scribe
40 IT'S HOLDEN / Chapter 9 / 30

Chapter 9 - GRANDMA DENISE

Grandma Denise came for Sunday dinner carrying peach cobbler and opinions.

She was Adrian's mother, sixty-seven, retired from a public library, and capable of noticing emotional weather before anyone had decided it was raining.

She hugged Luca first because he reached her first.

Then Holden.

"You got taller again."

"I don't think so."

"You did. My eyes work."

He smiled.

At dinner, Luca told her about soccer. Holden told her about the district exhibition only after she asked him what was new at school.

"Engineering merit," Denise said. "That's serious."

Holden shrugged.

"It wasn't first place."

"Did I ask if it was first place?"

He smiled again.

After dessert, Denise helped Sophie wrap leftovers while Adrian took the boys upstairs to find an old board game.

"What's going on?" Denise asked quietly.

Sophie stopped folding foil.

"Why do you think something's going on?"

"Because Adrian asked Holden what game he wanted before Luca."

Sophie stared at her.

Denise shrugged. "That boy doesn't change a habit without a meeting first."

Sophie laughed despite herself.

Then she told her.

Not everything.

Just the phone call, the voicemails, the violin calendar, and the way Holden had learned to say it was okay before anyone apologized.

Denise listened without interrupting.

When Sophie finished, she leaned against the counter.

"Adrian did this as a child."

Sophie blinked.

"What?"

"Not the favoritism. The disappearing."

"I thought he was an only child."

"He is."

Denise looked toward the stairs.

"His father worked long shifts. I worked two jobs for a while. Adrian was easy. Quiet. Good grades. He learned early that being low-maintenance got praised."

Sophie frowned.

"He never told me that."

"He probably doesn't think it's a story."

Denise rinsed a plate.

"That's how these things survive. People only count what hurt loudly."

Upstairs, Luca found the board game first and wanted to choose it.

Adrian said, "Holden picks tonight."

Luca asked why.

Adrian answered, "Because you picked last time."

Simple.

No speech about fairness.

No guilt.

Holden chose a strategy game Luca was too young to play well.

Then, after seeing Luca's disappointed face, he reached for the easier game.

Adrian put a hand on the box.

"You don't have to change."

Holden looked at Luca.

"He won't like this one."

"That's okay. He can learn or do something else."

Luca crossed his arms.

"I want the animal game."

Denise appeared in the doorway.

"And I want to be twenty-nine again. Life is full of disappointment."

Luca stared at her.

Holden laughed so suddenly he snorted.

Everyone laughed then, including Luca, although he was not completely sure why.

They played Holden's game.

Luca lost badly.

Halfway through, he climbed into Denise's lap and watched instead.

No one died from it.

When the boys went upstairs to brush their teeth, Denise sat beside Adrian at the table.

"Your wife told me you're figuring some things out."

Adrian exhaled.

"Apparently."

"Don't turn Holden into a project."

He frowned.

"I'm not."

"You will if you're not careful. You'll ask him to explain every feeling so you can prove you're listening. That's work too."

Adrian rubbed his jaw.

"So what do I do?"

"Notice things without making him file a report."

Adrian looked toward the stairs.

"I missed a lot."

"Probably."

"That's not very comforting."

Denise picked up her tea.

"I'm your mother. Not your publicist."

He smiled despite himself.

She softened.

"You can't redo eight or nine or ten. You can make eleven different."

Adrian looked down.

Denise added, "And don't make Luca responsible for the correction. He'll notice changes. Explain fairness without telling him he's been loved wrong."

Adrian nodded.

Before she left, Denise went upstairs to say goodnight.

Holden was at his desk reading.

She kissed the top of his head.

"Send me your weird science pictures anytime."

He looked up.

"Even if you don't know what they are?"

"Especially then. I spent thirty-five years helping people find books about things I didn't understand. Curiosity is free."

Holden smiled.

The next afternoon, Denise received a photo.

It showed three gears and a ruler.

The message read:

GUESS WHICH ONE MAKES THE WHEEL STRONGER.

Denise guessed wrong.

Holden sent back six laughing emojis.

Denise returned home after Sunday dinner and pulled an old photograph album from her closet.

She found Adrian at nine, sitting under the library desk with crayons scattered around his knees. In the next photo he was ten, holding a paper airplane. Then twelve, standing alone at an academic awards assembly because Denise had arrived late and missed the ceremony.

She remembered his response when she apologized.

It's okay, Ma. You work.

Denise sat on the bedroom floor longer than she intended.

The next week she invited Holden to the library where she had once worked. Most of the staff had changed, but one older librarian remembered Adrian.

"Quiet boy," the woman said. "Always had a book."

Holden smiled politely.

On the way home he asked Denise, "Was Dad lonely?"

"Sometimes."

"Did you know?"

Denise kept her eyes on the road.

"Not enough."

Holden waited.

"Did he forgive you?"

Denise smiled faintly. "Life is not a courtroom, baby. We loved each other while also getting things wrong."

Holden looked out the window.

"Dad keeps apologizing."

"Does that bother you?"

"Sometimes I don't know what to do with it."

"You don't have to do anything. An apology is supposed to carry its own weight."

May you like

He remembered that sentence months later, when Adrian apologized again. It gave him permission not to immediately answer with reassurance.

Sometimes he could simply say, "I heard you."

Related Stories

Other posts