scribe

Chapter 5 - EVADNE’S VERSION

Evadne came to Imani’s house alone on Monday evening.

Finnian was doing homework at the dining table.

When he saw her, he stiffened.

Imani asked:

“Does Cassiel know you’re here?”

“Yes.”

“Does he approve?”

Evadne’s mouth tightened.

“He doesn’t get to approve where I go.”

Imani almost smiled.

Evadne sat across from Finnian.

“I owe you an apology.”

He looked at his worksheet.

“For what?”

“For what I said in the dressing room.”

“You said I’m a mistake.”

“I said something cruel.”

“Same thing.”

She accepted that.

“Yes.”

Finnian finally looked at her.

“Do you think I’m a mistake?”

Evadne answered immediately.

“No.”

“Then why say it?”

She took a breath.

“Because I was angry at your father.”

“About me.”

“About what he wasn’t telling me.”

Finnian frowned.

“What?”

“The house. The trust. Where you were supposed to live after the wedding.”

Imani looked up.

Evadne continued.

“Cassiel told me you would mostly stay at the townhouse with Grandma nearby during the school week.”

Finnian stared.

“He told you that?”

“Yes.”

“He told me I’d live with you.”

Evadne closed her eyes.

“I know.”

The betrayal shifted shape.

Cassiel had not simply failed to prepare a room.

He had told two people different futures.

Finnian whispered:

“Why?”

Evadne looked at Imani, then back at him.

“I think he was afraid if he told either of us the full plan, one of us would say no.”

Finnian considered.

“So he wanted yes before truth.”

Imani looked at him, surprised.

Evadne nodded slowly.

“Yes.”

He returned to his worksheet.

For several minutes nobody spoke.

Then Finnian asked:

“What did you mean by new family?”

Evadne’s face tightened.

“I meant the marriage.”

“And old mistake?”

She looked ashamed.

“I meant how your father and Nyra had you before they were ready.”

Imani’s expression hardened.

“Finnian is not the mistake inside that sentence.”

“I know.”

“Do you?”

Evadne met her eyes.

“I do now.”

Finnian looked between them.

He did not understand why adults needed to nearly break something before recognizing the wording mattered.

Evadne continued:

“I thought Cassiel kept changing plans because he felt guilty about Nyra.”

“He should feel guilty?”

“No.”

“Then why?”

She paused.

“I was jealous of a life that existed before me.”

Finnian stared.

“Mom is dead.”

“I know.”

“That seems stupid.”

Evadne laughed once despite herself.

“It was.”

That was the first honest thing she said that made Finnian believe the apology might be real.

Evadne stayed at Imani’s house for nearly two hours.

Finnian eventually finished homework.

Then he brought out an old photo album.

“You want to see Mom?”

Evadne looked surprised.

“Yes.”

Imani watched from the kitchen but did not interfere.

Finnian opened the album.

Nyra holding him as a newborn.

Nyra at the beach.

Nyra wearing a yellow coat.

Nyra and Cassiel at a street festival.

Evadne felt something ugly rise inside her.

Not hatred.

Displacement.

These photographs documented a version of Cassiel who had loved before her.

She hated that she still reacted.

Finnian saw her face.

“You’re doing the weird thing.”

“What weird thing?”

“When Mom is in pictures.”

Evadne swallowed.

“I’m sorry.”

“You don’t like her.”

“I never knew her.”

“That’s not no.”

He was relentless without trying to be.

Evadne closed the album.

“I was jealous.”

“Of Mom?”

“Yes.”

“She’s dead.”

“I know.”

Finnian frowned as if this made jealousy logically impossible.

Evadne wished adulthood worked that way.

“I thought when your dad married me, I would finally stop feeling like I was joining a story already written.”

Finnian looked down at the album.

“Did you want a new story?”

“Yes.”

“Without me?”

Evadne’s chest tightened.

“No.”

“Then why did you call the old story a mistake?”

She took time.

“Because I wanted the past to stop competing with me.”

Finnian thought.

“Was I competing?”

“No.”

“But I was in the past.”

“Yes.”

“So?”

Evadne had no escape.

She had emotionally grouped Finnian with the history she wanted Cassiel to resolve.

Not because she wished the child gone.

Because she had not separated a living person from the grief and guilt attached to his origin.

“That was wrong.”

Finnian nodded.

Imani brought tea.

No one needed Evadne to become innocent.

Only honest.

Before leaving, Evadne asked:

“Can I see that picture again?”

“The yellow coat?”

“Yes.”

Finnian handed it over.

Nyra looked ordinary.

Windblown.

Laughing.

Not a ghost.

Not a rival.

Just a woman who had once existed fully.

Evadne returned the photograph.

“She looks happy.”

“She was.”

Finnian paused.

“Sometimes.”

Imani looked at him.

“Exactly.”

The word loosened something in Evadne.

May you like

Nyra did not need to become perfect for Evadne to respect the space she occupied in Finnian’s life.

Before Evadne left, Finnian asked one last question. “If Dad told you I was going to Grandma’s a lot, did you want that?” She answered carefully. “At first, yes.” He looked hurt. She continued. “Not because I didn’t want you. Because I thought it would make moving easier.” “For me?” Evadne paused. “Mostly for me.” Finnian nodded. He preferred that answer. Comfort designed around adults but described as helping children had become another pattern he could recognize. Evadne hated that he needed the skill.

Related Stories

Other posts