Chapter 29 - Five Plates Again

The idea came from Lucan.
"Can we have dinner with everybody for my birthday?"
Seraphine looked up from her laptop.
"Everybody who?"
"You. Dad. Orien. Caelan. Me."
"That's five."
"I know numbers."
"Apparently."
His birthday fell on a Friday in August. Seraphine suggested a restaurant, but Lucan wanted dinner at her townhouse because he wanted the chocolate cake she always made.
Evander offered to bring food.
"No tuna," Caelan said immediately.
Seraphine ignored him.
At six, the doorbell rang.
Orien entered carrying a gift bag. Evander followed with two trays of baked pasta and garlic bread.
For one second, the scene resembled an arrival from their married life.
Then Evander handed Seraphine the food and said, "Where do you want these?"
Not, I'm home.
Not, Need help, honey?
The language was different because the relationship was different.
"Kitchen counter. Thanks."
They set the table together.
Five plates.
Seraphine noticed before anyone else.
The memory of Thanksgiving returned: the empty fifth plate at Evander's townhouse, left there because Caelan could not bear every change happening at once.
Now every seat had a person.
But the arrangement was new.
Seraphine sat at one end. Evander sat halfway down the table. The boys filled the spaces around them.
Lucan opened presents before dinner because patience remained theoretical at eight.
Caelan gave him a soccer jersey. Orien gave him a remote-control car. Evander gave him a set of illustrated science books. Seraphine gave him a weekend camping trip.
"With who?" Lucan asked.
"Me and Caelan."
He frowned. "Dad can't come?"
Seraphine smiled. "Dad can take you camping another time."
Lucan looked at Evander.
"Deal?"
"Deal."
After dinner, Lucan blew out eight candles. Frosting ended up on his nose. Caelan took a photo. Orien stole the corner piece before anyone could claim it.
Then the conversation turned unexpectedly serious.
Lucan asked, "Are you guys friends now?"
Evander and Seraphine looked at each other.
"We're family in a different way," Seraphine said.
"That's not an answer."
"It is an adult answer," Caelan said.
"Those are the worst."
Evander laughed.
"Your mom and I care about each other. We work together for you boys. We don't spend time together the way friends usually do."
"So you're friendly."
"Sometimes," Seraphine said.
Lucan seemed satisfied.
Orien looked at Seraphine. "Can I ask something?"
"Sure."
"Do you wish you never married Dad?"
The room quieted.
Seraphine did not rush.
"No."
Evander looked at her.
"I wish we had done a lot of things differently. I wish I had never hurt you. I wish your dad and I had been more honest before resentment became bigger than the problems. But if I say I wish the marriage never happened, I would be wishing away years that gave all of us things that mattered."
Orien nodded.
"Dad?"
Evander leaned back.
"Same answer."
Caelan raised his glass of lemonade.
"To adults finally agreeing on something."
They laughed and clinked glasses.
The sound was small.
Five plates sat on the table.
This time, no one mistook togetherness for sameness.
After Lucan's birthday dinner, the boys went upstairs to test the remote-control car in a hallway far too narrow for it.
Evander and Seraphine stood on the small back patio with coffee.
From inside came a crash, followed by three voices insisting nothing had broken.
Neither adult moved.
"They'll tell us if there's blood," Seraphine said.
"Excellent parenting."
The August evening was warm. For a while they listened to insects in the shrubs and the boys arguing through an open window.
Seraphine looked at him.
"Are you happy?"
Evander considered the question.
"More honest than I was."
"That's not happy."
"I know. I think I'm getting there. You?"
She looked back through the kitchen window at the five plates waiting to be cleared.
"I used to think happiness was the picture staying intact. Big house. Husband. Three boys who looked like brothers in Christmas photos. I spent so much energy protecting the picture that I stopped checking how people inside it felt."
Evander nodded.
"I protected the structure too. Paid bills. Solved problems. Thought a house that ran smoothly was a healthy house."
"It did run smoothly."
"Orien learned to do laundry at eight because you refused."
Seraphine winced.
"Point taken."
"Sorry."
"No. Don't protect me from remembering. Just don't make remembering the only thing I am."
Evander looked at her.
"I don't."
She believed him.
That mattered more than forgiveness in the abstract.
"Do you ever regret taking the ring off that morning?" she asked.
He took his time.
"I regret that I made a permanent statement before I had a plan. I don't regret recognizing the line we'd crossed."
Seraphine nodded.
"I hated you for that sentence. 'Then we're done.'"
"I know."
"Now I think the marriage had been asking us to admit it for a while."
Inside, Lucan shouted, "It still works!"
A second crash followed.
Evander put down his coffee.
"That sounds expensive."
Seraphine smiled.
"Go be Dad."
He opened the door, then looked back.
"Good night, Seraphine."
"Good night, Evander."
There was affection in it.
There was history.
There was no invitation to return.
For once, all three things could exist without conflict.
A few weeks before the anniversary of the empty lunchbox, Dr. Park told Orien they could reduce his sessions.
"You can keep coming," she said. "But I don't think you need weekly appointments unless you want them."
Orien looked almost disappointed.
"Am I fixed?"
"You were never a broken appliance."
"Dad says stuff like that."
"Your dad pays me to say it with credentials."
Orien laughed.
She asked what had changed most during the year.
He thought for a long time.
"I ask now."
"For what?"
"Food. Help. Stuff. If Dad says no, I know it's just no. It doesn't mean I shouldn't have asked."
Dr. Park nodded.
"Anything else?"
"I don't check people's faces as much."
"What do you mean?"
"Like if I say I had fun at Mom's, I don't see if Dad gets sad. Or if I say Seraphine made good pasta, I don't wait to see if Mom gets mad."
"Do they still have feelings?"
"Probably. Adults have too many."
"True."
At the end of the session, Orien asked if he could come back if things got weird again.
"Absolutely."
"Even if it's not a big deal?"
Dr. Park smiled.
"You don't have to decide whether it's big enough before asking for help."
Orien went still for a second.
It was almost the same lesson Evander had tried to teach him at the townhouse table months earlier.
This time, Orien nodded without hesitation.
"Okay."
That evening, he told Evander he wanted to stop weekly therapy.
Evander resisted the urge to ask whether Dr. Park thought that was wise.
"What do you think?"
"I think I can go less."
"Then we'll try it."
May you like
Orien looked surprised by how easy the answer was.
Trust, Evander realized, was becoming ordinary too.