Chapter 2

The Son Maristella Lost
Caelan was the first person to leave the room.
He did not storm out. He did not shout. He walked through the foyer as if he had forgotten where the front door was and found it only by accident.
Evadne followed him onto the porch.
"Caelan."
He stopped at the top step without turning.
The warm afternoon suddenly seemed obscene. A lawn mower buzzed somewhere down the street. A dog barked twice. Ordinary life continued with an efficiency Evadne resented.
"Look at me," she said.
He turned.
His face had changed. It was the same face she had known for a year—the face she had watched asleep beside her, the face that smiled crookedly when embarrassed, the face she had imagined beside hers in wedding photographs.
Now it belonged to a stranger and, somehow, to family.
"Did you know?" he asked.
"What? No."
"Did she ever say she had another child?"
"Never."
"Did your father know?"
"I don't know."
He looked toward the living-room window.
"She recognized me immediately."
"She recognized your father."
Caelan's expression tightened.
"I don't know who my father is."
Evadne blinked.
There were facts about each other they had exchanged in fragments. Caelan had been raised by Sabrina and Thomas Voss in Rhode Island. He knew he had been adopted privately. He had never known the identities of his biological parents. His adoption records had been sealed when he was an infant. It had seemed sad, but distant. A chapter written before he could read.
Until now.
"Come inside," Evadne said.
"I can't."
"We need answers."
"And if she's right?"
Evadne could not answer.
Caelan looked down at her stomach.
She had not begun to show. At nine weeks, the pregnancy existed mostly as fatigue, nausea, and a secret heartbeat they had heard two days earlier at the doctor's office.
He swallowed.
"If she's right, Evadne..."
"Don't."
"We have to say it."
"Not yet."
"We have to."
Her eyes filled. "I said not yet."
He nodded once.
They went back inside separately.
Maristella had sat down on the edge of the sofa. The old album lay open beside her. She seemed twenty years older than she had fifteen minutes earlier.
Evadne remained standing.
"Start at the beginning."
Maristella looked at Caelan.
"Your biological father was Julian Voss."
Caelan's eyes sharpened.
"Voss."
"Yes."
"So my adoptive family—"
"Julian had an older sister named Sabrina."
Caelan sat down abruptly.
Maristella nodded through tears.
"Sabrina Voss."
He stared at the floor.
"My mother."
"Your adoptive mother."
"My mother," he repeated, more firmly.
Maristella flinched but accepted the correction.
"Yes. Your mother."
She took a breath.
At twenty-three, Maristella had been a graduate student. Julian Voss was twenty-five, studying architecture in Boston. They had met at a friend's engagement party, fallen into what she called a reckless, sincere love, and planned to marry after graduation.
Then Maristella became pregnant.
Her parents had reacted as though she had announced a crime.
The Romanos were wealthy, rigid, Catholic in public and ruthless in private. Maristella's father, August Romano, cared less about faith than reputation. Julian came from a respectable but ordinary family. August believed his daughter was throwing away every advantage he had built.
"I refused to give you up," Maristella told Caelan. "I left home before you were born. Julian and I rented a terrible apartment with pipes that knocked all night. We were happy anyway."
"Then what happened?"
Maristella looked toward the photograph.
"Julian died."
Caelan went still.
"How?"
"Car accident. You were eleven months old."
After Julian's death, Maristella had been alone, grieving, financially vulnerable, and estranged from her family. August Romano returned with an offer disguised as rescue. Come home. Finish school. Let the Voss family take the baby temporarily.
"I agreed to temporary guardianship," Maristella said. "I was twenty-four and barely functioning. I thought Sabrina would keep you for six months. Maybe a year."
Her mouth trembled.
"My father turned it into an adoption."
Caelan stared at her.
"You signed nothing?"
"I signed papers. I was told they were guardianship and estate forms. Later, when I tried to get you back, I learned I had signed surrender documents too."
"That's impossible."
"It should have been."
"You could have fought it."
"I did."
For the first time, Maristella's grief sharpened into anger.
"I spent three years fighting it. My father had attorneys. Sabrina had already moved. I was told you were thriving, that removing you would be cruel. Every door I opened had another locked door behind it."
Caelan's voice was low.
"Did Sabrina know you wanted me back?"
Maristella hesitated.
That hesitation answered before her words did.
"I don't know."
Evadne sank into a chair.
"And then you married Dad."
Maristella nodded.
"Four years later."
"Did he know?"
"Graham knew I had lost a son. He knew the adoption had been complicated. I never told him the Voss name because by then I had been warned that any contact might be treated as harassment."
Evadne laughed once, without humor.
"So everyone knew except me."
"I wanted to tell you."
"When? After the wedding?"
"Evadne—"
"After my baby was born?"
Maristella's face folded.
Caelan stood.
"We need proof."
Maristella nodded immediately.
"Yes."
"Not stories. Not photographs."
"DNA."
He looked at Evadne.
She understood what he could not say.
May you like
If Maristella was wrong, their lives could continue.
If she was right, nothing could.