Chapter 9 - THE ROOM QUESTION

Finnian returned to the new house a week later.
Evadne met him at the door.
Cassiel stayed in the kitchen.
The pale green room had changed.
The crib catalog was gone.
The baby blanket sample was gone.
A mattress leaned against the wall.
Evadne said:
“I want to make this your room.”
Finnian stared.
“Because I asked?”
“Because it should have been ready.”
“Where will the baby go?”
“If there’s a baby someday, we’ll figure it out.”
Finnian walked into the room.
He touched the wall.
“I don’t want it.”
Evadne froze.
Cassiel looked up from downstairs.
Finnian continued.
“I don’t want the room because I made you feel bad.”
“It’s not because—”
“Yes, it is.”
Evadne stopped.
He was right partly.
That was enough.
“What do you want?”
Finnian shrugged.
“I don’t know.”
Cassiel came upstairs.
“We can pick another room.”
Finnian looked at him.
“Why didn’t you ask before?”
Cassiel had no answer that did not sound terrible.
Because he thought the child would adapt.
Because he prioritized the baby plan.
Because he believed love could compensate later.
Evadne sat on the floor.
Finnian did too.
Cassiel remained standing.
Finnian asked:
“If I pick a room, does that mean the townhouse sells?”
Cassiel’s face tightened.
There it was.
The room was not just a room.
It was attached to property.
Money.
Custody.
Future inheritance.
Evadne looked sharply at Cassiel.
“You told him?”
“He deserves to know.”
“Yes. Before asking him to choose a bedroom.”
Cassiel sat down.
Finnian looked between them.
“Can I have both?”
“The houses?”
“Yes.”
“For now,” Cassiel said.
“What about later?”
“I don’t know.”
Finnian nodded.
“I want that answer more.”
Cassiel looked at him.
“More than what?”
“More than when you say something like you know.”
The child had learned to prefer uncertainty over false reassurance.
That was an indictment no legal document could improve.
Finnian visited the pale green room alone several times before deciding he did not want it.
He liked the window.
He disliked what the room meant.
One afternoon, he found Evadne sitting on the floor surrounded by paint samples.
She looked embarrassed.
“I was thinking about changing the color.”
“For me?”
“Maybe.”
Finnian sat across from her.
“Don’t.”
“Why?”
“Then I’ll know you changed the baby room because I got sad.”
Evadne placed the samples down.
“What if I want to make you feel welcome?”
“Ask me stuff.”
“What stuff?”
He shrugged.
“What lamp. What desk. Where my shoes go.”
She smiled sadly.
“Very glamorous.”
Finnian nodded.
“Also snacks.”
“Essential.”
They made a list.
Not room design.
Belonging details.
Toothbrush cup.
Drawer in the kitchen for school things.
Hook near the door for backpack.
Shelf in the bathroom.
Place for shoes.
Evadne realized the house had been prepared for adult life at scale.
Master closet.
Wine refrigerator.
Office.
Guest suites.
But Finnian needed smaller evidence.
A drawer.
A hook.
A cup.
The following week, she installed nothing without asking.
Finnian chose a red hook by the garage door.
It clashed with the house.
Evadne hated it.
She said:
“Perfect.”
He knew she was lying.
They both laughed.
The red hook became his favorite thing in the house.
Not because it was beautiful.
May you like
Because no hypothetical baby had been considered before buying it.
Finnian’s smaller bedroom eventually became the first room in the new house that looked genuinely lived in. Socks under the chair. Books stacked badly. A basketball rolling into the hallway. Evadne almost corrected the mess, then stopped. The pale green nursery remained beautiful and untouched for months. Finnian’s room was less elegant and more real. Cassiel sometimes stood in the doorway and felt relief at the disorder. It meant the house no longer contained only plans.