scribe

Chapter 14 - Behind the Sweaters

Gerald placed Natalie’s original letter beside Lena’s copy.

The pages matched.

But the envelope did not look as though it had been opened recently. The crease was soft, the flap worn.

Someone had read it before.

Gerald tried to remember the first months after Natalie died. They were a blur of casseroles left on the porch, sympathy cards, insurance calls, and Sophie waking at night asking whether dead people got lonely.

He remembered Lena returning a stack of documents.

He remembered putting them in a banker’s box.

Years later, when Yvonne moved in, she reorganized the study because Gerald said he could never find anything.

“You think she read it?” Sophie asked.

Gerald did not answer.

Lena did.

“We know the envelope was opened. We do not know who opened it.”

Sophie looked toward the stairs.

“Yvonne hides things in that wardrobe.”

Gerald nodded slowly.

“What else?”

“My bag.”

“I know.”

“My green notebook was there before it came back.”

“You saw it?”

“No. But it came back after she had it.”

“That is not the same thing.”

Sophie flinched.

Gerald immediately realized how the sentence sounded.

“I’m not saying I don’t believe you,” he said. “I’m saying we have to separate what we know from what we think.”

Sophie stared at him.

“That sounds like Aunt Lena.”

“It probably should have sounded like me years ago.”

The next day, Yvonne returned while Sophie was at school.

Gerald was home waiting.

Andrea Miles had advised him not to leave Sophie alone with Yvonne while the assessment continued. Dana Holt had separately told him to preserve financial records and not destroy, alter, or conceal documents.

Gerald did not tell Yvonne he had found Natalie’s letter.

He asked about the missing metal document box instead.

“What box?”

“The one you kept in your wardrobe.”

Yvonne set down her purse.

“My personal papers are not your concern.”

“We are married.”

“You discovered privacy after going through my business records?”

“Where is the box?”

“Safe.”

“Does it contain records from Sophie’s account?”

Yvonne’s mouth tightened.

“Talk to your lawyer.”

“I have.”

She looked at him for a long moment.

Then she smiled without warmth.

“Of course you have.”

Gerald felt something inside him settle.

Not courage exactly.

The exhaustion that comes after fear has already done its worst.

“Dana is preparing a petition for an accounting and removal of me as custodian,” he said.

Yvonne blinked.

“Removal of you?”

“Yes.”

“You volunteered that?”

“Yes.”

“You understand what that makes you look like?”

“Yes.”

“You could lose control of every dollar.”

“That is the point.”

For the first time, Yvonne raised her voice.

“You pathetic man.”

Gerald did not answer.

She stepped closer.

“I spent three years cleaning up after you. I handled taxes, bills, school forms, appointments. I made that house function while you drifted around grieving a woman who was dead.”

Gerald’s face tightened.

“And every time Sophie forgot something, every time she cried, every time she looked at you like I was an intruder, you disappeared. Do not stand there now and pretend I created your cowardice.”

“No,” Gerald said. “You didn’t.”

Yvonne stopped.

“I did that part myself.”

The answer gave her nothing to fight.

She turned away.

Gerald saw a manila folder protruding from her purse.

The label read BRIGHTPATH — CLOSING.

“What are you doing with Birch Lane?”

Yvonne pulled the purse toward her.

“Nothing.”

“You have closing documents.”

“It’s a refinance.”

Dana had warned Gerald about that possibility.

If Yvonne borrowed against the duplex or sold it, tracing and recovering funds could become more difficult.

“Do not move that property,” he said.

Yvonne laughed.

“You don’t own it.”

“No. But Sophie may own part of the money inside it.”

Yvonne’s face went still.

Gerald took out his phone.

“I’m calling Dana.”

Yvonne grabbed her purse and walked toward the door.

“Then tell Dana she should move quickly.”

After she left, Gerald went upstairs.

He stood in front of the open wardrobe.

Without the metal box, the back shelf looked deeper than before.

He moved the folded sweaters.

Behind them were things that did not belong there.

A birthday card from Lena, unopened.

Two school newsletters.

A library fine notice.

Sophie’s missing red hair ribbon.

A spelling test.

And beneath them, a sealed envelope from Ms. Alvarez dated three weeks earlier.

Gerald opened it.

Inside was a note requesting a parent conference because Sophie had become increasingly anxious about misplaced belongings and appeared afraid of getting in trouble at home.

May you like

At the bottom, Ms. Alvarez had written:

Please contact me. Sophie seems to believe every mistake is evidence that something is wrong with her.

Related Stories

Other posts