scribe

Chapter 25 - Cassia and Nico Tried One Date and Discovered That Love Had Changed Too Much to Resume on Old Terms

In February, nearly seven months after Amaya’s birth, Nico asked Cassia to dinner.

Not to “talk.”

Not as co-parents.

A date.

He made that explicit, which impressed Cassia enough to say yes.

Janine watched Amaya. Odessa threatened Nico with bodily embarrassment if he came home too late and then clarified she was joking when he gave her a look.

They went to a small burger place they used to visit after basketball games.

The familiarity was both comforting and dangerous.

For the first twenty minutes they laughed easily. Nico told a story about a classmate who installed a brake assembly backward in lab. Cassia described a professor who used the phrase “circle back” fourteen times in one online lecture.

Then silence arrived.

Not bad silence.

The kind that asks what the evening means.

Nico looked at her. “Do you think we could do this again?”

Cassia took a sip of lemonade. “Dinner?”

“You know what I mean.”

She did.

She looked down at the table. “I don’t know.”

His face tightened but he waited.

“I care about you,” she said. “I never stopped. But there’s part of me that worries if we get back together, we’ll tell ourselves the baby means the relationship survived when really we never rebuilt it.”

Nico nodded slowly.

“That’s fair.”

“And I worry you’ll always wonder if I’m comparing you to Malik.”

His jaw tightened slightly. “I do wonder.”

“I know.”

He looked out the window.

“Do you compare us?”

Cassia answered carefully. “Not the way you mean. I compare how I felt around both of you sometimes. Not who was better. More what I was looking for.”

Nico looked back at her.

“What were you looking for?”

“To feel seen.”

He absorbed that.

“And with me?”

“I loved you. But we were both immature. We assumed love meant attention would always take care of itself.”

Nico let out a breath. “That sounds old for seventeen.”

“We got old fast.”

They both smiled sadly.

After dinner they walked to the car.

Nico said, “I still want us.”

Cassia looked at him. “Then want it slowly.”

He laughed softly. “What does that mean?”

“It means don’t ask me for a title because we had one before. Let’s see if who we are now actually fits.”

Nico thought about it.

Then he nodded. “Okay.”

At Janine’s house, Amaya was awake and furious about bedtime. The moment Nico saw her, the date’s emotional intensity rearranged itself around practical life.

He took the baby while Cassia changed into sweatpants.

Within ten minutes they were both trying to soothe her, laughing in exhausted disbelief at how quickly romance had become noise, formula, and a missing pacifier.

At one point Cassia looked at Nico over Amaya’s head and said, “This is probably the least romantic second date in history.”

He smiled. “Still counts.”

Maybe it did.

May you like

Not as proof they were back together.

As proof they could imagine a future without forcing it to look like the past.

Related Stories

Other posts