scribe

Chapter 12 - BOTH

Mavis asked Isolde one question three different ways.

“If the adults stopped asking you to protect their feelings, what would you want?”

Isolde frowned.

“I already said I want both.”

“I know. I want to understand what both means to you.”

They sat in a small child-interview room with two armchairs, a low bookshelf, and a box of colored pencils nobody had touched.

Isolde thought.

“It means I want school to stay the same.”

Mavis wrote that down.

“I want to sleep at Mom’s and Dad’s. I don’t want them changing days because they’re mad.”

Another note.

“I want Dad to stop asking me what Mom says about court.”

Mavis looked up. “Has he done that?”

“Before.”

“How often?”

Isolde shrugged. “Sometimes after pickup. He’d say, ‘Did your mother tell you why she wants Friday?’ Or, ‘Did she tell you what she filed?’”

“Did your mother do that too?”

Isolde took longer.

“Sometimes she asked if Dad talked about London.”

Mavis nodded. “How did that feel?”

“Like there was a right answer.”

“What else does both mean?”

Isolde looked at the carpet.

“I don’t want Seraphine gone.”

Mavis’s pen paused.

“Even after the document?”

“She did something bad. That doesn’t mean I want her erased.”

“Okay.”

“I want her to stop acting like Mom is temporary.”

Mavis wrote slowly.

“And London?”

“No.”

The answer was immediate.

“You do not want to move to London?”

“No.”

“Would you want to visit?”

“Yes. Maybe. With a real return ticket.”

Mavis’s mouth twitched.

“Anything else?”

Isolde took a breath.

“If Dad wants the job, I don’t want him to say I made him lose it.”

Mavis stopped writing.

“Has he said that?”

“No.”

“Are you afraid he will?”

“Yes.”

That sentence appeared in Mavis’s report not as evidence against Aurelian, but as a warning to every adult.

The child was beginning to anticipate being made responsible for adult sacrifices.

Judge Mercer read the report in silence.

At the next status conference, she addressed both parents.

“I am going to say this once. Neither of you will tell this child that she cost you a job, a home, a marriage, money, court time, or access to the other parent. Those are adult consequences of adult decisions.”

Aurelian’s jaw tightened.

Amaris nodded.

Judge Mercer looked at him specifically.

“Mr. Valemont, do you understand?”

“Yes.”

“And Ms. Duvall?”

“Yes.”

Isolde did not hear the order directly.

Mavis told her afterward only, “The judge made sure no one is allowed to make you responsible for what happens with the London job.”

Isolde’s whole body seemed to soften.

She had not realized she had been bracing for that sentence until someone promised it would not be hers to carry.

The phrase “overthink” became another point of tension between Isolde and Aurelian.

At their next visit she asked him directly, “Do you think I overthink?”

He sighed. “Sometimes.”

“What does that mean?”

“You can get stuck on details.”

“Like the sentence I found?”

“That detail mattered.”

“So which details don’t?”

Aurelian rubbed the back of his neck.

“I don’t have a good answer.”

Isolde crossed her arms.

“When adults say I overthink, it usually means I’m still asking after they want me to stop.”

Aurelian looked at Mavis.

Mavis did not save him.

He turned back to his daughter.

“That may be true with me.”

“Why?”

“Because questions slow down plans.”

“And you like plans.”

“Yes.”

“So maybe I don’t overthink. Maybe you over-rush.”

Mavis looked down to hide a smile.

Aurelian stared at Isolde for a second, then laughed once.

“That is annoyingly possible.”

Isolde did not smile immediately.

“Don’t make it a joke if you mean it.”

His expression changed.

May you like

“I mean it.”

That distinction—between laughing because a truth was uncomfortable and laughing so the truth no longer had to matter—was another thing he was learning late.

Related Stories

Other posts