scribe

Chapter 13 - The Message That Never Existed

Naomi answered Alistair’s custody letter with eleven pages and no adjectives.

She attached the prenatal medical record, the photograph of Sunniva’s cheek, Alistair’s written apology for striking her, the nonemergency incident report from Ingrid’s house, and a short declaration from Sunniva stating that she had moved twenty-three minutes away for safety and remained under the care of the same obstetric practice.

She did not attach Rosa’s unsigned statement.

Not yet.

“She is a witness, not ammunition,” Naomi explained. “We preserve her credibility.”

Alistair’s attorney responded two days later with what he called “supporting communications.”

There were eight screenshots.

The first showed a text Sunniva had sent Ingrid at 1:14 a.m. in June:

I don’t know if I can do this.

Alistair’s lawyer described it as evidence that Sunniva had expressed doubts about motherhood.

Sunniva opened the conversation on her own phone.

The full exchange read:

SUNNIVA: I don’t know if I can do this.

INGRID: The shower?

SUNNIVA: Forty-five people in Celestine’s garden while I’m nauseated and pretending I like games involving diapers? I may flee the country.

INGRID: I will smuggle you out in a cake box.

Sunniva stared at the screen.

“They cut off the line before and after.”

Naomi nodded. “Context matters.”

The second screenshot showed Sunniva writing, I need to get away from this house.

The full conversation was from a formal dinner Celestine hosted for eighteen investors. Sunniva had texted a friend from the upstairs bathroom after being cornered by a drunk guest who kept touching her elbow.

The third showed: I feel nothing today.

It was a message to Ingrid about fetal movement at twenty-one weeks, followed seven minutes later by: Never mind. There she is. Kicking like a tiny horse.

Sunniva placed both hands over her belly.

“She,” she said quietly.

Naomi looked up. “You know?”

“Dr. Reyes told me last week. I hadn’t told Alistair yet.”

Naomi’s expression softened. “Congratulations.”

The word felt strange in a room full of accusations.

Sunniva smiled anyway.

Then they reached the final screenshot.

It showed a message from Sunniva to Ingrid dated July 9:

Sometimes I wish I weren’t pregnant. Everything would be easier.

Sunniva read it three times.

“I never wrote that.”

Naomi did not react visibly.

“Search the date.”

Sunniva did.

There was no such message.

“Search those words.”

Nothing.

“Could you have deleted it?”

“No.”

“Could your mother have deleted it?”

“Not from my phone.”

Naomi nodded. “We do not jump to fabrication until we verify. We can obtain carrier records where available, preserve the devices, and ask for the native source or production method. Screenshots alone are easy to misinterpret and, in some circumstances, easy to alter.”

Sunniva looked at the image again.

The conversation above the alleged message showed Ingrid asking whether Sunniva wanted soup.

Sunniva opened her real thread.

On July 9, Ingrid had indeed asked about soup.

Sunniva’s actual response was:

Only if it comes with a new spine. This baby has moved into my ribs.

The next line was a laughing emoji from Ingrid.

Same timestamp window.

Different words.

Naomi’s face hardened.

“That is much more concerning.”

“Alistair had access to my phone.”

“When?”

“All the time. We knew each other’s passcodes.”

“Access does not prove he created this.”

“I know.” Sunniva hated how automatic the phrase had become. “But someone did.”

That afternoon, Naomi sent a preservation request demanding the original electronic source of every screenshot and requesting that no device, message archive, or cloud backup be altered.

Alistair called Sunniva twelve minutes later.

She did not answer.

He left a voicemail.

“Sunniva, I did not create those screenshots. I need you to believe me about that. Mother gave the file to Martin. I assumed it came from my phone. I should have checked. I should have checked everything.”

His voice sounded exhausted.

Then, after a pause:

“I know that sentence means nothing now.”

Sunniva listened twice.

She sent it to Naomi.

That evening, Ingrid cooked tomato soup. Sunniva ate half a bowl and went upstairs early.

At 9:40, Naomi emailed.

Alistair’s attorney had withdrawn the disputed screenshot “pending authentication.”

At 10:15, another email arrived.

This one was from Gabriel Finch.

He had received a response from Harcourt Capital’s counsel regarding the loan agreement. The company claimed the document was genuine and said it had relied on Sunniva’s signed commitment when obtaining third-party financing.

Attached was a lender file summary.

Sunniva read the first page.

Her $350,000 supposed loan was not the only document bearing her name.

The financing package listed her as a “limited personal guarantor” for obligations up to $1.2 million.

She called Gabriel immediately.

“I never guaranteed anything.”

“I believe you,” he said. “Do not contact the lender yourself tonight.”

“How can someone guarantee a million dollars without knowing?”

“They should not be able to do that lawfully. Tomorrow we find out what document they think they have.”

Sunniva sat on the edge of the yellow bed after the call ended.

For the first time since leaving Harcourt House, the overnight bag was fully unpacked.

May you like

But she understood now that walking out had not ended the trap.

It had only made its paperwork visible.

Related Stories

Other posts