scribe

Chapter 6

The Father Who Knew Half the Story

Graham Mercer came home from a two-day conference in Philadelphia carrying a suitcase, a paper bag of pastries, and no idea that his family had changed while he was gone.

Maristella met him in the foyer.

One look at her face made him set the suitcase down.

"What happened?"

"Evadne brought someone home."

Graham waited.

"Her boyfriend," Maristella continued. "His name is Caelan Voss."

The color left Graham's face more slowly than it had left hers.

He knew the surname.

Maristella saw it.

"You remember."

Graham closed his eyes.

"Julian's family."

She nodded.

"Caelan is him."

For several seconds Graham did not understand.

Then he did.

"The baby?"

"My son."

He sat on the bottom stair.

Maristella had told him about the child before they married. Not every legal detail, not the names, but enough. She had said she once had a son with a man who died, that the boy had been adopted by relatives, that the separation had not been entirely voluntary. Graham had never pressed for names because Maristella's grief had been physical when the subject arose.

He had thought restraint was kindness.

Now it looked like negligence.

"Where is Evadne?"

"At home."

"And Caelan?"

"Providence, I think."

Graham looked at his wife.

"Are you certain?"

"DNA confirmed it this morning."

He covered his face.

Maristella sat beside him.

"She's pregnant."

Graham's hands dropped.

"No."

The word came out as a father's refusal to reality.

"Nine weeks."

He stood so abruptly the stair creaked.

"Why didn't she call me?"

"Because she doesn't know what to say to either of us."

"I'm her father."

"And I am her mother. That didn't make me safe from her anger."

Graham walked into the living room and back again.

"We should have told her."

Maristella stared at him.

"You told me not to."

He stopped.

The old conversation returned with embarrassing clarity.

Evadne had been thirteen. She had discovered an old hospital bracelet among Maristella's things bearing the name Baby Boy Romano. She had asked who it belonged to.

Maristella had wanted to tell her.

Graham had argued against it.

Not because he wanted to deceive Evadne, he had told himself, but because Maristella did not know where her son was. What would a thirteen-year-old do with the knowledge that she had a missing brother? Search the internet? Contact strangers? Reopen a case everyone had survived?

Wait until she's older, Graham had said.

Older became sixteen. Then college. Then graduation. Then always another reason.

"I was wrong," he said.

Maristella's laugh was exhausted.

"So was I."

Graham drove to Evadne's townhouse without calling first. She almost did not let him in.

"Mom told you."

"Yes."

"How much did you know?"

Graham answered honestly.

"That she had a son. That she lost custody through an adoption she believed was manipulated. I did not know the Voss name until years later when I saw an old envelope, and by then your mother had asked me not to pursue it."

Evadne folded her arms.

"So you knew I had a brother."

"Yes."

"And when I started dating Caelan Voss, you didn't recognize the name?"

Graham's brow furrowed.

"You never told me his surname."

Evadne opened her mouth, then stopped.

She searched her memory.

She had called him Caelan. Her parents knew him only as the man she was seeing. They had not met him. The relationship had begun while Graham and Maristella spent much of the year traveling between Connecticut and Arizona to care for Graham's sick mother. Evadne had postponed introductions repeatedly.

The coincidence was cruel but plausible.

"I should have known enough to warn you that a brother existed," Graham said. "That part is on me."

Evadne looked away.

"I'm tired of adults saying they lied because they loved someone."

"Then don't accept that excuse from us."

She looked back.

Graham stepped farther into the room but kept his distance.

"We were afraid of causing pain. We caused more pain. Intent doesn't erase result."

Evadne's expression trembled.

"Dad, I don't know how to do this."

He did not ask what this meant. Pregnancy. Loss. Family. All of it.

"Then don't do all of it today."

She began to cry.

Graham held out his arms, but waited.

Evadne crossed the room and let him hold her.

It was the first familiar thing that had happened in a week.

Over her shoulder, Graham saw Caelan's jacket still hanging on the dining chair.

May you like

He understood there were some losses no father could repair.

He simply held his daughter while she learned that survival and acceptance were not the same thing.

Related Stories

Other posts