scribe

Chapter 6 - The Cost of Being the Reliable One

On Monday morning, Diane found a permission slip in her mailbox.

It was not addressed to her.

The paper had Nolan's school logo at the top and Corinne's name printed under PARENT OR GUARDIAN. Beneath that, in blue ink, someone had written Diane Brooks as the emergency contact.

Diane stood at the curb staring at it.

The mail carrier had probably slipped it into the wrong box because Corinne's old address was still connected to several school records. That was the practical explanation.

The less practical question was why Diane's name was there at all.

She knew she was an emergency contact, of course. She had been one since Nolan started preschool. What she did not remember was being asked.

That realization sent her inside to the kitchen drawer where she kept old documents. She found the preschool registration form from three years earlier. There it was again: Diane Brooks. Relationship: great-aunt. Authorized pickup: yes.

She remembered the first time Nolan's school had called her.

Corinne had been in a meeting. Nolan had thrown up after lunch. Diane had canceled a dentist appointment, driven across town, picked him up, bought ginger ale, and sat with him until his fever came down.

She had not minded.

That was what made all of this difficult.

Diane was not trying to prove she did not love them. She was trying to remember where love ended and assignment began.

Her phone rang.

This time it was Shonda.

Diane answered while sorting the mail.

“Hey, baby.”

“Hey, Aunt Diane. You got a minute?”

“That depends.”

Shonda laughed nervously. “Okay, see, that's new.”

“What do you need?”

“Nothing. I swear. I was just calling because the group chat is still a mess.”

“I muted it.”

“Smart.”

Diane carried her coffee to the table.

Shonda hesitated. “Can I ask you something without you thinking I'm taking sides?”

“People usually say that right before taking sides.”

“I just want to understand. You really wouldn't have watched the kids if Corinne had asked?”

Diane thought about it.

“I don't know.”

“You had bingo.”

“Yes.”

Shonda sounded surprised by how seriously Diane said it.

Diane continued, “Maybe I would've skipped bingo. Maybe I would've told her I already had plans. Maybe I would've offered another weekend. The point is I should have had the chance to decide.”

“I get that.”

“Do you?”

“Yes. Actually... more than I wanted to.”

Diane heard something change in her niece's voice.

“What happened?”

Shonda exhaled. “Corinne called me Saturday and asked why I couldn't leave the birthday dinner to keep the kids.”

Diane closed her eyes.

“She asked you that?”

“Not exactly like that. But basically.”

“And what did you say?”

“I told her I had plans.”

“Did she get mad?”

“She got quiet. Which is worse.”

Diane smiled despite herself.

Shonda lowered her voice. “Aunt Diane, I think Corinne has gotten used to everybody rearranging around her because things have been hard.”

Diane looked at Nolan's permission slip.

“Things have been hard for her.”

“I know.”

“Losing her mama. Those two fathers being inconsistent. Working full time. I know.”

“But hard isn't the same as helpless.”

Diane said nothing.

Shonda added, “And helping isn't the same as being available on command.”

Diane ran a thumb along the edge of the paper.

“Loretta said almost the same thing.”

“Loretta is usually right.”

“Don't ever tell her that.”

They laughed.

After the call, Diane opened a small notebook from the kitchen drawer.

She did not intend to keep score. She hated people who weaponized every favor they had ever done.

Still, she began writing.

School pickups.

Doctor visits.

Rent assistance.

Weekend childcare.

Emergency groceries.

Car rides.

Birthday cakes.

Summer camp deposits.

A month when Corinne's car was being repaired and Diane had driven her to work before sunrise.

She stopped after two pages.

The list did not make her feel generous.

It made her tired.

Diane turned back several pages and began adding dates where she could remember them. She stopped after ten minutes because the exercise started to feel like an audit, and that was not what she wanted. Corinne was not a customer. Nolan and Esme were not debts.

Still, patterns mattered.

One Saturday stood out: the morning Diane had canceled a dental cleaning because Corinne's sitter failed to arrive. Another note reminded her of a winter evening when she drove across town in freezing rain because Nolan had forgotten his inhaler at her house. There were dozens of moments Diane would choose again without hesitation.

That complicated the story she was telling herself.

She was not a victim of Corinne's dependence.

Often, Diane had enjoyed being essential.

When the family called her first, she felt trusted. When children ran into her arms, she felt rich in a way money could not create. After Leon died, usefulness had helped fill hours that otherwise echoed. Solving problems gave shape to grief.

Diane wrote one more line in the notebook: I taught them I would always say yes.

She underlined it.

That did not excuse Corinne's assumption. It did prevent Diane from pretending the pattern had been built by one person alone.

She tore out no pages.

Instead, she wrote a second heading beneath the list.

WHAT I STILL WANT TO GIVE.

Birthday dinners.

School plays.

Emergency help when I can.

Occasional sleepovers.

Sunday meals.

Advice when requested.

Time because I choose it.

The new list made her smile.

A boundary, she realized, did not have to be a wall around generosity. It could be the thing that kept generosity from souring into resentment.

Then she noticed something else.

Almost none of the entries contained anything Diane had received in return.

Not because Corinne was cruel. Not because she did not love Diane.

Because Diane had trained everyone around her to believe she needed nothing.

She rarely asked for rides. Rarely admitted loneliness. Rarely said she was tired. When her own knee surgery had left her limping for three weeks, she had prepared frozen meals in advance rather than ask family to cook.

When her husband Leon died eight years earlier, Diane had accepted casseroles for one week and then started taking care of other people again.

Reliable people had a strange problem.

Everyone admired their strength until strength became a service.

Diane closed the notebook.

That afternoon, she called Nolan's school.

“This is Diane Brooks,” she said. “I'm listed as an emergency contact for Nolan Brooks. I need to know what that means exactly.”

The secretary explained the procedure.

Diane listened carefully.

“Can his mother change it?”

“Yes, ma'am.”

“Good. Because I'd like her to call me before I'm listed on anything new.”

The secretary paused, perhaps uncertain why that mattered.

May you like

Diane smiled to herself.

A week earlier, she might not have known either.

Related Stories

Other posts