scribe

Chapter 4 - The Girl Who Lent the Tablet

Althea Frost had never considered herself brave.

She also had never considered herself cruel.

That was the lie she had been telling herself for four months.

When Mr. Bell asked her to come to the office, she knew immediately that the lie was ending.

Her mother had not arrived yet, so Dr. Ross sat in the room as the required adult witness.

Mr. Bell placed a school tablet on the desk.

“Is this assigned to you?”

Althea nodded.

“Did you have it this morning?”

“Yes.”

“Did you use it in the restroom?”

“No.”

“Did someone else?”

Althea’s eyes moved to the floor.

Dr. Ross spoke gently. “You’re not in trouble for telling the truth.”

That sentence made Althea almost laugh.

Children were always told they would not get in trouble for telling the truth.

Then they told it, and everything changed.

“Sybilla borrowed it,” she said.

“Why?”

“She said she needed to message her mom.”

“During class?”

Althea nodded.

“From the restroom?”

Another nod.

“What did she say had happened?”

Althea pressed her lips together.

“She said Callie was going to make something up.”

Mr. Bell leaned forward.

“Before the mouse incident?”

Althea looked up.

“Yes.”

The room went still.

“How long before?”

“I don’t know. Maybe five minutes.”

Dr. Ross asked, “Was the mouse already in Callie’s backpack then?”

Althea began to cry.

Mr. Bell changed his tone. “Althea, did you put the mouse there?”

“No.”

“Did you see who did?”

“No.”

“Did you know someone planned to?”

Althea’s crying worsened.

“No.”

It was true, technically.

She had not known about the mouse.

She had known about other things.

Dr. Ross handed her tissues.

“Tell us what you did know.”

Althea shook her head.

“I can’t.”

“Why?”

“She’ll say I did it.”

“Who?”

Althea did not need to say the name.

Mr. Bell already knew.

Dr. Ross waited.

Althea whispered, “Sybilla always says there has to be one person everybody agrees is the problem.”

Mr. Bell frowned.

“What does that mean?”

“She says if everybody agrees, then teachers think it’s true.”

“Agrees about what?”

“That Callie lies. That she cries for attention. That she acts weird.”

“Do you believe that?”

Althea stared at the tissue in her hands.

“No.”

“Then why did you repeat it?”

Because Sybilla had invited her to sit with the older girls at lunch.

Because Nerissa had once been excluded for three weeks after disagreeing.

Because Sybilla’s birthday parties were famous, and her mother hosted half the parent committee events at school.

Because Callie never fought back.

Because cruelty was easiest when the target was quiet.

Althea whispered, “I didn’t want them to turn on me.”

Dr. Ross’s voice stayed steady. “So you helped them turn on her.”

Althea flinched.

“Yes.”

It was the first complete truth she had said all day.

Meanwhile, Margaret Wrenford drove Callie home along the tree-lined roads outside McLean.

The car heater ran high.

Callie stared through the window.

“Do you want to tell me anything?”

“No.”

“All right.”

“I’m sorry.”

Margaret glanced at her. “For what?”

“For making you leave work.”

“You did not make me do anything.”

“You had that painting.”

Margaret almost missed the turn into their neighborhood.

“What painting?”

“The one from the museum. The river one.”

Margaret stared at her daughter.

“You remember me telling you about that?”

Callie nodded.

Margaret had mentioned the restoration weeks ago.

Her child had been worried about interrupting a workday before a mouse was found in her backpack.

“Callie,” she said carefully, “has someone been telling you that you’re a burden?”

“No.”

Too fast again.

Margaret’s hands tightened on the steering wheel.

At home, Callie went upstairs to change.

Margaret carried the stained jacket to the laundry room.

She almost put it into the sink.

Then something stopped her.

Evidence, Ms. Reeve had called the desk markings.

Margaret photographed the jacket instead.

Front.

Sleeves.

Collar.

As she turned it inside out, something fell from the pocket.

A folded square of paper.

Margaret opened it.

Three words were written in blue ink.

NEXT TIME WORSE.

Margaret stood motionless in the laundry room.

Then she heard Callie behind her.

“Mom?”

Margaret turned.

Callie saw the note in her hand.

All color left her face.

And Margaret finally understood that the mouse was not the threat.

Althea’s father arrived before the interview ended. He stood outside the office listening to only the final few minutes, and when his daughter emerged, he did not ask whether she had been “as bad as the others.” He asked, “Did you hurt someone?”

Althea nodded.

“Then we start there.”

She cried harder.

In the car, she told him she had kept measuring herself against Sybilla. If Sybilla invented the plan, then Althea was better. If Nerissa laughed first, then Althea was better. If she hesitated before joining in, then she was better.

Her father said, “Better than the worst person in the room is not the same as good.”

The sentence stayed with her.

At the same time, Mr. Bell reviewed the device logs with a technician. The borrowed tablet had connected to the school network in the restroom at 8:56 a.m. The message to Lydia had been brief: CALLIE MIGHT TELL. COME UP.

May you like

The wording disturbed him. Not because it proved what had happened, but because it proved Sybilla’s concern was disclosure, not safety.

It was the fulfillment of one.

Related Stories

Other posts