Chapter 7 - Bethany’s Stamp

Bethany Cole called Sunniva at 7:12 the next morning.
Sunniva almost did not answer.
The name on the screen carried too many associations: Celestine’s immaculate office, Christmas cards mailed on heavy cream paper, calendars arranged months in advance, and now two documents Sunniva said she had never signed.
Ingrid was making oatmeal at the stove.
“Who is it?”
“Bethany.”
Ingrid turned off the burner.
Sunniva answered and put the call on speaker only after telling Bethany she was doing so.
“Sunniva?” Bethany’s voice was barely above a whisper. “Are you alone?”
“My mother is here.”
A pause.
“Fine. I need to tell you something before Mrs. Harcourt tells me not to.”
Sunniva sat down.
“Did you notarize my signature on a postnuptial agreement?”
Bethany began to cry.
Not dramatically. It sounded worse than that—small, ashamed breaths, as if she were trying not to let anyone in the next room hear.
“I stamped it.”
“Did you see me sign it?”
“No.”
Ingrid closed her eyes.
Sunniva gripped the edge of the table.
“Did you see me sign the Harcourt Capital loan agreement?”
“No.”
“Who gave them to you?”
“Mrs. Harcourt.”
“Celestine?”
“Yes.”
“What did she say?”
Bethany hesitated.
“She said you had signed at home and that you were on bed rest and didn’t want visitors. She said it was ministerial. She said your signatures were familiar to everyone.”
“I was not on bed rest.”
“I know that now.”
“Why didn’t you call me?”
Bethany’s answer came after a long silence.
“Because I wanted to keep my job.”
The honesty hurt more than an excuse.
Sunniva asked, “Why are you calling me now?”
“Because she asked me yesterday to backdate a notary journal entry.”
The kitchen went still.
“I said no.”
“What entry?”
“Your postnup.”
Sunniva glanced at Ingrid.
“Isn’t a notary supposed to keep a journal?”
“In our state it’s recommended for some acts and required in certain circumstances. The company has its own compliance policy too. I kept one for every Harcourt document because their lawyers preferred it.”
“And there’s no entry for me?”
“No.”
“Is there one for the loan agreement?”
“No.”
Sunniva took a slow breath.
“Do you have the journal?”
Bethany’s voice dropped.
“Yes.”
“Where?”
“With me.”
Sunniva resisted the urge to tell her to bring it immediately. Naomi had warned her not to turn herself into an investigator or ask witnesses to steal company property.
“Please don’t alter anything,” Sunniva said. “And don’t take anything you don’t have the right to take. I’m going to give your number to my attorney. You can decide whether you want to speak with her.”
Bethany began crying again.
“I’m going to lose my job.”
“I can’t promise you won’t.”
“I have a daughter in college.”
Sunniva closed her eyes.
A week ago, that sentence might have made her reassure Bethany. Might have made her absorb the cost of someone else’s decision so they would not have to.
Instead she said, quietly, “And I have a daughter or son coming in a few weeks. I need to know what was done in my name.”
Bethany inhaled shakily.
“There’s more.”
Sunniva opened her eyes.
“What?”
“Mrs. Harcourt didn’t create the signatures herself.”
“Who did?”
“I don’t know. She gave me the pages already signed.”
“Did Alistair know?”
“I don’t know.”
It was the answer Sunniva feared most. Uncertainty kept hope alive in the exact place it could do the most damage.
Bethany continued.
“But I heard them argue about the loan agreement last winter.”
Sunniva’s heartbeat quickened.
“About what?”
“Mr. Harcourt said the bank wanted proof the money was committed. Mrs. Harcourt said, ‘Then give them the proof.’ He said, ‘She never agreed to that amount.’”
Ingrid sat down across from Sunniva.
“What did Celestine say?” Sunniva asked.
Bethany whispered, “She said, ‘Agreement is a luxury for families that are solvent.’”
The sentence chilled the room.
After the call, Sunniva sent the recording to Naomi. She had told Bethany the call was on speaker, but Sunniva was not sure about the state’s recording law, so she had not secretly recorded it. Instead, Ingrid had taken contemporaneous notes. Naomi would decide what could be used and how.
At eleven, Naomi called back.
“Bethany has agreed to speak with us and to consult her own lawyer. Good move not asking her for the journal directly.”
“Do you believe her?”
“I believe she just gave us several facts we can verify.”
“What about Alistair?”
“We do not know yet what he knew about the forged signatures.”
Sunniva looked at his apology text.
“I want to believe he didn’t know.”
“That is a personal feeling. Preserve it if you need to. But don’t let it substitute for evidence.”
After the call, Sunniva went upstairs to shower.
Her wedding ring caught on the hem of her cardigan as she undressed.
She slid it off and placed it on the dresser.
For the first time since the wedding, she left it there.
When she came back downstairs, Ingrid was standing at the front window.
“What is it?” Sunniva asked.
A black sedan had stopped across the street.
Celestine stepped out carrying a silver thermos and two porcelain cups in a padded case.
“She brought tea,” Ingrid said.
May you like
Sunniva looked at the wedding ring-shaped pale line around her finger.
“No,” she said. “She brought an argument.”