scribe

Chapter 1 - THE EMPTY CHAIR

By the time Maelis Arden noticed the empty chair, the first course had already gone cold in front of her.

The dining room of Arden Hall looked exactly the way Christmas was supposed to look in picture books. Beeswax candles burned in silver holders. Holly garlands ran along the carved mantel. A twelve-foot fir tree shimmered beyond the archway, its lights blurred into gold whenever Maelis blinked. Snow pressed pale against the tall windows while the fireplace gave off a dry, steady crackle.

Everything was beautiful except for the chair beside her.

It had been set properly: porcelain plate, folded linen napkin, crystal water glass, polished dessert fork. No coat draped over the back. No handbag beneath it. No person.

Maelis kept looking at it because three weeks earlier her father had knelt beside her bed and promised that Christmas Eve would be different.

“I’ll try to make sure your mother can come,” Caedmon had said.

At seven, Maelis believed promises came in only two kinds: kept and broken. She had not yet learned the adult category called trying.

She waited until Eudora Arden finished cutting her pheasant.

“That’s Mommy’s chair, right?” Maelis asked.

The room became strangely still, though nobody had stopped moving yet.

Eudora lifted her napkin and touched one corner to her mouth. At sixty-seven, she had perfected the ability to make even irritation look ceremonial.

“No,” she said. “It’s for Aunt Celestine.”

Maelis looked toward Celestine, who was already sitting three places away.

Celestine’s face changed first.

Only a little.

A tiny tightening around the eyes.

Maelis turned to her father.

“You promised she’d eat with me tonight.”

Caedmon’s fork paused above his plate.

“I said I’d try.”

That phrase landed somewhere behind Maelis’s ribs.

Ysoria lifted her wineglass. Her emerald satin sleeves caught the candlelight.

“Your mother isn’t part of this family anymore.”

She said it lightly, almost kindly, as though explaining that a shop had closed.

Maelis frowned.

“Then why does Mommy still pay for this house?”

Caedmon’s fork struck the plate with a small silver click.

That was the first sound.

Then none.

Not the cutlery. Not Celestine’s breathing. Not even Eudora’s necklace shifting against the brocade neckline of her dress.

Caedmon lowered his fork.

His eyes were no longer tired.

They were alert.

“Who told you that?”

“Mommy’s lawyer,” Maelis said. “You left your phone on the table.”

Eudora stiffened.

“Children shouldn’t listen to adult matters.”

Maelis looked down at her plate.

She had expected someone to tell her she had misunderstood.

Instead, everybody had become afraid of the sentence.

Then the front doorbell rang.

Once.

Clean and sharp through the old house.

Everyone froze.

Maelis did not look toward the hallway.

She kept her eyes on her father.

“Mommy said tell the truth tonight,” she said quietly, “or her lawyer will tomorrow.”

The bell rang again.

Caedmon stood so quickly his chair moved back half an inch.

Ysoria’s hand tightened around her wineglass.

Eudora whispered, “Celestine.”

But Celestine did not move.

She was staring at Caedmon.

“What did you do?” she asked.

It was the first question of the night that was not directed at Maelis.

And for the first time, Maelis understood that the empty chair had never been the real secret.

Maelis had not meant to frighten anyone.

That bothered her most.

She had asked a question the way she asked where her mittens were or whether the Christmas pudding had raisins. Yet Eudora's hand had stopped in midair, Ysoria had forgotten to drink from her glass, and Celestine's eyes had gone to Caedmon before they went anywhere else.

Maelis looked again at the empty chair. A year ago, she would have assumed the grown-ups knew more because they were grown. Tonight she discovered that knowing more and telling the truth were not the same thing.

The bell waited somewhere beyond the dining-room doors.

Caedmon straightened his cuff although it was already straight.

"Stay here," he said.

"Is it Mommy?"

"I don't know."

It was a strange answer from a man who had spent the whole dinner sounding certain.

Celestine watched him leave.

Ysoria whispered, "This is unnecessary."

Eudora answered, "Not another word."

Maelis looked from one woman to the other.

"What shouldn't I know?"

Neither replied.

So she folded her hands in her lap and listened to her father's footsteps cross the hall.

May you like

The mystery was no longer who had rung the bell.

It was why four adults were afraid a seven-year-old might hear the answer.

Related Stories

Other posts