scribe

Chapter 4 - THE CUPBOARD ABOVE THE WASHER

I waited until the school run.

Calanthe took the boys because Leontes’s primary school was farther away. I offered to take Ysoria to nursery later.

The moment the front door closed, I went to the utility room.

The cupboard above the washer was high enough that the children could not reach it.

Inside were detergent pods, spare batteries, cleaning cloths—and a plastic storage box with a lid.

I opened it.

Food.

Dozens of individually wrapped snacks.

Fruit chews. Crackers. Miniature chocolate bars. Raisin boxes. Biscuits.

Some were the same candy I had seen on Halloween.

On top was a notebook.

I opened it.

The first page said:

REWARD INVENTORY.

Below that were columns for Leontes, Emeric, and Ysoria.

Leontes and Emeric had check marks beside almost every day.

Ysoria’s column had almost none.

Instead, there were notes.

Cried when asked to wait.

Didn’t finish crust.

Asked for Daddy.

Wouldn’t say thank you loudly enough.

Dropped cup.

Wet sleeve.

Slow putting shoes on.

My mouth went dry.

Some notes were absurd even by strict parenting standards. One entry simply read:

Mentioned Elowyn.

No treat.

Elowyn.

Ysoria’s mother.

I sat on the laundry counter because my legs suddenly felt unreliable.

Calanthe had known Elowyn was not a forbidden subject. I had told her from the beginning that Ysoria would grow up hearing her mother’s name. There were photographs in Ysoria’s room. A small silver music box had belonged to Elowyn. I talked about her when Ysoria asked.

Why would mentioning her dead mother cost a child a biscuit?

I took photographs of every page.

Then I heard the front door.

Too soon.

I put the notebook back, closed the cupboard, and walked into the hall.

Leontes stood there alone.

His backpack was still on.

“Where’s Calanthe?” I asked.

“In the car. She forgot Emeric’s project.”

He looked terrified that I might say more.

I crouched.

“I found the notebook.”

His face crumpled.

“Am I in trouble?”

“No.”

“Promise?”

“I promise.”

His shoulders lowered slightly.

“Why did you tell me?”

He looked toward the door.

“Because Ysoria cried in the bathroom yesterday.”

“Why?”

“She thought if you saw the wrapper, you would be mad at her.”

I could barely speak.

“Why would she think that?”

Leontes shrugged, but tears filled his eyes.

“Mum says little kids make grown-ups tired. She says Ysoria makes you tired.”

I stared at him.

“Does she say that to Ysoria?”

He nodded.

The front door opened.

Calanthe called, “Leontes?”

He jumped.

I stood.

She appeared holding a cardboard solar-system model.

Her gaze moved from me to her son.

“What are you two doing?”

“Talking about school,” I said.

Leontes stared at the floor.

Calanthe studied him long enough that I could see he was fighting the urge to apologize for something he had not done.

Then she handed him the project.

“Car. Now.”

He hurried outside.

Calanthe waited until he was gone.

“You’re confusing them,” she said.

“With what?”

“Your suspicion.”

I kept my voice even.

“After school, we’re talking.”

“You said that already.”

“I mean it.”

Her expression changed.

For the first time, I saw a flicker of fear.

Not because of the wrapper.

Because she was wondering what else I had found.

I did not tell her.

Instead, I took Ysoria to nursery.

At pickup, her teacher, Mrs. Pritchard, asked if I had a minute.

We stepped away from the other parents.

“I’ve been meaning to speak to you,” she said. “Ysoria has started hiding food in her pockets.”

My heart sank.

“How long?”

“A few weeks.”

She hesitated.

“And yesterday she asked me something I didn’t quite know how to answer.”

“What?”

Mrs. Pritchard looked genuinely troubled.

After Calanthe drove away again, I stood in the utility room with the cupboard open and tried to imagine how often the notebook had been used. The paper was worn at the corners. Several pages had smudged fingerprints. This had not been an impulsive system created for a difficult week. It had become routine.

I checked dates against my calendar.

On one day marked CLINGY — NO TREAT, I had been in Rotterdam for a client meeting.

On another, MENTIONED ELOWYN — NO TREAT, I had texted Calanthe asking how everyone was doing. Her reply had been a photograph of all three children smiling on the sofa beneath the words PERFECT DAY.

The discrepancy made me sit down.

Pictures had become evidence of appearance, not experience.

I remembered how often I had accepted them gratefully while rushing between meetings. A photograph arrived. Three faces smiled. I felt reassured. I never asked what happened before or after the shutter clicked.

When I picked Ysoria up from nursery that afternoon, she ran toward me holding a painted paper plate. She looked happy.

For one dangerous second, I wondered whether I had exaggerated everything.

Then Mrs. Pritchard touched my arm and asked for a private word.

May you like

That was when I understood why patterns mattered. A child could laugh at three o'clock and still be afraid at breakfast. Happiness did not cancel harm any more than harm canceled every happy moment.

“She asked how many stars a child needs before they’re allowed to miss their mother.”

Related Stories

Other posts