Chapter 15 - The Second Side Letter

Julian Crane had spent thirty years making complicated things sound routine.
Under oath, that talent became less charming.
Elaine’s team obtained an expedited deposition after Marianne disclosed Julian’s visit. Company counsel did not oppose it. Brett’s personal counsel objected to nearly every third question.
Audrey did not attend in person. Elaine advised against filling the room with unnecessary emotion. Instead, Audrey waited in her lawyer’s office for updates.
At noon, Elaine walked in carrying a legal pad.
“There is a second document.”
Audrey stood.
“What document?”
“An amended founder side letter dated 2018.”
“I never signed an amendment.”
“I know.”
Elaine set down the pad.
According to Julian, Brett had asked his firm in 2018 to draft an amendment that would loosen the thirty-five-percent protection in case institutional investors demanded more flexibility. A draft was prepared.
“It was never executed,” Elaine said. “Julian says it stayed in the firm’s deal folder as DRAFT 4.”
Audrey understood before Elaine finished.
“Someone used it.”
“Yes.”
In 2021, when Audrey’s shares were supposedly repurchased, the closing binder contained an “Amended and Restated Founder Protection Letter” that looked final.
It bore Audrey’s reproduced signature.
Again.
The altered document removed the thirty-five-percent floor and replaced Audrey’s consent right with simple board approval.
“Julian says he did not authorize the final version,” Elaine said.
“Do you believe him?”
“That is not the same question as whether he has exposure.”
“Meaning?”
“His firm kept the editable draft. His firm provided the old signature sample. His firm circulated the 2021 closing binder. At minimum, we need to know who touched what.”
Audrey paced to the window.
“Why did he go to Marianne?”
“He says he panicked when he saw her copy because the original 2016 language proves the later amendment materially changed your rights.”
“He wanted to know which version survived.”
“Yes.”
“That sounds like he knew the problem before last week.”
Elaine nodded. “We learned something else.”
Audrey turned.
“Julian billed Brett’s personal holding company in 2021 for ‘founder restructuring strategy.’ Those bills were paid through BHH Advisory.”
The circle tightened.
“What did he advise?”
“He is asserting privilege on communications with Brett personally. We’re challenging parts of that because the same firm represented the company during transactions affecting you.”
Audrey sat down.
“Was he helping Brett steal my shares?”
“I won’t tell you something we can’t prove yet.”
Audrey closed her eyes.
“I know.”
Elaine softened. “But his story has changed.”
“How?”
“At first, he said he didn’t remember the 2016 protections clearly. Today he admitted he warned Brett in an email that reducing you below thirty-five percent without a valid amendment could create a rescission claim.”
Audrey’s eyes opened.
“When?”
“Two weeks before the 2021 repurchase.”
“Do we have the email?”
“Not yet. He testified to it. The special committee has demanded it from his firm.”
Audrey felt her anger sharpen into something cleaner.
Brett had not stumbled into a technical violation.
He had been warned.
That afternoon, another piece arrived from an unexpected place.
The contractor whose Wisconsin invoices had been assigned to Audrey’s supposed shareholder debt produced his original records under subpoena.
His invoices had never contained Audrey’s home address.
Someone had altered the project-description pages after submission.
Metadata on one altered spreadsheet showed the editor’s user name.
BHolloway.
Elaine placed the printout in front of Audrey.
“Again,” she said, “a user name is not a human hand. But it narrows the questions.”
Audrey stared at the letters.
BHolloway.
Her phone rang.
It was Rachel, her family lawyer.
“Before you hear this elsewhere,” Rachel said, “Brett has agreed to a counselor for Micah and to stop sending him messages about the dispute.”
Audrey let out a breath.
“That’s good.”
“There’s something else. His lawyer asked whether you would consider global mediation—marriage, ownership, and corporate claims.”
Audrey looked at Elaine.
“Already?”
Rachel said, “People ask for mediation when they want control over the range of outcomes.”
“What is he offering?”
“They haven’t given numbers yet.”
Audrey glanced at the evidence spread across Elaine’s table.
False debt.
Copied signature.
Altered side letter.
Payments to Brett’s private entity.
A sale designed to complete the transfer of power.
“He doesn’t want to mediate because he’s sorry,” she said.
Rachel replied, “That would not be my working assumption.”
That evening, the special committee suspended Julian Crane’s firm from all company matters pending review.
May you like
Three hours later, Brett’s board allies called an emergency executive session.
For the first time in ten years, Brett Holloway was not invited.