Chapter 15 - The Girls Who Followed

Callie did not answer Althea.
For two days, she did not answer anyone.
Dr. Ross visited the Wrenford home with Margaret’s permission and did not mention school for the first twenty minutes.
They talked about books.
Callie liked mysteries where clues mattered.
“Because if clues matter,” she said, “the ending isn’t cheating.”
Dr. Ross smiled sadly.
“That’s a good rule for stories.”
“And people.”
“Sometimes.”
Callie looked at her.
“Why did Nerissa and Althea do it if they knew it was bad?”
Dr. Ross considered the answer carefully.
“Fear. Approval. Habit. Cowardice. Sometimes people join cruelty because they’re afraid cruelty will choose them next.”
“That doesn’t make it okay.”
“No.”
“Then why explain it?”
“Because understanding a reason is not the same as excusing it.”
Callie thought about that.
Althea’s message remained unanswered.
Nerissa had sent none.
At school, both girls were struggling differently.
Althea confessed things before adults even asked.
Nerissa minimized, then corrected herself, then minimized again.
Ms. Reeve saw how shame worked.
Althea accepted that she had done harm.
Nerissa kept trying to prove she was not the worst person involved.
That distinction mattered.
One afternoon, Catherine Cole asked if Nerissa could write Callie a letter.
Dr. Ross said only if there was no expectation of response.
The letter arrived sealed.
Margaret offered Callie the choice to read it.
Callie did.
Nerissa wrote:
I kept thinking because Sybilla had the ideas, I wasn’t responsible. But I laughed. I lied. I knew about the list. I didn’t know every part, but I knew enough. I’m sorry I told myself I was just standing there when sometimes I was helping.
Callie stopped there.
She folded the letter.
“Do I have to forgive her?”
“No.”
“Will everyone think I’m mean if I don’t?”
“Some might.”
“That’s not fair.”
“No.”
Callie placed the letter in a drawer.
She did not destroy it.
Meanwhile, Thomas Drake provided another piece of evidence.
He had found a deleted draft email in Lydia’s home office computer backups.
It was addressed to Dr. Mercer but never sent.
The draft complained that Callie had received “inappropriate favoritism” and suggested her emotional behavior was disrupting other students.
The draft predated the mouse incident by three days.
Attached was a screenshot of Callie crying in the stairwell.
Thomas told the school he believed Lydia had planned to escalate her campaign through formal parent complaints.
Lydia denied intending to send it.
Her attorney insisted drafts were not actions.
Legally and procedurally, that was true.
But the school board was not a criminal court.
Its concern was campus safety and community conduct.
Lydia’s parent privileges were revoked for the remainder of the academic year.
More serious consequences depended on the disciplinary panel and any civil action the Wrenfords chose to pursue.
Margaret consulted an attorney.
She did not want a lawsuit unless necessary.
The attorney explained options: formal demand to preserve records, possible claims related to harassment or intentional infliction depending on evidence and state law, school contractual obligations, and protective agreements.
Margaret listened.
Then asked, “What helps my daughter fastest?”
The attorney answered honestly.
“Probably not litigation.”
So Margaret chose boundaries first.
Written no-contact agreement.
No direct or indirect communication from Lydia or Sybilla to Callie.
No distribution of images.
Deletion and certified removal of the shared folder copies under counsel supervision.
School safety plan.
Independent therapeutic support for Callie.
She would reserve other rights.
When Margaret explained this to Callie, her daughter asked, “Does that mean we’re not fighting?”
Margaret touched her braid.
“We are fighting.”
“It doesn’t sound like fighting.”
“Good fighting often looks like paperwork.”
Callie almost smiled.
It was the first joke she had made about the situation.
Then her expression changed.
“Mom?”
“Yes?”
“I want to go back Monday.”
Margaret stared.
“Are you sure?”
“No.”
That answer was more honest.
Margaret’s consultation with counsel gave her an unexpected sense of control because the attorney translated emotion into choices. Preserve this. Decline that. Request written confirmation. Do not answer informal messages. Put boundaries in language others could be held to.
On the drive home, Callie asked, “Did the lawyer say we could sue?”
“Yes.”
“Are we?”
“Not right now.”
“Why?”
“Because I’m trying to choose what helps you, not what sounds strongest.”
Callie thought about that.
“What if I want them punished?”
“Then tell me.”
“I don’t know if I do.”
“That’s allowed.”
Adults kept asking Callie what outcome she wanted as though hurt automatically created a clean desire for revenge or forgiveness. She felt neither cleanly. Some days she wanted Sybilla to feel exactly as afraid as she had. Other days she wanted never to hear Sybilla’s name again.
Dr. Ross told her contradictory feelings were not decisions.
“You can feel ten things,” she said. “We still choose actions one at a time.”
Callie liked that rule too.
May you like
It meant she did not have to become morally perfect just because she had been harmed.
“But I want Ms. Reeve to meet me at the door.”