scribe

Chapter 21 - DIFFERENT IS NOT BETTER

Felix asked the question while Thomas was tightening the steering wheel on the slide.

"Was August's treehouse better than my slide?"

Thomas stopped turning the wrench.

August was nearby, sitting under the maple with his robotics notebook open. He heard the question but kept his eyes on the page.

"Better how?" Thomas asked.

Felix shrugged. "Just better."

"They're different."

"But which one was more fun?"

Thomas looked toward August.

This time August knew the glance was not a request for rescue. Thomas was thinking.

"The treehouse was fun because August and I built it together," Thomas said. "The slide is fun because you use it in a different way."

Felix frowned. "So the treehouse was better because you made it."

Thomas sat back on his heels.

"No."

Felix was not satisfied.

"If we build more stuff on my slide, can it be better?"

August looked up now.

The question sounded like competition, but Felix's face held no malice. He wanted to know where his place was in a family history that began before he existed.

Thomas seemed to understand the same thing.

"You don't need a better thing than August had," he said.

Felix picked at a loose thread on his shorts.

"Why?"

"Because his memories don't take anything away from yours."

Felix thought about that.

"Can I have a treehouse too?"

Thomas laughed. "We do not have another tree."

"We have the little one by the fence."

"That tree is thinner than your leg."

Felix inspected his leg as if the comparison might be negotiable.

August smiled.

Later that day, Thomas found August in the garage charging a robot battery.

"Did you hear that conversation?"

"Yeah."

Thomas leaned against the workbench beneath the old board.

"I've been thinking about how much I tried to make sure Felix never felt like he came second."

August looked up.

"He's younger."

"That's not the same as second."

Thomas glanced toward the backyard.

"When he was born, you already had seven years of stories with us. Trips. Holidays. The treehouse. Little routines. Every time he noticed something from before him, I wanted to give him an equivalent."

"Like my red bucket."

"Sometimes."

"My old room decorations."

Thomas nodded.

"And maybe the backyard."

August sat very still.

Thomas continued, "I think I confused making space for him with replacing signs that you were here first."

August considered the sentence.

"Did Mom?"

"Probably in her own way. You'll have to ask her."

"Why didn't you just make new stuff with him?"

Thomas gave a tired smile.

"Because reusing something is faster. Because little kids want what big kids have. Because parents are not nearly as thoughtful in real time as they sound during apologies."

August laughed.

Thomas picked up the small red board from the sandbox edge that Felix had temporarily removed to wash off mud.

"This works because you chose to give it."

"Yeah."

"The slide sign works because it's his."

"Yeah."

Thomas looked at the old door board overhead.

"And that works because I finally stopped trying to make every family object belong to everyone equally."

August tilted his head.

"You were doing that?"

"Sometimes. I thought shared family meant shared ownership."

"Doesn't it?"

"Some things. Not everything."

Thomas pointed toward August's toolbox.

"Your tools are yours. The kitchen table is ours. Felix's stuffed bear is his. The couch is ours. Memory works like that too. Some memories belong to the whole family. Some belong to two people. That doesn't make them secret or unfair."

August looked again at the two names.

"Grandma is in the treehouse story too."

"She lent the ladder."

"But her name isn't on the board."

"Exactly."

August smiled.

That evening, Felix asked August to look through old family photos with him.

They sat on the floor using the tablet.

Felix swiped through images from before he was born.

"You had that green cup?"

"Yeah."

"Where is it?"

"Probably gone."

"You went to the beach without me."

"You didn't exist."

Felix scowled. "Still."

August laughed.

They reached the treehouse album.

Felix stopped at a photograph of August and Thomas burning the names.

"Dad looks younger."

"He was."

"You look tiny."

"I was seven."

Felix studied the image.

"I wish I was there."

August felt something soften.

"I wish you could've seen it."

Felix looked at him.

"Really?"

"Yeah. You would've liked the bucket."

Felix grinned.

"I have the bucket."

"I know."

"And the red board."

"I know."

"So I have treehouse stuff."

August nodded.

"You do."

Felix leaned against his shoulder and swiped to the next photo.

August realized sharing history felt different from surrendering it.

He could tell Felix every story without rewriting who had been there.

He could give him the red bucket without adding his name to an old board.

He could love that Felix had new memories with Thomas without asking whether they were better.

Different was not a ranking.

That was a useful thing for brothers to learn before adults taught them otherwise.

That night Felix asked whether both wooden signs could stay forever. Thomas told him probably not forever; wood weathered, houses changed, people moved. Felix looked alarmed until August said, "We can keep the stories even if something breaks."

Felix considered this and then asked whether stories took up garage space.

"No," August said.

May you like

"Good," Felix replied. "Mom likes those."

From the kitchen Caroline shouted that she had heard him. The boys laughed, and August thought there might finally be enough room in the family for old stories and new ones without measuring which took more space.

Related Stories

Other posts