scribe

Chapter 11 - The Apology Orien Did Not Owe

The first time Orien saw Warren Royce, he was carrying a tray of nachos at Caelan's Saturday soccer game.

Warren stood near the sideline in a wool coat, looking like he belonged in a magazine advertisement for expensive watches. He clapped loudly whenever Caelan touched the ball and shouted advice the coach did not ask for.

Orien sat between Evander and Lucan.

"That's their real dad?" he asked.

Evander kept his eyes on the field. "He's their biological father."

"Does that mean you're fake?"

Evander looked at him. "No."

"Then why does everybody say real?"

"Because adults use lazy words when relationships are complicated."

Lucan leaned over. "Dad's Dad. Warren's also Dad."

Orien considered that.

"That's confusing."

"A little," Evander admitted.

After the game, Caelan ran toward them, flushed with pride after scoring the final goal. He hugged Warren first.

Evander felt the reaction before he could stop it: a small tightening in his chest.

Then Caelan turned and hugged him too.

"Did you see the goal?"

"Every second."

Warren approached with a smile that did not reach his eyes.

"Hale."

"Warren."

"Appreciate you keeping my seat warm."

Seraphine, coming up behind him, closed her eyes.

Evander felt Orien stiffen beside him.

He could have answered. There were dozens of sharp responses available. Instead he looked at Caelan.

"Great game. We'll see you tomorrow at ten."

Warren frowned. "Tomorrow?"

"Sunday visit," Seraphine said.

"With him?"

"Yes."

"Why?"

Caelan answered before anyone else.

"Because I want to."

The adults went quiet.

On the drive home, Orien stared out the window.

"Warren doesn't like you."

"Seems possible."

"Are you mad Caelan hugged him first?"

Evander gripped the steering wheel.

Children noticed everything adults hoped they had hidden.

"I felt something for a second," he admitted. "But Caelan doesn't owe me first place."

Orien turned toward him.

"What if I like Mom's boyfriend someday?"

Evander knew he meant Elise, his biological mother, who lived forty minutes away and had recently started seeing someone named Nathan.

"Then I hope he's good to you."

"You won't be jealous?"

"I might feel jealous. Feelings happen. What matters is what I do with them."

Orien looked down at his hands.

"Seraphine had feelings too."

Evander nodded slowly.

"Yes."

"So why is she bad for doing stuff because of them?"

"She isn't a bad person. She made choices that hurt you. Those are different things."

Orien was quiet until they pulled into the townhouse garage.

Then he said, "I think I made her mad."

Evander turned off the engine.

"How?"

"I always wanted you when I got sick. And I asked you to come to my games. Maybe she thought Caelan and Lucan didn't get enough."

"That was not your job to manage."

"But maybe if I needed less -"

"Stop."

Evander's voice was gentle but firm.

Orien looked up.

"You are not responsible for making adults fair by becoming smaller. You are not responsible for my marriage. You are not responsible for Seraphine's resentment. You are not responsible for Caelan and Lucan's relationship with me."

Orien's eyes filled.

"Then who is?"

"The adults. Me included."

That evening, Orien asked to call Seraphine.

Evander hesitated only long enough to make sure the request was truly his.

She answered on the second ring.

"Hi, Orien."

His voice shook. "I'm sorry if I took Dad away from Caelan and Lucan."

Evander closed his eyes.

There was silence on the line.

Then Seraphine said, very clearly, "No. You did not. I need you to hear me. You did nothing wrong. I was angry about things your dad and I should have handled together, and I treated you unfairly. That was my choice. Not yours."

Orien wiped his cheek.

"Are you mad at me?"

"No."

"Do you hate me?"

Seraphine's breath caught.

"No. I am ashamed that I made you wonder that."

Evander stepped into the hallway to give them privacy.

He heard no dramatic reconciliation. No promise that everything would return to normal.

They talked about school.

Seraphine asked about his science project. Orien told her the volcano had collapsed before the vinegar went in. She laughed softly.

When the call ended, Orien found Evander in the hallway.

"She said sorry."

"How do you feel?"

Orien rolled his eyes. "Dr. Park said you ask that too much."

Evander laughed.

"Fair."

Orien walked past him toward the kitchen.

"I'm hungry."

It was the first time Evander heard those words as a victory.

Before Orien called Seraphine, he spoke with Elise.

They were walking through a grocery store when he asked, "Would you be mad if I forgive her?"

Elise stopped beside a shelf of cereal.

"No."

"Even though she was mean to me?"

"Forgiving her would be about what you need, not what I need."

"Dad says I don't have to."

"He's right."

Orien put a box of cereal into the cart.

"What if I forgive her and then she does it again?"

Elise pushed the cart slowly.

"Then forgiveness doesn't mean you have to keep trusting her. Those are different things."

"That's confusing."

"Most useful things are."

At checkout, Orien asked whether Elise hated Seraphine.

She took longer to answer.

"I hated what she did. I was angry enough that for a few days I wanted to hate her. But if I make her into a monster, then you have to decide whether all the good memories you have with her were fake. I don't think that's fair to you."

Orien looked relieved.

"The aquarium wasn't fake."

"No."

"She stayed with me when I threw up."

"You have told me that six times."

"It was a lot of throw up."

May you like

Elise laughed despite herself.

The conversation helped Orien make the phone call later, not because his mother gave permission to forgive, but because she gave him permission not to divide every adult into good and bad before he could decide what he felt.

Related Stories

Other posts