Chapter 3 - The Camera Next Door

Camille Foster waited until Alaric’s car disappeared around the corner before walking across the lawn.
She carried nothing but her phone and a folded grocery bag because she did not want to arrive looking like a witness.
Rosalind answered after the second knock.
Up close, the redness on her cheek had faded into a muted bruise beneath makeup. Camille felt anger rise so fast she had to slow her breathing before speaking.
“I made too much banana bread,” she said, lifting the empty grocery bag as if surprised to find nothing inside it.
Rosalind blinked.
Camille winced. “That sounded less ridiculous in my head.”
Something in Rosalind’s face gave way—not into tears, but into weary understanding.
“You saw.”
Camille nodded.
Rosalind stepped back and let her in.
They sat at the kitchen table. The casserole dish from the night before was gone. The folder Vivienne had left remained near the place mat, closed now.
Camille placed her phone on the table.
“My side camera caught the window.”
Rosalind’s fingers tightened around her mug.
“How much?”
“Enough.”
“Did it record sound?”
“Not from inside. I heard the slap from my study because my window was open. The video shows him strike you, you hit the wall, and him turning away.”
Rosalind stared into her tea.
Camille continued carefully. “I saved the original file. I also copied it to an external drive. I haven’t sent it anywhere.”
“Why not?”
“Because I wanted you to know first, unless I thought you or the baby were in immediate danger.”
Rosalind’s eyes lifted.
“You didn’t call the police.”
“I almost did.” Camille did not defend herself. “Then I saw him move away from you. I watched until the kitchen went dark. Maybe I made the wrong call.”
“No.” Rosalind pressed her thumb against the handle of her mug. “I don’t know.”
The admission filled the kitchen.
Camille reached across the table but stopped short of touching her. “Has he done it before?”
Rosalind’s gaze shifted toward the wall.
She could still see the slight scrape where her shoulder had struck it.
“Three times,” she said.
Camille inhaled slowly.
“The first was last winter. He grabbed my arm hard enough to bruise it. Then in May he shoved me into a closet door. In July he slapped me in the garage.”
“And last night.”
Rosalind nodded.
“Was alcohol involved every time?”
“Twice.”
“His mother?”
Rosalind looked at her sharply.
Camille said, “I’m not blaming her. I’m asking.”
Rosalind leaned back.
“Every time, they’d spoken that day.”
She thought of the folder on the table.
Camille followed her gaze. “What’s that?”
“Something they want me to sign.”
She slid the folder over.
Camille did not open it. “Do you have a lawyer?”
“No.”
“You should get one before you sign anything.”
“I know.”
“Not his family lawyer.”
“I know.”
Rosalind’s voice cracked on the second word.
Camille waited.
“I keep thinking I should have left after the first time,” Rosalind said. “But then he was horrified. He cried. He stopped drinking for months. He went to counseling twice. Then he said the counselor was making him feel like a criminal.”
Camille said nothing.
“Everyone loves him,” Rosalind continued. “My obstetrician likes him. The neighbors like him. The people at the grocery store know him. He brings my grandmother’s flowers to the cemetery.”
“Good people can do terrible things,” Camille said. “And people who do terrible things can still do kind things. You don’t have to solve his entire soul before you decide whether you’re safe.”
Rosalind closed her eyes.
That sentence was the first thing anyone had said that did not require her to choose between the Alaric who had once sat on a bathroom floor holding her hair while she was sick and the Alaric who had slapped her into a wall.
Both could be true.
Camille unlocked her phone and turned the screen toward Rosalind.
“I can give you the file now.”
Rosalind looked at the still frame. In it, her body was blurred by motion, one hand already going to her belly. Alaric’s arm was extended. It was ugly and ordinary.
Not cinematic. Not ambiguous.
She whispered, “Send it.”
Camille sent the original video file through an encrypted share link, then wrote down the exact date, time and camera model on a sheet of paper.
“You’re very organized,” Rosalind said.
“I used to work in insurance claims.”
That almost made Rosalind smile.
Before Camille left, she paused at the door.
“One more thing. My camera recorded him pulling into the driveway about a minute before he came inside. He was still on the phone.”
Rosalind’s stomach tightened.
“Can you hear that?”
“Some of it. Not everything.”
“What did he say?”
Camille hesitated.
Rosalind’s hand moved protectively over her abdomen. “Please.”
Camille looked directly at her.
“He said, ‘She’ll sign. She always calms down.’ Then he said, ‘I know what’s at stake.’”
Rosalind did not move.
May you like
Outside, a garbage truck groaned down the street.
Inside, she stared at the cream folder on the table and understood that the slap might not have begun with dinner at all.