scribe

Chapter 16 - Before I Do Something Worse

Nathan read the first sentence three times.

I need to tell you the truth before I do something I can’t take back.

Below it, Victoria’s handwriting was less controlled than usual.

I resent her.

Nathan stopped.

He glanced into the back seat. Cece was watching houses pass outside, Backup Foxy tucked beneath her chin.

He folded the letter and waited until they returned to the hotel.

Only after Cece was asleep did he read the rest.

I know how ugly that sounds. I have tried to call it exhaustion, discipline, disrespect, anything but what it is. When Cecilia walks into a room, you change. Your whole face changes. You listen to her in a way you stopped listening to me months ago. I know she is your daughter. I know I am the adult. I know all of that, and sometimes I still feel like I am losing to an eight-year-old.

Nathan sat motionless.

Victoria had known.

Not after the fact.

Before.

The letter continued.

I have started making rules that are stricter than they need to be because I want her to feel that I have authority too. Sometimes when she asks for you, I want to say no simply because she asked. I hate that part of myself. I have not hurt her. I would never hurt her. But I am afraid of who I become when I feel invisible in this house.

Nathan closed his eyes.

The date was fourteen days before his trip.

She had identified the danger with startling clarity.

Then she had hidden the letter.

The final paragraph was worse.

I want to tell you this, but I’m afraid you’ll look at me differently. I’m afraid you’ll choose her without even thinking. Maybe I should handle it myself. Maybe if she learns to respect me while you’re gone, this feeling will pass.

Nathan lowered the page.

There it was.

The fork in the road.

Victoria had recognized jealousy as dangerous, considered telling him, then decided secrecy would give her more control.

He called his lawyer the next morning.

The letter was shared with investigators through proper channels.

Detective Ruiz read it carefully.

“This is significant context,” she said.

“She knew she was escalating.”

“It indicates awareness of resentment and concern about her own behavior. A prosecutor will decide how much weight it carries.”

Nathan stared at the copy.

“She wrote, ‘I have not hurt her.’”

“That was true or false depending on what had happened by that date.”

Nathan thought back.

The earlier food restrictions had already started in smaller ways.

No snack after arguing.

No dessert after asking for him.

Maybe Victoria did not call those harm.

That frightened him almost more.

Dr. Morris later explained something similar without discussing the criminal evidence.

“People often create private definitions that protect their self-image,” she said. “If ‘harm’ means hitting, they can tell themselves withholding food or isolating a child is discipline. That doesn’t make the behavior less harmful.”

Nathan rubbed his face.

“What do I tell Cece if she someday asks why?”

“The truth at a level she can understand. Victoria had feelings she was responsible for managing. Instead, she made Cece carry them.”

At school, Cece was beginning to stabilize.

She still kept emergency snacks in her backpack, but she no longer hid wrappers.

Coach Collins noticed something else.

Cece started asking questions.

“Can I get water?”

“Yes.”

“Can I sit out one lap?”

“Yes.”

“Can I eat my snack now?”

“If that’s what your plan allows, yes.”

The questions were small acts of testing.

Would adults punish her for having needs?

Sarah answered consistently.

One Friday, after PE, Cece stayed behind.

“Coach?”

“Yeah?”

“Did you know right away?”

“Know what?”

“That Victoria was bad.”

Sarah thought carefully.

“I knew something was wrong when you cried over the snack. I didn’t know everything.”

“Why did you believe me?”

“Because you told me something serious, and my job was to listen and get help. I didn’t have to decide the whole case in that moment.”

Cece looked down.

“What if I was wrong about something?”

“People can forget details when they’re scared. That doesn’t mean adults ignore them.”

Cece nodded slowly.

Then she asked the question Sarah had expected eventually.

“Did you tell her?”

“No. Not before the safety people decided what should happen.”

Cece’s eyes softened.

Sarah smiled.

“You asked me not to tell her you told me. I couldn’t promise to keep everything secret, because I had to get help. But I could make sure I didn’t hand you back to the person you were afraid of.”

Cece absorbed that distinction.

Later, Nathan picked her up.

In the car she said, “Coach didn’t keep my secret.”

Nathan glanced at her.

“Are you upset?”

“No.”

“Why not?”

“Because she kept me safe instead.”

Nathan felt his eyes sting.

Cece looked out the window.

Then she added, almost casually, “That’s different.”

Yes, Nathan thought.

May you like

It was.

And perhaps learning the difference between secrecy and safety would be one of the most important things Victoria had nearly taken from her.

Related Stories

Other posts