scribe

Chapter 14 - What Nessa Was Paid To Forget

After the poisoning attempt, Nessa was moved to a secure medical housing unit under constant observation.

Her cooperation changed.

Before, she had admitted only what documents could force her to admit.

Now she asked for a full proffer with state investigators.

Caly was not present, but Miriam obtained a summary under the post-conviction discovery order.

Nessa said the arrangement began seven weeks before Dean’s death, when Rhea Dorne approached her through a private investigator who sometimes used people facing criminal charges for low-level surveillance work.

Nessa needed money and wanted leverage on her theft case.

At first, the job was simple: follow Dean Alcott, photograph meetings, note vehicles.

Then Dean started meeting with Caly.

Rhea’s instructions changed.

“Focus on Calythene Forrest,” Miriam read. “Document any off-site contact. Do not approach.”

Caly listened without interrupting.

Two days before the murder, Detective Mara Venn contacted Nessa even though no homicide had yet occurred.

That detail made everyone stop.

“What reason did a homicide detective have to contact her before Dean was killed?” Caly asked.

Miriam checked the summary. “Venn told her she was helping corporate security with a potential theft case.”

Caly’s skin prickled.

“So police were already involved.”

“At least Venn was.”

Nessa said Venn asked whether Caly had met Dean privately and whether she seemed “angry or desperate.” Nessa said she had no basis to know.

Venn replied, “You may notice more if you pay attention.”

The night of the murder, Rhea positioned Nessa outside the river house.

At 9:47, Victor arrived by boat.

At 10:05, Caly arrived by SUV.

At 10:07, Rhea messaged that Caly’s arrival was unplanned.

At 10:12, Nessa heard shouting from inside the house.

At 10:15, she saw Cecily run toward the blue Audi carrying the black document case.

At 10:16, Cecily drove east.

Nessa had never told anyone that detail before.

“Why didn’t she photograph Cecily?” Caly asked.

“She says she was moving to get a better angle on the front door.”

“What happened after?”

“At about 10:18, she saw you come outside briefly, look toward the river, then go back in.”

Caly remembered.

She had found Dean bleeding in the library and heard an engine on the water. She ran to the back terrace, saw only darkness, then returned to call 911 and try to stop Dean’s bleeding.

The prosecution used a neighbor’s description of Caly outside as evidence she was “fleeing and reconsidered.”

Nessa’s account gave it another meaning.

“What did she hear?” Caly asked.

“Not words. A man shouting. Then a loud crash.”

“Victor.”

“Likely.”

“And Rhea?”

“Nessa never saw her enter. She believes Rhea came by water after Victor.”

Miriam continued.

The morning after the murder, Venn met Nessa at a diner. She showed Nessa a photograph of Caly and said investigators knew Caly had killed Dean during a dispute over stolen money.

Nessa objected that she had seen Victor arrive first.

Venn said Victor’s presence was “corporate business” and irrelevant.

Then Cecily joined them.

Cecily told Nessa her pending theft charges could be resolved and housing assistance arranged if she “stayed focused on what mattered.”

“What mattered?” Caly asked quietly.

Miriam read Nessa’s words.

“Caly Forrest at the house. Caly Forrest angry. Caly Forrest connected to the car leaving.”

“But Nessa knew the car was Cecily’s.”

“Yes.”

“Did she say that?”

“She says she tried. Cecily told her, ‘Cars change hands. Don’t pretend you know who owned what.’”

Caly rubbed her eyes.

“And then Venn told her it was mine.”

“Yes.”

The $18,500 housing check came next. Nessa used it to clear motel debt, pay a deposit, and settle bills. Her theft case vanished after she testified.

There was one more payment.

Four months after Caly’s conviction, Nessa received $40,000 from a legal settlement involving a shell company she had never sued.

The company’s lawyer was Cecily Wren.

“That’s the real payoff,” Caly said.

“It looks like one.”

For once Miriam did not resist the language.

Nessa had spent most of it quickly. But she kept the photographs and prepaid phone because she feared that once she destroyed everything, she would become disposable.

She was right.

The poisoning attempt proved someone still wanted her silent.

Caly stared at the proffer summary.

“Did she say who killed Dean?”

“No. She did not see the killing.”

“Then we still have a hole.”

“Yes.”

Caly looked at the evidence board Marisol had built from photocopies.

Victor went in.

Cecily left by car with the document case.

Rhea and Victor likely left by water.

Dean was alive when Caly arrived? She could not be sure. He had been barely conscious, unable to form words.

“What if Dean was still alive when Victor left?” Caly asked.

Miriam studied her. “Then the killer could be someone else.”

“Or he was dying from something Victor did.”

“Yes.”

“We need the autopsy again.”

Miriam nodded.

The original cause of death was a penetrating wound from the metal letter opener, entering below the ribs and damaging the liver. The medical examiner estimated Dean could have remained conscious for several minutes and alive for longer.

Caly had found the letter opener on the floor beside him.

Her partial print was on the handle.

At trial, the state emphasized that no usable foreign prints were recovered.

The evidence inventory contained one detail nobody had focused on.

A smear of dark polymer near the base of the handle.

It had never been tested.

Miriam requested modern analysis.

Three days later, the lab produced a preliminary result.

The polymer was consistent with a synthetic tactical glove coating used in several security and law-enforcement models.

May you like

Caly looked at Rhea’s old personnel photograph.

Rhea was wearing black protective gloves clipped to her belt.

Related Stories

Other posts