Chapter 10 - Birch Lane

Lena did not take Sophie to Birch Lane to investigate.
She was very clear about that.
“You are ten,” she said when Sophie asked. “You do not need to become a detective because the adults around you failed to behave like adults.”
“But you’re going.”
“I’m going to meet an attorney.”
“Is the attorney at Birch Lane?”
“No.”
Sophie crossed her arms.
Lena almost smiled. “You got that expression from your mother.”
Sophie uncrossed them immediately.
The attorney’s name was Dana Holt. She practiced estate and fiduciary litigation from a small office above a pharmacy downtown. Lena had found her through the county bar referral service and paid for the first consultation herself.
Sophie was not present.
But that evening, Lena called her with Gerald’s permission and explained only what Sophie needed to know.
“The account is governed by state law,” Lena said. “Your father, as custodian, has a duty to keep the property separate, keep records, and use it for your benefit. There are rules about using custodial funds for expenses a parent is already legally obligated to provide.”
“Did he break the rules?”
“There are enough questions that Dana thinks a formal accounting is appropriate.”
“What’s that?”
“It means your father may have to show where the money went, with records.”
“What if he can’t?”
“Then a judge can decide what happens next.”
Sophie sat on the floor of her bedroom with the phone pressed to her ear.
“Will he go to jail?”
“That is not what we are doing right now. This starts as a civil matter about protecting the account and getting accurate records. If evidence of a crime appears, that is for authorities to evaluate, not us.”
Sophie was relieved and disappointed at the same time, then ashamed of the disappointment.
“What about Yvonne’s house?”
“Dana checked the public filing. Birch Lane is titled to BrightPath Learning Services LLC.”
“The fake tutoring company.”
“We have evidence that the company billed your account for services you say you never received. We do not yet have proof that every dollar used to buy the duplex came from your account.”
Sophie looked toward her bedroom door.
It was closed.
“Dad has the bank records now.”
“Yes.”
“Will he give them to you?”
“I asked.”
“What did he say?”
Lena hesitated.
“He said he needs time.”
Sophie laughed once, a small bitter sound that startled her.
“Dad always needs time when someone else needs him to do something.”
Downstairs, Gerald heard the sentence through the heating vent.
He was standing in the kitchen with a stack of bank statements in his hand.
For several seconds he did not move.
Then he carried the statements into the garage, sat at the workbench, and began sorting them by year.
He found withdrawals he remembered signing.
He found withdrawals he did not.
Some used electronic authorization codes that could have been entered by anyone with his login.
Some had his scanned signature attached.
And some had physical signatures that looked like his but were wrong in small ways—the G too narrow, the final r too neat.
Gerald took out old contracts from his filing cabinet and compared them.
By midnight, he had divided the transactions into three piles.
SIGNED BY ME.
MAYBE SIGNED BY ME.
NOT SIGNED BY ME.
The first pile was large enough to destroy every excuse he had left.
The third was large enough to frighten him.
At 12:26 a.m., he texted Lena.
I will meet with your attorney. Sophie should not be there.
Lena replied one minute later.
Agreed.
Then another message appeared.
Bring every statement. Do not warn Yvonne first.
Gerald stared at the screen.
He thought of the schoolbag.
He had not known Yvonne hid it.
But he had watched her hit Sophie’s hand.
He had known enough.
The next afternoon, while Yvonne was grocery shopping, Gerald drove to Dana Holt’s office with the account records in a sealed box.
Dana spent forty minutes reviewing them before she spoke.
“This is more serious than I expected,” she said.
Gerald’s mouth was dry. “How serious?”
Dana lifted one invoice.
“This payment says eight thousand two hundred dollars for educational assessment and intervention.”
“She never had that.”
“I know. Lena gave me Sophie’s school records showing no such service.”
She placed a second document beside it.
“This payment went to BrightPath.”
Gerald nodded.
Dana placed a third sheet on top.
It was a transfer record from BrightPath’s bank account, obtained from documents Gerald had found in Yvonne’s home filing drawer and voluntarily brought with him.
Three days after the payment cleared, almost the same amount had been transferred to the escrow company that handled the Birch Lane closing.
Gerald stared at the page.
May you like
Dana folded her hands.
“Mr. Mercer, this is no longer just a story about poor bookkeeping.”