Chapter 5 - Cassia Faced the First Question No One Else Could Answer for Her

Three days after the clinic visit, Cassia sat across from the school counselor, Ms. Avery, and tried to explain what she wanted from the rest of senior year.
It was the first conversation about the pregnancy that did not begin with paternity.
That alone felt like relief.
Ms. Avery was direct but kind. She explained attendance options, prenatal accommodations, graduation planning, and how to handle rumors if Cassia’s pregnancy became visible before school ended.
“Your education is still yours,” she said. “Pregnancy changes logistics. It does not erase your future.”
Cassia had not realized how badly she needed to hear that.
At home, Janine had begun overcompensating in the opposite direction. She checked vitamins. Read nutrition articles aloud. Asked if Cassia felt sick every forty minutes. The care was loving and exhausting.
“You can breathe,” Cassia finally told her one night.
Janine looked offended. “I am breathing.”
“No. You’re monitoring.”
Her mother stopped.
Then, surprisingly, she laughed.
“Fair.”
They sat at the kitchen table together afterward with a bowl of sliced apples between them.
“Do you want to keep the baby?” Janine asked.
Cassia stared at her.
The question had been hovering around every adult conversation but never asked so plainly.
“I think so.”
“Think or know?”
Cassia looked down. “Know. I’m scared, but yes.”
Janine nodded slowly. “Then we plan around that.”
Cassia felt both relieved and terrified.
Later that evening, Nico texted.
Can we talk?
She stared at the message for several minutes before replying: yes.
They met at a small park near their neighborhood, sitting on opposite ends of a bench beneath trees just beginning to turn.
Nico looked tired.
“So,” he said.
“So.”
He rubbed his palms together. “I don’t even know where to start.”
“Neither do I.”
He looked at her finally. “Did you love him?”
Cassia’s stomach twisted.
“No.”
“Did you love me?”
She looked down. “Yes.”
“Then why?”
There it was. The impossible question. The one she had been asking herself in quieter language ever since June.
“I felt ignored,” she said finally. “Not by you exactly. By everything. You were gone. My mom was working all the time. Malik was around and listened to me. Then it got confusing.”
Nico stared at the ground. “So being listened to became this?”
“I’m not defending it.”
“Good.”
She swallowed. “I knew it was wrong.”
“After?”
“Before too.”
That hurt him visibly.
Cassia let the silence stay.
“I’m sorry,” she said.
Nico’s eyes remained on the gravel path. “I know you are.”
She waited.
“I don’t know if I can still be your boyfriend,” he said.
Tears rose in her eyes, but she nodded. “I understand.”
“I also don’t know if I’m the father.”
“I know.”
“And if I am…” He stopped.
Cassia looked at him. “Then we figure it out.”
Nico shook his head. “No. We figure out being parents. That’s not the same as figuring us out.”
The distinction hurt because it was mature.
Cassia nodded again.
For the first time, they separated pregnancy from relationship.
It did not make anything easier.
It made things clearer.
That night after meeting Nico in the park, Cassia sat on the bathroom floor with her back against the tub and cried silently into the sleeve of her cardigan.
She did not cry because Nico had said he might not be her boyfriend anymore. Not only because of that.
She cried because for months she had secretly believed confession would produce a clean punishment. Nico would hate her. Janine would be furious. Odessa would reject her. Malik would become the obvious villain. She would know exactly where to place herself in the wreckage.
Instead everybody remained complicated.
Nico was hurt and still concerned about her appointments.
Janine was disappointed and still brought her tea.
Odessa was furious with both sons and still spoke to Cassia as if her future remained intact.
Malik had done harm and was still a person Cassia once trusted.
Complexity was harder than condemnation because it required Cassia to keep living as someone more than the worst thing she had done.
Janine found her twenty minutes later.
She sat on the closed toilet lid without asking questions at first.
Finally she said, “Was the conversation bad?”
Cassia wiped her face. “Honest.”
“Sometimes that feels worse.”
“He said he doesn’t know if he can still be my boyfriend.”
Janine nodded slowly. “That makes sense.”
Cassia stared at her mother. “You’re supposed to say he’ll come around.”
“No. I’m supposed to help you survive whatever truth exists, not sell you a prettier one.”
Cassia leaned her head back against the tub.
“I hate myself.”
Janine’s face changed.
“No.”
“I do.”
“You hate what you did. Those are different sentences, and you need to stop using them like they mean the same thing.”
Cassia’s eyes filled again.
“What if everybody always sees me as the girl who did this?”
“Some people will.”
“That’s terrible advice.”
“It’s honest advice.” Janine leaned forward. “Other people will watch what you do next. More importantly, you will.”
Cassia looked down at her hands.
Janine continued, “Shame likes to sound moral. It tells you that if you punish yourself hard enough, you’re taking responsibility. Most of the time you’re just making yourself too small to do any actual repair.”
Cassia swallowed.
“So what does repair look like?”
“Right now? Doctor appointments. Telling the truth. Finishing school. Respecting Nico’s anger. Respecting your own boundaries. Not making your pregnancy a referendum on whether you deserve a future.”
Cassia sat quietly.
Then she said, “That sounds harder than hating myself.”
Janine gave a tired smile. “Most useful things are.”
They stayed in the bathroom until Cassia’s breathing settled.
Before bed, she opened the journal Ms. Avery had suggested and wrote one line across the first page:
I am responsible for what I did, but I am not required to become only that.
May you like
She stared at it for a long time.
Then she closed the book and slept better than she expected.
Related Stories