Chapter 25 - YOU ARE ALLOWED TO LOVE HER

There are questions adults answer with facts.
What time is bedtime?
Where is my rabbit?
Why is the moon following the car?
Then there are questions that require you to decide, in a few seconds, which part of the truth a three-year-old should have to carry.
Ysoria stood beside her bed with one finger resting on Elowyn’s photograph.
“Why did Mummy Calanthe not like my mummy?” she asked again.
I sat on the rug.
“Come here.”
She climbed into my lap.
I chose each word carefully.
“Calanthe had some feelings that were too big for her, and she handled them badly.”
Ysoria frowned.
“Like angry?”
“Yes. And jealous.”
“What is jealous?”
“When you feel upset because someone else has something you wish you had.”
She thought about that.
“What did my mummy have?”
“You.”
Ysoria looked startled.
“But Calanthe had Lee and Emeric.”
I almost laughed at the simple accuracy of it.
“Yes. She did.”
“So why?”
“I don’t know all the reasons.”
It was important to say that too.
Not every adult failure had an explanation a child needed to solve.
I touched the photograph.
“What I do know is that you are allowed to love your mum. You are allowed to talk about her. You are allowed to miss her. You do not have to earn that.”
“Zero stars?”
“Zero stars.”
She leaned against my chest.
“Can I love Calanthe too?”
The question hurt more than I expected.
I looked at the top of her golden head.
“Yes.”
Even after everything, yes.
A child’s attachment was not a courtroom verdict.
“You can love someone and still be sad about what they did.”
“Are you sad?”
“Very.”
“Are you angry?”
“Yes.”
“At me?”
“Never for this.”
She relaxed.
Later, after she slept, I sat alone in the kitchen.
The house had accumulated evidence everywhere. Printed statements. Photographs. Copies of emails. Solicitor letters.
But the most important work did not fit into a file.
It was teaching a child that hunger did not require permission.
That grief was not misbehavior.
That an adult’s jealousy was not her responsibility.
The next morning, Mrs. Pritchard called.
“There’s been a change,” she said.
My stomach tightened automatically.
“What kind?”
“A good one, I think. Ysoria asked for another cracker at snack time.”
I exhaled.
“She didn’t hide it?”
“No. She asked. Then she ate it.”
I closed my eyes.
“That’s good.”
“There’s something else. She drew her family today.”
I waited.
“She drew you, herself, Leontes, Emeric, Aunt Seraphine, and two women.”
“Two?”
“She said one was her mummy in the sky and one was Mummy Calanthe at Grandma’s house.”
I swallowed.
“Was she upset?”
“No. She seemed very matter-of-fact.”
Children could sometimes hold contradictions more honestly than adults.
That afternoon, Helena called with news from Calanthe’s solicitor.
Calanthe wanted to provide a full written disclosure of the trust withdrawals and business finances.
In exchange, she was not asking for immunity or secrecy anymore.
“What changed?” I asked.
“Her solicitor may have explained reality.”
“Or?”
“Or she has decided cooperation is better than denial. We don’t need to assign motive yet.”
Stay boring.
Facts.
Dates.
Documents.
“All right,” I said. “I’ll read it.”
The disclosure arrived that evening.
It was twenty-three pages.
On page seventeen, Calanthe described the Halloween incident in her own words.
I read the paragraph twice.
Then a third time.
She did not call it a joke.
She did not call it discipline.
She wrote:
I gave Ysoria an empty wrapper because she mentioned Elowyn and I wanted her to feel excluded.
The sentence was devastating.
The disclosure also contained a chronology of small household incidents I had never known about. Calanthe wrote that she sometimes sent Ysoria away from family movie night after the child mentioned Elowyn, telling herself the toddler was overtired. She admitted withholding a bedtime story twice because Ysoria cried for me while I was traveling. She described removing photographs because they made her feel "erased."
None of those events would have sounded enormous in isolation.
Together, they formed a climate.
I called Mrs. Pritchard and asked whether children recover from this kind of pattern.
She reminded me she was a teacher, not a clinician, but said something useful anyway.
"Young children learn through repetition," she said. "That means harmful patterns matter. It also means healthy patterns matter."
So I stopped searching for one perfect corrective conversation.
We built repetition.
Breakfast happened every day.
Snacks appeared without moral commentary.
Elowyn's name could be spoken without the room changing temperature.
When Ysoria cried, someone comforted her before asking whether a rule had been broken.
When I traveled, I video-called at the same time each evening and told her exactly when I would return.
Repair, I learned, was mostly boring too.
May you like
That made it reliable.
It was also the first time Calanthe had named the act without hiding inside another word.