scribe

Chapter 9 - Sixteen Minutes Earlier

Nessa had not been a random eyewitness.

She had been watching the house.

That truth arrived with the photographs.

The first image showed Victor Forrest stepping from a small workboat at 9:49 p.m. He wore a dark rain jacket and carried the black document case Evan remembered.

The second showed him walking toward the rear entrance.

The third, taken at 10:05, showed Caly’s gray SUV approaching the main road.

The fourth showed Caly entering through the front door.

The fifth was blurred motion and taillights from a blue sedan on the east road at 10:16.

Nessa had possessed all five.

At trial, the jury saw none of them.

“Why would she take pictures?” Caly asked the next morning.

Miriam had arranged a confidential meeting in the attorney room with Nessa’s lawyer, Dana Pike, present by video from another unit. Nessa herself appeared on screen wearing khaki trousers and her rust thermal top, burgundy cloth still tied around her wrist.

For the first time since the yard, she did not look smug.

She looked tired.

“I was working for a private investigator,” Nessa said.

Caly’s fists tightened beneath the table.

Miriam spoke first. “Name.”

“Rhea Dorne.”

Caly knew that name too.

Rhea had run corporate security for Forrest Meridian.

“What did she hire you to do?”

“Photograph whoever came to the river house.”

“Why?”

“She said the company thought Dean was leaking documents.”

“Who authorized it?”

“She said Cecily Wren.”

Caly leaned toward the screen. “You saw Victor.”

Nessa’s eyes lowered.

“Yes.”

“You photographed him.”

“Yes.”

“And then you told the jury you saw me leave after the murder.”

Nessa looked up.

“I told them what they wanted.”

Caly’s anger rose so fast she tasted metal.

“You let me lose four years because they wanted it?”

Dana Pike interjected. “Ms. Forrest—”

“No.” Caly kept her eyes on Nessa. “She gets to hear this. You watched my uncle go in before me. You kept proof. Then you pointed at me in court.”

Nessa’s face hardened defensively. “You think I was free?”

“You walked out of that courtroom.”

“I had a felony theft case hanging over me. Rhea had proof I’d been skimming from clients. Venn told me I could go to prison for years. Cecily said Victor had judges, cops, everyone. Then she showed me pictures of my mother’s apartment and said people who caused problems sometimes lost more than court cases.”

Caly went silent.

Miriam asked, “Was that a direct threat?”

Nessa shook her head. “Not direct. That was how she did it. Nothing direct.”

“And the photographs?”

“Cecily told me to destroy the ones with Victor. I kept copies.”

“Why?”

“Insurance.”

Caly almost laughed at the ugliness of the word.

“You kept my freedom as insurance.”

Nessa flinched.

Miriam kept the interview moving. “Who told you to say Caly drove away?”

“Venn.”

“Did you actually see her leave?”

“No.”

“Did you see who left in the blue sedan?”

“No. I was behind trees. I saw the car, not the driver.”

“Did you see Victor leave?”

“No.”

“Did you see Rhea Dorne?”

Nessa’s eyes shifted.

Caly caught it.

“You did.”

Nessa swallowed.

“I saw her boat.”

Miriam leaned forward. “Explain.”

“About ten-thirty, after police arrived, I moved downriver because I was scared they’d find me. I saw a second boat headed toward Harbor Point.”

“Who was in it?”

“Two people. I couldn’t see faces.”

“One could have been Victor?”

“Could have.”

“And the other?”

Nessa hesitated. “Rhea always wore a white stripe on her security jacket. I saw something white on the second person.”

Caly remembered Rhea Dorne: tall, composed, former military police, the woman who controlled every executive floor camera at Forrest Meridian.

“Why didn’t you photograph the boat?”

“Too dark.”

Miriam asked about the prepaid phone.

Nessa said Rhea had given it to her for surveillance work. Detective Venn later used the same phone to communicate with her during witness preparation, believing an unregistered device would leave less discoverable evidence.

“Did you delete messages?”

“Cecily told me to.”

“Did you?”

“Most.”

“Most?”

Nessa looked at Caly.

“The phone backed up some messages to a memory card.”

Caly’s breath caught.

“Is the card still in it?” Miriam asked.

“I think so.”

The call ended after another twenty minutes.

Caly remained seated after the screen went dark.

She had imagined confronting Nessa for years. In every version, the moment ended with certainty. Nessa admitted the lie. Caly felt vindicated. Anger became something clean.

Reality was worse.

Nessa had lied.

Nessa had been coerced.

Nessa had taken money.

Nessa had kept evidence.

Victim and perpetrator existed in the same woman, and Caly did not know what to do with that.

Miriam closed her notes. “You do not have to forgive her.”

“I wasn’t planning to.”

“You also don’t have to simplify her.”

Caly looked at the blank screen.

“I liked it better when she was just evil.”

“I know.”

That afternoon, the prepaid phone was examined by a forensic specialist under court-approved procedures.

The memory card still worked.

Most messages were fragments: meet times, locations, instructions.

Then they found one exchange dated the morning after Dean’s murder.

Venn: YOU SAW FORREST LEAVE IN THE BLUE SEDAN.

Nessa: I SAW THE SEDAN. NOT HER IN IT.

Venn: YOU RECOGNIZED HER. WE’LL GO OVER IT AGAIN.

Three hours later came another message from an unidentified number.

YOU WILL NOT MENTION VICTOR AT THE HOUSE.

Nessa replied:

WHO IS THIS?

May you like

The answer was one line.

THE PERSON MAKING SURE YOUR CASE DISAPPEARS.

Related Stories

Other posts