scribe

Chapter 13 - THE ARGUMENT IN THE KITCHEN

The first serious argument Caroline and Andrew had about Milo happened after he went to bed.

That should have made it private.

It did not.

The kitchen vent carried sound up the stairwell, and their voices, though not shouting, sharpened enough to travel.

"I think we're making him focus on this too much," Andrew said.

Caroline folded a dish towel harder than necessary.

"Focus on what? His feelings?"

"No. Every feeling. Every reaction. Every sentence. We ask him how he feels about how he felt."

"Because we spent months not asking."

"That doesn't mean we have to swing all the way to the other side."

Caroline dropped the towel on the counter.

"So what's your suggestion? Go back to telling him to cheer up?"

"That's not fair."

"Neither is acting like I'm creating the problem because I'm trying to repair it."

Andrew rubbed both hands over his face.

"I'm saying maybe he's eight and sometimes he should just play."

"He does play."

"Then why are we discussing every sad moment like it's a family case study?"

Neither noticed the shadow on the staircase.

Milo sat three steps from the top, knees pulled to his chest.

He had come down for water.

He stayed because he heard his name.

Caroline lowered her voice.

"Mrs. Holloway told us he was hiding in bathrooms. I'm not going to pretend that fixes itself because we bought sticky notes."

"I'm not asking you to pretend. I'm asking whether we're teaching him sadness gets more attention than anything else now."

Milo stood silently.

Then the stair creaked.

Both adults turned.

He froze.

Caroline's face changed.

"Milo."

"Sorry."

"You don't need to apologize."

"I was getting water."

Andrew pulled out a chair.

"Come here."

Milo shook his head.

"You were fighting because of me."

"No," Caroline said immediately.

Milo looked at her.

She stopped.

That answer was too simple.

They had been discussing him. Pretending otherwise would teach him not to trust obvious facts.

Andrew spoke carefully.

"We were disagreeing about how to help you. That's different from the disagreement being your fault."

Milo remained on the stairs.

"If I wasn't sad, you wouldn't be fighting."

Caroline felt the trap in the logic.

Technically, perhaps.

But children should not be responsible for keeping adults from disagreeing by having fewer needs.

"If the dishwasher broke, Dad and I might disagree about how to fix it," she said.

Milo frowned. "I'm not a dishwasher."

Andrew almost laughed, then stopped.

"Definitely not."

Caroline tried again.

"You telling us the truth gives us information. What we do with that information is our job."

Milo looked at Andrew.

"Do you think I talk about being sad too much?"

Andrew's face fell.

"No."

"You said every feeling."

"I did. And I shouldn't have said it that way."

Milo descended one step.

"What did you mean?"

Andrew took a breath.

"I worry that your mom and I are so afraid of missing something now that we're turning you into a project."

Caroline looked at him.

The sentence was better than the argument had been.

Milo came down another step.

"I don't like when you both look at me after I say something normal."

Caroline winced.

"We do that?"

"Yesterday I said the cereal was bad and you asked if I felt unheard."

Andrew covered his mouth.

Caroline stared at him.

"Don't laugh."

"I'm trying not to."

Milo's mouth twitched too.

Caroline groaned.

"Okay. That was ridiculous."

"A little," Milo said.

Andrew leaned on the table.

"So we need another adjustment."

Milo looked suspiciously at the refrigerator.

"Not another rule."

"No rule."

"Good."

Caroline sat down.

"Can you tell us when we're doing too much?"

Milo shrugged. "Maybe."

Andrew corrected himself. "And if you don't, it's still our job to notice."

Milo nodded.

Then he looked at both of them.

"Can you finish fighting after I go upstairs?"

Caroline blinked.

"You want us to continue?"

"If you stop because I heard, then I'll think you only don't fight when I don't know."

Andrew stared at his son.

"That's... very specific."

"I don't want to wonder."

Caroline glanced at Andrew.

"We can finish talking. Not fighting."

Milo accepted that.

He got his water and went upstairs.

This time they waited until his bedroom door closed.

Andrew lowered his voice.

"He's right."

"About what?"

"We're staring at him like he's a weather instrument."

Caroline nodded.

"And you're right that we can't spend every day correcting ourselves out loud in front of him."

Andrew sat across from her.

"So what do we do?"

"Maybe fewer questions. More availability."

"Toast."

She smiled. "Apparently toast."

They talked another twenty minutes.

No one won.

They agreed to keep the counselor appointment but stop bringing every small mood to the family table. They agreed not to ask Milo to reassure them that they were improving. They agreed that if they disagreed about parenting, they would not hide the existence of disagreement from him, but they would make clear that resolving it was adult work.

Upstairs, Milo lay awake listening.

He could not hear the words anymore.

Only the murmur.

For the first time, the sound did not make him think he needed to become easier.

The next morning, he found Andrew making coffee.

"Did you finish?"

Andrew nodded.

"Mostly."

"Who won?"

"Nobody."

Milo frowned.

"Then what happened?"

Andrew smiled.

"We understood each other better."

Milo considered that.

"That's not how Ben and I argue."

"How do you argue?"

"One person says sorry and then we play something."

Andrew laughed.

"Honestly, that's not a terrible system."

Milo poured cereal.

Then he said, "Ben and I haven't had a real argument yet."

Andrew thought of Jaylen, Theo, missed calls, and distance.

"You probably will."

Milo looked at him.

"Is that bad?"

Andrew shook his head.

May you like

"Not if both of you are allowed to stay after."

Two days later, Milo learned whether that was true.

Related Stories

Other posts