scribe
40 IT'S HOLDEN / Chapter 17 / 30

Chapter 17 - LUCA'S QUESTION

Luca noticed everything eventually.

He noticed that Dad asked Holden about school more often.

He noticed that Holden sometimes got the first phone call.

He noticed that Mom had stopped interrupting Holden to solve minor problems for him.

He noticed the new photo in the hallway.

At first, these changes were simply weather.

Then one Saturday, Adrian and Holden left for a model-building store while Luca stayed home with Sophie.

Luca stood at the window watching their car disappear.

"Why can't I go?"

"Because it's Holden's afternoon with Dad."

"I can be quiet."

"I know."

"I like stores."

"I know."

"Then why?"

Sophie sat on the couch.

"Come here."

Luca climbed beside her, suspicious.

"Sometimes you and Dad do soccer things without Holden."

"Because he doesn't like soccer."

"Right. And sometimes Holden gets things with Dad that are just his."

Luca frowned.

"But I like Dad."

"Holden does too."

"I know."

He picked at a couch cushion seam.

"Did I take his Dad time?"

The question was so direct that Sophie felt a physical ache.

"No."

"But you keep saying Holden gets turns now."

She chose her words carefully.

"Dad and I realized we weren't paying enough attention to making sure everybody got time. That was our mistake. Not yours."

"Because of soccer?"

"Soccer was part of it. But soccer isn't bad."

"Did Holden hate my games?"

"You'd have to ask Holden how he feels."

Luca looked worried.

That evening, he did.

Holden was at his desk assembling a model gearbox when Luca appeared in the doorway.

"Do you hate soccer?"

Holden blinked.

"What?"

"Mom said I have to ask you."

"Ask me what?"

"If you hate my games."

Holden put down the tiny screwdriver.

"I don't hate your games."

Luca entered the room.

"Do you hate when Dad goes?"

"No."

"Then why do you need Dad days?"

Holden was silent.

There were adult ways to answer and child ways.

He chose neither perfectly.

"Because sometimes everybody knows what you like without asking."

Luca frowned.

"Soccer."

"Yeah. Soccer. Space. Dinosaurs. Orange soda."

"I like lemonade too."

"Okay. Lemonade."

Luca smiled briefly.

Holden continued, "Sometimes I felt like people didn't know my stuff as much."

"I know you like bridges."

"Now you do."

Luca's smile disappeared.

"Did I do something?"

"No."

Holden said it firmly.

"Mom and Dad did some things without noticing. You didn't."

"Like what?"

Holden thought about the phone calls.

"Dad would call and ask for you first."

Luca looked startled.

"Because I answer loud."

Holden laughed.

"Maybe."

"You can answer loud too."

"I know."

"Like HELLO DAD!"

Luca shouted the words so loudly Sophie called from downstairs, "Inside voices!"

Holden laughed harder.

Luca climbed onto the rug.

"You can have Dad Saturday."

"Thanks."

"But can I come next time?"

"Maybe."

"Okay."

He started to leave, then turned back.

"Holden?"

"Yeah?"

"If Dad asks for me and you're talking, you can say no."

Holden looked at him.

"Okay."

Luca nodded as if a contract had been completed.

The next week, Adrian called from the grocery store because he wanted to know whether they needed milk.

Holden answered Sophie's phone while she was upstairs.

"Hey."

Adrian said, "Hey, Holden. Is Mom there?"

"Upstairs."

"Okay. Is Luca—"

He stopped himself.

Holden heard it.

A small silence.

Then Adrian said, "Actually, tell me how your day was while I wait for her."

Holden smiled.

Across the room, Luca looked up from his toys and shouted, "DON'T ASK FOR ME YET!"

Holden burst out laughing.

Adrian laughed through the phone.

Sophie came downstairs confused.

For once, the old pattern was visible enough to become funny without becoming harmless.

That mattered too.

Luca's question about whether he had taken Dad time lingered with Sophie. She worried that even careful corrections could make the younger boy feel as if his existence had caused the problem.

So she created no fairness chart, no equal-minutes schedule, no visible tally on the refrigerator.

Instead, she paid attention to language.

When Adrian took Holden to the model store, Sophie did not tell Luca, "It's Holden's turn because you've had lots of turns."

She said, "They are doing something together today."

When Adrian took Luca to soccer, nobody explained it as repayment.

He simply went.

A few weeks later, Luca asked Holden to come to the park and practice passes. Holden said no because he was reading.

Luca complained to Sophie.

"He never wants to do anything."

Holden heard from the couch.

"I played yesterday."

"But I want today."

Sophie said, "Then you can ask somebody else or play alone."

Luca frowned. "Why doesn't he have to?"

"Because brothers are not employees."

Holden laughed so hard he lost his page.

Later Luca went outside by himself. Ten minutes later a neighbor joined him. He forgot to be offended.

Holden watched through the window and felt a small release.

For years, his helpfulness had been treated as a family resource: useful, renewable, assumed. Now it was becoming something he could offer.

The offering felt warmer because refusal was possible.

Luca eventually invented his own version of private time. He asked Sophie for "just-me breakfast" one Saturday and wanted pancakes without Adrian or Holden at the table.

Sophie laughed but agreed.

Holden came downstairs, saw the arrangement, and started backing away.

Luca pointed at him. "You can get cereal. Just don't talk to Mom yet."

Holden looked offended. "This house is becoming authoritarian."

From upstairs Adrian shouted, "WELCOME TO THE CLUB."

Holden ate cereal silently while Luca told Sophie a long story about school.

May you like

Instead of feeling excluded, Holden felt strangely proud. Luca had learned that asking for focused attention was allowed.

The correction was no longer only for one child. It was becoming a family skill.

Related Stories

Other posts