scribe

Chapter 22 - WHAT COUNTS AS A CHOICE

Judge Mercer met with Isolde privately on Wednesday afternoon.

Mavis sat in the room. A court reporter did not.

The judge explained that this was not a secret vote and that Isolde would not be asked to select a winner.

“I already told Mavis I want both,” Isolde said.

“I know.”

Judge Mercer wore no robe in chambers. That helped.

“What I want to understand,” she said, “is what makes a choice feel like your choice.”

Isolde considered the question.

“When I know what I’m choosing.”

The judge nodded.

“What else?”

“When I can say no and the person doesn’t punish me.”

Another nod.

“When they don’t tell me something bad will happen if I don’t answer fast.”

“Anything else?”

Isolde looked toward Mavis, then back.

“When nobody is sad at me for loving the other person.”

Judge Mercer wrote something down.

“Do you want to move to London?”

“No.”

“Do you want your father to turn down his job because you said no?”

Isolde’s face tightened.

“I don’t want to decide his job.”

“Good. You do not have to.”

“Could he go without me?”

“Yes.”

The answer frightened her.

Judge Mercer saw it.

“That possibility is not a punishment,” she said. “Adults sometimes make choices that change how families spend time. If your father chooses a job elsewhere, the adults will make a plan for contact. You are not responsible for choosing his career.”

Isolde looked down.

“What if he goes because I don’t want London?”

“Then he goes because he decides the job is right for him even though you do not want to relocate. Those are two separate choices.”

Isolde nodded slowly.

The separation mattered.

For weeks every adult decision had seemed to attach itself to her answer.

Sign, and the family could move.

Refuse, and the job might disappear.

Live with Dad, and maybe keep the room.

Live with Mom, and maybe lose something else.

Judge Mercer was telling her adults were capable of owning their side of a consequence.

Before Isolde left, she asked one question.

“Are you mad at Dad?”

The judge folded her hands.

“My job is not to be mad at him. My job is to decide what arrangements protect your interests and what rules the adults must follow.”

“So you don’t pick who’s good?”

“No.”

Isolde stood.

May you like

That answer disappointed the part of her that wanted a clean story.

It comforted the part of her that knew clean stories were often where adults hid the missing paragraphs.

Related Stories

Other posts