Chapter 17 - Twelve Million Reasons

The Aster Ridge side letter appeared in the special committee’s production on Monday morning.
Elaine called it “the motive document.”
Audrey called it worse.
Under the proposed transaction, ordinary shareholders would receive cash and rollover equity according to their holdings. Brett would receive those proceeds too.
But separately, through a management incentive agreement, he would receive up to twelve million dollars in additional rollover equity and performance units if three conditions were met.
First, he remained chief executive after closing.
Second, the company delivered specified voting control to Aster Ridge without unresolved founder veto rights.
Third, all “legacy founder claims” were released or extinguished.
Audrey read the third condition twice.
“They paid him more if I stopped existing as a governance problem.”
Elaine corrected gently. “They proposed to. We do not have evidence Aster Ridge knew your rights were being falsified.”
“Does that distinction help me emotionally?”
“No.”
Aster Ridge’s lawyers had already taken pains to make their own position clear. They said Brett and company counsel represented that all founder rights had been validly amended years earlier. The fund had required representations and warranties that the cap table was accurate.
If that was true, Brett had not merely deceived Audrey. He may also have placed the company in breach of its proposed sale agreement.
The special committee found something else in the side-letter negotiations.
An email from an Aster Ridge partner to Brett:
We need confirmation that Audrey Finch cannot block the close. Please have company counsel certify.
Brett forwarded the email to Julian Crane with a two-word message.
Fix this.
Four hours later, Julian replied:
We have a path, but I remain concerned about the original 2016 language and enforceability of the 2018 amendment file.
That was the email Julian had referenced under oath.
Two days afterward, the company’s diligence room received the supposedly executed 2018 Amended and Restated Founder Protection Letter bearing Audrey’s copied signature.
Elaine placed the timeline on a whiteboard.
Aster Ridge asks whether Audrey can block.
Brett says fix this.
Julian warns about the original document.
A signed “amendment” appears.
Then the 2021 share repurchase reduces Audrey below the protected threshold.
The transactions had occurred years apart, but the paper trail made them look like stages of the same objective.
“Did Brett create the fake amendment in 2021 or just use it later?” Audrey asked.
“We don’t know yet.”
“Does it matter?”
“Very much.”
At midday, the special committee’s counsel requested to interview Audrey.
Elaine prepared her for two hours.
“Answer only what you know. If you don’t remember, say you don’t remember. Do not improve a story because the improved version feels true.”
Audrey smiled faintly. “You really know how to ruin a revenge fantasy.”
“I’m expensive because I do.”
The interview lasted three and a half hours.
They asked about Audrey’s role in the company, her knowledge of the repurchase, her personal finances in 2021, the home renovation, the Founder Protection Letter, the gala, the brooch, and the state of her marriage.
Audrey answered what she could.
At one point, an investigator asked, “Did Mr. Holloway ever express resentment about your family’s financing?”
Audrey thought of his phone call.
“Yes.”
“When?”
“Repeatedly in general terms over years. Explicitly last Thursday.”
She recounted the statement: Aster Ridge was my chance to finally make the company mine.
The investigator wrote it down without visible reaction.
When the interview ended, Audrey found Micah waiting in Elaine’s reception area with Rachel’s assistant. School had closed early because of a water-main problem, and Audrey had forgotten the schedule change.
“I’m sorry,” she said.
Micah shrugged. “Ms. Brooks has better snacks than your office used to.”
Elaine appeared in the doorway. “That is privileged information.”
Micah almost smiled.
On the drive home, he asked, “Is Dad going to jail?”
Audrey’s hands tightened on the wheel.
“Why are you asking?”
“Someone at school said he committed fraud.”
“I don’t know what will happen. Right now there are civil investigations and lawsuits. No one should tell you they know the ending.”
“Do you want him to go to jail?”
Audrey took a long breath.
“I want facts to have consequences. I don’t get to choose every consequence.”
Micah looked out the window.
After a while he said, “That sounds like a lawyer answer.”
“It does.”
“I liked you better when you hated centerpieces.”
Audrey laughed despite herself.
Then Micah said, “I have counseling tomorrow with Dad.”
“I know.”
“What if I don’t know what to say?”
“You can say that.”
“What if he says sorry?”
“You don’t have to forgive on a schedule.”
“What if I do forgive him later?”
Audrey glanced at him.
“Then that will belong to you. Not to me.”
Micah nodded slowly.
That night, Elaine emailed a new document.
It was an internal projection prepared for Brett personally.
At the top, in bold, were the words:
VALUE TO BHH UPON REMOVAL OF FINCH BLOCKING RIGHTS: $12.4M–$16.8M.
May you like
For years Brett had told himself Audrey’s family made him feel purchased.
Now there was a spreadsheet showing exactly how much he expected to be paid for removing her.