Chapter 11 - THE PHOTO ON THE REFRIGERATOR

On Monday, Ms. Holloway emailed a photograph from the family-object presentations.
In it, August stood beside the treehouse board with his notebook open. The plank was almost as wide as his shoulders. His face looked serious, not sad, but the empty wall space behind him was obvious because Thomas had left before the presentation.
Caroline printed the photograph and put it on the refrigerator.
August noticed it before breakfast.
"Why'd you print that?"
"I like it."
"Dad isn't in it."
Caroline looked at the picture.
"I know."
"He had to get Felix."
"I know that too."
August poured milk over his cereal.
Caroline said, "A photo can be true without being someone's fault."
He looked at her.
"What does that mean?"
"It means your dad had a good reason to leave. It also means you stood there without him after he promised he'd be there. Both are true."
August sat down.
He did not like how much room that idea created.
Usually, when there was a good reason for something, he considered the feeling solved.
Felix got hurt, so Dad left.
Mom was tired, so she forgot.
Work was busy, so the museum moved.
Good reasons acted like erasers.
Caroline was suggesting they did not have to.
Thomas entered wearing a tie and carrying his coffee.
He saw the photograph.
"That's a nice shot."
Then he stared at it longer.
"I hate that I wasn't there."
August said automatically, "You had to-"
Thomas raised a hand.
"I know why I left. I'm not asking you to make me feel better about it."
August stopped.
Felix climbed onto his chair.
"I had stitches."
"We remember," Caroline said.
"Three."
August coughed into his fist to hide a laugh.
"Four," Felix corrected himself.
Thomas pointed at him. "Three. I signed the form."
Felix looked betrayed by documentation.
The photo stayed on the refrigerator.
Over the next week, August began noticing something strange about pictures.
There were many photographs of Felix doing things.
Felix at soccer.
Felix at preschool graduation.
Felix learning to ride a bike.
Felix wearing his first uniform.
There were many photographs of August too, but more of the recent ones showed him standing next to things rather than doing them.
At family dinners.
Beside birthday cakes.
At school concerts after the performance.
He wondered if that meant anything or if he had simply started avoiding cameras.
On Wednesday, he opened the family photo app on the kitchen tablet and searched his own name.
Caroline had tagged most photographs carefully.
Age seven: treehouse construction. Forty-three photos.
Age eight: lake day. Nineteen photos.
Age nine: science fair. Six photos.
Age ten: school chorus. Four photos.
Age eleven: birthday dinner. Twelve photos.
August stared at the numbers.
Thomas came into the kitchen.
"What are you doing?"
August almost closed the app.
Instead he said, "Looking at pictures."
Thomas set down his keys.
"Of what?"
"Me."
Thomas smiled. "Good-looking kid."
August did not smile back.
Thomas pulled out the chair beside him.
"What's up?"
August showed him the screen.
"There are less every year."
Thomas looked at the folders.
"Huh."
"Felix has a lot."
Thomas scrolled through a few months.
"Your mom takes more pictures than I do."
"I know."
"And you're older. You don't always want us pointing phones at you."
"I know."
Thomas glanced at him.
"But?"
August tapped the science-fair folder.
"There are pictures after things. Not during them."
Thomas opened one.
August stood beside a trifold board holding a ribbon.
"Did we go to this?"
August looked at him.
Thomas's face changed before August answered.
"Mom came at the end."
"Where was I?"
"Felix had swim lessons."
Thomas closed his eyes briefly.
"Right."
August immediately said, "It was the last class before evaluations."
Thomas opened his eyes.
"There you go again."
"What?"
"Giving me the reason before I ask."
August looked down.
"It was a reason."
"Yes. It was."
Thomas rested his forearms on the table.
"Did you want me at the science fair?"
August swallowed.
"Yeah."
Thomas nodded.
"Okay."
August waited for an explanation.
None came.
Thomas simply sat with the answer.
That felt uncomfortable in a new way.
"Are you mad?" August asked.
"At you? No."
"At yourself?"
Thomas smiled faintly. "A little."
August almost said sorry.
He caught himself.
That evening Thomas went through the calendar for the next month.
Not to fill every empty square with August.
To ask what mattered.
"School assembly next Thursday?"
"Not important."
"You sure?"
"Yeah. I'm not in it."
"Robotics open house?"
"I want to go."
Thomas added it.
"End-of-year picnic?"
August shrugged. "Parents don't have to come."
"That's not an answer."
August thought.
"Mom maybe. You don't need to."
Caroline, listening from the sink, said, "I can do that."
They continued.
The process took twelve minutes.
August wondered why it had once seemed impossible.
At the end, Thomas said, "I'm going to miss something again."
August looked at him.
"Probably."
"I don't mean because I don't care. Life happens."
"I know."
"But I don't want you learning that the only way to be easy to love is to need less attendance."
August stared at the calendar.
The sentence embarrassed him because it sounded too close to something private he had never said aloud.
Thomas added, "And I don't want Felix learning the opposite either."
"What's the opposite?"
"That he has to be loud enough to keep us."
August looked toward the living room, where Felix was arguing with a cartoon character on television.
He smiled.
The next morning, the presentation photograph still hung on the refrigerator.
May you like
August did not wish Thomas into it.
He did not need to pretend the empty space was meaningless either.