scribe

Chapter 20 - PEOPLE WITH OPINIONS

The trouble with private family decisions was that families rarely kept them private.

Nadine’s sister Simone learned about the school choice over Sunday brunch.

By dessert, she had opinions.

Simone was three years older than Nadine, successful, affectionate, and incapable of treating an unspoken thought as a permanent condition.

“So let me understand,” she said. “Malcolm can afford Crestmont for Jordan, but Aaliyah might stay at Jefferson?”

Nadine felt herself tense.

Across the table, Malcolm continued cutting his food.

Aaliyah and Jordan were in the den with Simone’s children, safely out of earshot.

“It’s Aaliyah’s choice,” Nadine said.

Simone raised an eyebrow.

“She’s fourteen.”

“She’s choosing between two good programs.”

“Sure, but one has resources the other doesn’t.”

Malcolm set down his fork.

“Jefferson’s magnet program has resources Crestmont doesn’t.”

Simone looked at him.

“You know what I mean.”

“I do. That’s why I’m answering carefully.”

Nadine gave him a warning glance.

Simone leaned back.

“I’m not attacking you, Malcolm. I just know my niece. If one child gets a premium option and the other gets the budget option, kids remember that.”

Nadine felt the old fear return instantly.

Malcolm saw it.

He said, “Jefferson is not a budget version of Aaliyah’s life.”

“I didn’t say her life.”

“You called her school a budget option.”

“Financially, it is.”

“And financially, the public library is cheaper than buying every book. That doesn’t make reading there a lesser experience.”

Simone smiled thinly.

“You always have an analogy.”

“Occupational hazard.”

Nadine interrupted.

“Simone, we’ve spent weeks on this. Please don’t reduce it to who gets the more expensive thing.”

Her sister’s expression changed.

“I’m trying to protect Aaliyah.”

“I know.”

“Because men say ‘fair’ when they mean they don’t want to spend money.”

Malcolm’s face went still.

Nadine felt anger rise—not at Malcolm, but at the familiarity of Simone’s logic.

A month earlier, she might have agreed.

Now she heard the trap.

“Not this man,” Nadine said.

Simone looked at her.

Nadine continued.

“He offered to cover the remaining tuition if she chooses Crestmont.”

Simone blinked.

“Oh.”

“He also offered to put money toward writing programs, college counseling, technology, and whatever else makes sense if she chooses Jefferson.”

Simone looked at Malcolm.

“Then what were you two fighting about?”

Malcolm answered before Nadine could.

“What my responsibility means and whether responsibility comes with a real place in the family.”

Simone frowned.

Nadine said, “I was asking him to prove he loved us by paying like a father while I had spent years reminding him he was only a stepfather when parenting got uncomfortable.”

Simone stared at her.

“You said that?”

“More than once.”

“And you’re admitting this in front of him?”

Malcolm almost smiled.

Nadine did.

“Yes.”

Simone sat back.

“Well. I hate when people grow because it ruins my argument.”

The tension broke.

Later, while Malcolm helped carry plates to the kitchen, Simone stopped him.

“For what it’s worth, I wasn’t trying to insult you.”

“I know.”

“I’ve watched Nadine do everything alone before.”

“I know that too.”

“She’s going to overreact sometimes when something feels like Aaliyah is being left behind.”

Malcolm rinsed a plate.

“I understand the reason.”

“But?”

“But understanding a reason doesn’t make every reaction fair.”

Simone nodded.

“That sounds like something she needs.”

“So do I.”

Simone smiled.

“You two are annoyingly functional.”

“We were nearly divorced by a tuition statement three weeks ago.”

She laughed.

“You weren’t nearly divorced.”

“No. But we were definitely going to ruin a perfectly good dining table with paperwork.”

From the den came Aaliyah’s laughter.

Nadine stood in the doorway watching her daughter.

May you like

For once, the fact that other people had opinions did not make her question the work she and Malcolm had done.

That was progress too.

Related Stories

Other posts