Chapter 14 - The Lawyer Her Father Never Chose

Everett Sloan’s office had once occupied the top floor of a glass building downtown. By the time Samuel began asking questions, Sloan had retired to Florida and the firm had merged twice.
But old billing records survived.
Samuel obtained copies from Rosalind’s reopened estate file after filing the necessary petition to inspect and supplement the probate record. The process was slower than television and more revealing than Rosalind expected.
There were no dramatic safes.
There were invoices.
One invoice from July 2022 listed six hours for “conference regarding private-company interest / creditor coordination.”
Rosalind had never been billed for those six hours.
Another entry showed “no charge — courtesy coordination with V. Vale.”
A week later, Sloan’s firm had sent Rosalind a letter stating that all known non-public securities of Jonathan Mercer had either been liquidated or deemed without estate value.
Samuel placed the pages side by side.
“He was communicating with Vivienne while advising you.”
“Was that illegal?” Rosalind asked.
“Not every contact with another interested party is improper. But if he represented you as personal representative of the estate, his duties ran to the estate. We need to know whether he withheld information or acted under a conflict.”
Naomi had hired a forensic accountant, Priya Desai, to trace the $86,000 transfer and evaluate documents Rosalind lawfully possessed.
Priya found the next piece.
Three months after Jonathan’s estate closed, Vale Advisory Services LLC paid Sloan’s former firm $42,000.
The invoice description read: STRATEGIC RESTRUCTURING CONSULTATION.
Vale Advisory Services was controlled by Vivienne.
Rosalind stared at the bank record.
“So she paid my probate lawyer after he helped close my father’s estate without the shares.”
Samuel raised a finger. “We know her company paid his firm. We do not yet know the payment was for your estate matter.”
Rosalind nodded, though she hated the discipline of uncertainty.
They sent a preservation letter and request for Sloan’s file.
Three days later, his lawyer responded.
Sloan was willing to produce non-privileged records and asserted that he had relied on representations from Vale Residential Group that Jonathan’s shares had been redeemed before death.
The records included an email.
From: Vivienne Vale
To: Everett Sloan
Date: July 1, 2022
Everett,
Please keep the Mercer interest out of Rosalind’s immediate concerns. Arthur and Jonathan settled the economics long ago even if the paperwork lagged. She is emotionally fragile and does not need to inherit a corporate dispute while burying her father. We will provide confirmation for the estate file.
Sloan had replied:
I need written confirmation of redemption and payment before I can omit an asset.
Two days later Vivienne sent him a one-page “redemption confirmation,” purportedly signed by Arthur Vale and dated May 20, 2022—before Jonathan’s death.
That document was different from the August 30 board consent.
Rosalind compared them.
The May confirmation said the redemption had already occurred.
The August consent said it became effective on August 30.
Two documents.
Two dates.
Two incompatible stories.
Samuel said, “That inconsistency matters.”
Sloan’s file contained no proof of payment.
It did contain a handwritten note from him: V says payment netted against Mercer obligations. Need backup.
No backup followed.
Yet two months later the estate closed.
Samuel rubbed his forehead. “He should have resolved this.”
“Why didn’t he?” Rosalind asked.
The answer came in Sloan’s own later email to a partner.
Client wants estate closed. Vale issue supposedly resolved; no funds available to litigate. VVRG may retain firm for restructuring work. Monitor conflict.
Rosalind read the last two words.
Monitor conflict.
“He knew.”
Samuel did not soften it. “He recognized there was at least a potential conflict.”
“And kept going.”
“Yes.”
The betrayal was quieter than Alaric’s slap.
That made it no less intimate.
Rosalind had sat across from Everett Sloan three weeks after her father’s funeral and cried because she could not understand a tax form. He had pushed a box of tissues toward her. He had told her, “Let us carry the administrative burden.”
She had thanked him.
Now she understood that while she was trying to remember her father’s passwords and cancel his cable service, other people had been deciding which part of his estate she would never know existed.
That evening Alaric sent a message through Naomi.
I found an old email from Dad to me. It mentions Jonathan’s shares. I think Rosalind should have it.
The email was dated April 2022.
Arthur had written:
Alaric, if anything happens to me before we clean this up, do not let your mother turn Jonathan’s stake into a family war. It is real. He earned it. If Rosalind ever becomes part of your life permanently, tell her the truth before money makes cowards of all of us.
Rosalind stopped breathing for a moment.
April 2022.
She and Alaric had been engaged then.
Their wedding had been six months later.
May you like
Arthur had told him to tell her.
Alaric had not.