Chapter 16 - THE COPY

Adrian moved faster than anyone expected.
He bent to retrieve the fallen page.
Gideon reached it first.
For one second the two men faced each other across the edge of the boardroom table, neither touching the paper.
Then Harriet Vale said, “Leave it where it is.”
Adrian straightened.
“It is a company record.”
Lucian looked down at the photocopy.
He recognized Celeste’s handwriting immediately.
The visible lines were from the entry dated twelve days before her death.
I confronted Adrian today. He denied directing the Bellmere payments and said the vendor structure was approved by staff below him. I do not believe him.
Lucian raised his eyes.
“Where did you get this?”
Adrian’s expression settled into professional irritation.
“Celeste raised concerns years ago. Some of her notes were copied into an internal review file.”
Miriam leaned forward. “Which review?”
“I would have to check.”
“You were chief financial officer. You cannot identify an internal review involving accusations against you?”
Adrian’s jaw tightened.
Harriet asked again, “Where did you get the page?”
“I said, from archived materials.”
Gideon carefully slid the photocopy into a transparent folder supplied by Miriam.
“The original notebook was found last night in a private piano bench at Vane House,” he said. “It has never been part of the company archive to our knowledge.”
Adrian gave a small shrug. “Then Celeste must have copied pages separately.”
Lucian might have accepted that explanation once.
Now he studied the paper instead of Adrian.
A handwritten arrow appeared in the lower margin. Next to it Celeste had written:
Ask G. before speaking to Lucian. He will confront A immediately.
Lucian’s heart slowed.
Gideon saw it too.
Celeste had written “Ask G.”
Gideon.
But Gideon had never seen the notebook or that entry.
If Celeste had intended to show him and died before doing so, the copy could not have come through him.
Miriam asked Adrian to produce the archive file from which he claimed the page had been copied.
“Of course,” he said.
But he did not sound confident.
The meeting ended with Adrian temporarily removed from operational access pending review. He left without looking at Lucian.
In the corridor outside, Harriet caught Lucian’s arm.
“I owe you an apology,” she said.
“For what?”
“For seeing the photograph and believing I understood the story around it.”
Lucian looked at her.
“You saw something that actually happened. I hit her.”
“Yes.” Harriet did not soften. “And that still matters.”
“I know.”
“What I should not have done was assume it explained everything else.”
Lucian nodded.
That distinction mattered to him now. He did not want innocence manufactured from Vespera’s guilt. He wanted the truth intact, even where it made him ashamed.
Back at Vane House, he and Gideon finished reading Celeste’s final entries.
The notebook described no fear for her life. No mysterious illness. No accusation of physical danger.
It described financial suspicion.
It described Adrian’s evasions.
And it described Vespera.
Three days after confronting Adrian, Celeste wrote:
Vespera asked whether I had shown Lucian anything. I told her the accounts were none of her concern. She smiled and said, “Everything becomes someone’s concern eventually.” I disliked the answer more than I can explain.
Lucian read the sentence again.
Then he turned the page.
The next entry was short.
I have hidden this notebook because I am tired of wondering who enters my study. If I am wrong, I will feel foolish later. If I am right, at least one record will remain where neither of them thinks to look.
Neither of them.
Celeste had linked Adrian and Vespera years ago.
The final line was underlined once.
The piano is the only place Vespera never goes.
Lucian closed the notebook.
Yet Adrian possessed a copy.
Miriam later examined the photocopy and found that it came from an older office machine, consistent with equipment used at the foundation years earlier. That did not reveal who copied it, but it narrowed the possibilities. The page had not been produced recently from Lucian’s newly found notebook. Someone had copied Celeste’s private writing long before the board meeting.
Gideon asked the company archive team for every file Adrian claimed might contain Celeste’s notes. No matching review file appeared. There were references to an “accounting concern” closed after her death, but no notebook pages attached.
Adrian’s explanation became thinner.
Lucian resisted the urge to call him a liar publicly. He had learned that letting a weak story remain visible could be more useful than attacking it too early.
That night, he placed Celeste’s original notebook beside a photograph of her holding newborn Eulalie. He had spent years protecting his memories of Celeste from scrutiny because grief made examination feel disloyal. Now her own writing asked for the opposite. She had wanted questions followed.
May you like
He wondered whether love could include revisiting the dead without idealizing them. Celeste had been careful, sometimes anxious, occasionally stubborn. She had also noticed what everyone else missed. By writing down uncertainty instead of pretending certainty, she had left Lucian a path that remained trustworthy years later.
Which meant at some point, somehow, the hiding place had ceased to be secret.