Chapter 2 - THE SCORECARD

Malcolm slept badly.
At 2:14 in the morning, he opened his eyes and found Nadine facing the opposite wall. A thin line of moonlight cut across the bedroom carpet. Her breathing was slow, but he could not tell whether she was asleep.
He almost spoke.
Instead, he stared at the ceiling.
Marriage, he had learned, was full of invisible accounting. Not only money. Effort. Loyalty. Sacrifice. Who apologized first. Who remembered birthdays. Who drove farther. Who changed plans. Who gave up more.
Most couples survived because they did not calculate every transaction.
Malcolm worried that he and Nadine had begun calculating.
The next morning, neither mentioned the dining table.
Nadine packed lunch for Aaliyah. Malcolm fried eggs. Jordan arrived from Renee’s house at seven-thirty with his backpack over one shoulder and his uniform tie hanging loose around his neck.
“Morning,” Jordan said.
“Fix the tie,” Malcolm told him.
Jordan rolled his eyes, but fixed it.
Aaliyah came down two minutes later in jeans, a gray school sweatshirt, and white sneakers. She took an apple from the bowl and glanced at Jordan.
“You look like you’re running for office.”
Jordan looked down at his blazer. “And you look like you’re going to sleep in chemistry.”
Aaliyah smirked.
For a few seconds they were only two teenagers living in the same house.
That, Malcolm thought, was the part adults were good at ruining.
Nadine watched them from the kitchen island.
Her eyes went to Jordan’s embroidered school crest.
Malcolm saw it.
So did she know he saw it.
Jordan checked his phone. “Mom’s outside.”
He picked up his bag.
Malcolm frowned. “I thought I was taking you.”
“She has an early meeting near school. She texted me.”
“All right. Love you.”
“Love you too.”
Jordan left.
Aaliyah followed ten minutes later, earbuds in, calling, “Bye!” over her shoulder.
When the front door closed, the kitchen became too quiet.
Nadine wiped the counter although it was already clean.
Malcolm poured coffee.
She said, “Do you know what Aaliyah asked me last week?”
He waited.
“She asked why Jordan’s school has a college counselor for every grade and hers has one counselor for hundreds of kids.”
Malcolm looked at her.
“That’s a fair question.”
“She notices things.”
“I’m sure she does.”
“She notices his class trip is to Washington, D.C. She notices his school has a robotics lab. She notices his blazer costs more than three of her hoodies.”
Malcolm set down the coffee.
“So she did ask about Crestmont?”
Nadine hesitated.
“She asked why he goes there.”
“That’s not the same question.”
“Why are you splitting hairs?”
“Because you said this was about her opportunity. I’m trying to understand what she actually wants.”
Nadine’s jaw shifted.
“She wants to know why one child in this house has access to things the other doesn’t.”
Malcolm’s voice stayed calm.
“And what did you tell her?”
“That adults make choices based on circumstances.”
“That sounds right.”
“She said it sounded like a polite way of saying some kids get more.”
Malcolm sat with that.
Aaliyah was sharp. Too sharp sometimes. She could find the weak seam in an adult explanation and pull until the whole thing opened.
“What are you asking me to do?” he said.
Nadine took a breath.
“I want you to consider Crestmont for her.”
“That’s different from last night.”
“Fine. I’m asking more clearly now.”
“Okay.”
The answer surprised her.
“Okay?”
“I’ll consider it.”
Her shoulders loosened, but only slightly.
“Then why did you say all that last night?”
“Because considering a school with you is one thing. Being told that paying for it proves whether I love you is another.”
Nadine looked down.
Malcolm continued.
“And if I’m going to help make a major decision for Aaliyah, I need to know whether you actually want me involved in major decisions for Aaliyah.”
“This is about education.”
“That’s parenting.”
“It’s also money.”
“Exactly.”
She sighed.
“So what, you want disciplinary rights in exchange for tuition?”
“No.” Malcolm’s voice sharpened for the first time. “I want us to stop talking like family roles are vending machines. Put in money, receive authority. That’s not what I’m saying.”
“Then what are you saying?”
“I’m saying you can’t ask me to function like a full parent only when the part of parenting in front of us has a dollar sign.”
Nadine became still.
Malcolm softened his tone.
“I care about Aaliyah. You know I do.”
“I know.”
“Then stop making me prove it with comparisons.”
She looked toward the hallway where the children had disappeared.
“Maybe I’m not comparing them,” she said. “Maybe I’m comparing what I was able to give before you and what I thought our family would look like after I married you.”
That was the first sentence Malcolm heard that morning that sounded less like an accusation and more like the truth.
He pulled out the chair across from him.
“Sit.”
May you like
Nadine did.
For the first time since the papers hit the table, neither of them was trying to win.