no one had actually said.
Then Andrew looked toward the ceiling, toward Milo's room.
"This isn't about us."
Caroline hated how much she needed to hear that.
He opened the laptop again.
"Read the part about the bathroom."
She did.
When she finished, Andrew said, "That wasn't today."
"I know."
"So when he said he'd go cry in the bathroom..."
"He already does."
Neither of them touched the tea.
Andrew scrolled through the portal himself. There were ordinary school notices around the teacher's messages: library books due, picture day reminders, a permission slip for a science museum. The normality made the warnings feel stranger. Nothing in their house had looked like a crisis. Milo did homework. Milo said thank you. Milo put his plate in the sink without being asked most nights.
Apparently, he also had a private system for disappearing whenever his feelings seemed inconvenient.
Andrew stopped scrolling.
"Did we teach him this?"
Caroline looked away.
"That's a dramatic question."
"Is it?"
"We don't tell him he's not allowed to be sad."
Andrew raised one eyebrow.
"Today you told him your head hurt when he asked what to do if he missed Ben."
"Because my head hurt."
"And I told him to call Ben like that solves losing him."
Caroline folded her arms.
"So now we're terrible because we didn't give perfect answers in one conversation?"
"No. I'm asking whether it was one conversation."
Upstairs, a floorboard creaked.
They both stopped.
A moment later Milo appeared at the kitchen doorway in pajamas, holding an empty glass.
Caroline closed the laptop too quickly.
His eyes went to it.
"Were you reading my school stuff?"
She hesitated.
"Some messages from Mrs. Holloway."
Milo held the glass against his chest.
"Am I in trouble?"
Andrew's face tightened.
"No. Why would you be in trouble?"
Milo shrugged.
"She said she might tell you."
Caroline opened the laptop again, deliberately this time.
"Tell us what?"
Milo's gaze moved between them.
"That I go to the bathroom sometimes."
"When you're sad?" Andrew asked.
Milo nodded.
"Why there?"
Milo considered the question as if there were a correct answer he needed to find.
"It's quiet."
Andrew waited.
"Anywhere else?"
Milo shifted one bare foot over the other.
"Sometimes the library stairwell."
Caroline's stomach turned.
"At school?"
"Only if no one's there."
"Milo, why do you think you need to hide?"
He looked genuinely confused by the question.
"I don't hide."
"You just said you go where nobody can see you."
"That's different."
"How?"
Milo stared into his empty glass.
"Hiding is when you don't want people to find you. I come back when I'm done."
Caroline had no answer for that.
Andrew pulled out a kitchen chair.
"Come sit for a minute."
Milo did, but he perched on the edge instead of relaxing.
Andrew sat across from him.
"When did you start doing that?"
Milo frowned, thinking.
"I don't know."
"This year?"
"Maybe."
Caroline asked softly, "Was it after Ben told you he was moving?"
Milo shook his head.
"Before."
"Before what?"
He took a breath.
"Before Grandma's dog died."
Caroline blinked.
"Rufus?"
Milo nodded.
Rufus had died the previous November. Milo had loved that old dog. Caroline remembered him crying in the car after they left her mother's house.
She also remembered saying, You're going to make yourself sick if you keep this up.
Andrew rubbed his beard.
"That was months ago."
"Yeah."
"What happened then?"
Milo looked toward Caroline, then down.
"Mom said crying wouldn't bring him back."
Caroline felt the sentence hit a place in her chest she had not prepared to defend.
"I didn't mean you weren't allowed to cry."
Milo nodded quickly.
"I know."
That automatic agreement was worse than disagreement.
Andrew asked, "What did you think she meant?"
Milo lifted the glass and turned it slowly between his hands.
"That crying doesn't help anything."
Caroline's throat tightened.
Milo stood.
"Can I get water now?"
She nodded.
He filled the glass, thanked them, and went upstairs.
Only after his footsteps disappeared did Andrew speak.
"We need to call Mrs. Holloway."
Caroline looked at the closed laptop.
"Tomorrow."
Andrew shook his head.
"No. We need to email tonight and ask for a meeting."
She almost argued.
Then she remembered Milo explaining the difference between hiding and simply leaving until he was done.
Caroline opened the laptop.
The cursor blinked in a blank message window.
For the first time, she did not know what version of herself she wanted the teacher to see.
So she typed the truth.
We missed your messages. We are concerned. Please tell us what Milo has been trying to tell you.
Before she pressed send, she noticed a fourth unread message beneath the others.
It was not from Mrs. Holloway.
May you like
It was from the school counselor.
Subject: A note Milo asked me not to send unless necessary.