Chapter 25 - CELESTE’S LAST WITNESS

Naomi Redd was seventy-three and lived in a small stone house near Bath surrounded by roses she claimed to hate pruning.
For eight years she had been the external accountant for the Vane Foundation.
Then she retired.
When Miriam called to ask about Celeste’s concerns, Naomi became quiet.
“I wondered whether this day would come,” she said.
Lucian traveled to see her with Gideon.
Naomi brought out a document box before they had finished tea.
Inside were old audit notes, correspondence, and one sealed envelope with Celeste’s handwriting.
Lucian stared at it.
The envelope was addressed to Naomi.
It had been opened years ago.
“I received that two days before Celeste went into hospital,” Naomi said. “She sent copies of invoices and asked me to review them privately.”
“Did you?”
“Yes.”
“What did you find?”
“Enough to be concerned. Not enough to accuse anyone without more work.”
“What happened next?”
Naomi looked ashamed.
“Adrian called.”
Lucian already knew he would hate the answer.
“He said Celeste was ill and had become anxious about routine accounting matters. He told me Lucian wanted the issue handled internally to avoid adding to her stress.”
“I never said that.”
“I know now.”
“Why didn’t you call me?”
“You had a wife in hospital and a baby at home. Adrian was your chief financial officer. I believed him.”
The same sentence in different mouths.
I believed him.
I believed her.
Trust had been the weapon because trust had been abundant.
Naomi handed Lucian Celeste’s note.
It was brief.
Naomi,
Please verify Bellmere, Hart & Fen, and the restoration payments. Adrian says the overlap is administrative. I think it is deliberate. Vespera Corvin appears connected to Bellmere beyond what she disclosed. Do not discuss this with Adrian until you have independent records.
C.
Beneath the signature was one more line.
If I have misunderstood, I will apologize to both of them gladly.
Lucian traced the sentence with his eyes.
That was Celeste exactly. Careful even in suspicion.
Naomi removed another paper from the box.
“This is why I kept everything.”
It was a memo Adrian sent after Celeste’s funeral.
The matter raised by Celeste has been reviewed and resolved. No further action is required. Please archive related correspondence.
Naomi tapped the page.
“I never completed the review.”
Gideon looked at her. “Did Adrian know that?”
“Yes.”
“Then his statement was false.”
“Yes.”
The timeline was finally intact.
Celeste raised concerns.
Naomi began checking.
Celeste became ill.
Adrian halted the inquiry by falsely claiming the matter had been resolved.
Vespera possessed at least one copy of Celeste’s private notes after her death.
Years later, Vespera married Lucian.
The suspicious payment structure continued.
And when Lucian blocked the property sale that could benefit Adrian and Vespera, they began building a record designed to remove him from control.
Naomi looked at Lucian for a long moment.
“Your wife was trying to protect the family before any of us understood there was something to protect it from.”
Lucian swallowed.
He had feared Celeste’s notebook would lead him into a darker mystery about her death.
Instead it gave him something gentler and more painful.
Proof that she had been herself until the end—careful, skeptical, fair.
Naomi also remembered meeting Vespera once in Celeste’s final month. Vespera arrived at the foundation office claiming she needed copies of vendor contracts for an event reconciliation. Naomi thought the request odd because the event department already had those records. When Naomi asked which contracts, Vespera specifically named Bellmere.
At the time Naomi assumed Vespera was being thorough.
Now the memory acquired weight, but Gideon again kept it in its proper place. Naomi’s recollection was old and unrecorded. It supported context; it did not become proof by repetition.
Before Lucian left, Naomi apologized once more for accepting Adrian’s instruction to close the review.
Lucian surprised himself by saying, “I’m not asking everyone who trusted him to become guilty for what he did with that trust.”
Naomi looked at him for a long time.
“Then remember to include yourself in that sentence.”
He had no answer.
On the drive home, Celeste’s note lay in Gideon’s document case between them. Lucian thought about how many people had been manipulated through virtues rather than weaknesses: Naomi through professional trust, Lena through fear of harming Eulalie’s stability, Seraphine through respect for grief, Lucian through loyalty and his desire to keep family pain private.
May you like
Vespera and Adrian had not succeeded because everyone around them was foolish. They succeeded because decent assumptions can be exploited by people who know where those assumptions live.
And proof that the people she questioned had spent years counting on everyone else’s grief to bury the questions with her.