scribe

Chapter 14 - The Apology Letter

Victoria sent the letter through her attorney.

Because the protective order prohibited direct contact, her lawyer first provided it to Nathan’s counsel, who advised him not to show it to Cece unless her therapist believed it would help.

Nathan read it alone.

Nathan,

I know you have already decided who I am.

I am not asking you to ignore what happened. I lost control. I handled Cecilia’s behavior badly. I was overwhelmed and alone, and I felt like every attempt to create structure was being undermined by her need to make me the villain.

Nathan stopped reading.

Even in an apology, Cece was responsible.

He continued.

I should never have put food on the floor. I should never have restricted access to snacks the way I did. I am deeply ashamed of that. But I did not intend to starve her. I believed she was eating at school and hiding food elsewhere. I know now that I was wrong.

Nathan stared at the sentence.

She believed Cece was eating at school.

The account logs showed Victoria received every warning.

The letter went on.

I loved her. I still do. I became jealous of the bond you shared, and I hated myself for it. When you traveled, I felt I had one chance to establish a relationship where she respected me instead of waiting for you to overrule me.

Nathan’s anger shifted.

For the first time, Victoria had named jealousy.

Not fully.

Not honestly enough.

But named it.

The letter ended with a request for treatment, forgiveness, and someday supervised contact.

Nathan forwarded it to Maya, Detective Ruiz, and his lawyer.

He did not reply.

At therapy that week, Cece worked with Dr. Lena Morris, a child psychologist experienced in trauma. They used drawings, not interrogation.

Cece drew the house.

She drew the kitchen very large.

She drew herself small beside the stairs.

She drew Victoria near the refrigerator.

She did not draw Nathan.

Dr. Morris asked, “Where was Dad?”

Cece drew a tiny rectangle in the corner.

“That’s his phone.”

“Was he in the phone?”

“He was far away.”

“What did you want to happen?”

Cece colored the phone blue.

“I wanted it to ring and him to hear me.”

“Did it?”

“No.”

“What happened instead?”

Cece drew a line between herself and Victoria.

“She heard everything.”

At the end of the session, Dr. Morris spoke with Nathan privately.

“Cece is not only afraid of hunger,” she said. “She is afraid that access to you can be controlled by someone else.”

Nathan nodded.

“How do I fix that?”

“You cannot promise you will never be physically away. You can make communication predictable and redundant.”

Together they created a plan.

Cece would have Nathan’s number memorized.

She would also have Mark’s number.

The school would maintain updated contacts.

Cece would know that if a device failed, she could tell any teacher, counselor, nurse, or administrator, “I need help contacting my dad.”

Nathan bought a basic child-safe phone with limited contacts and no social media.

When he gave it to her, Cece did not look excited.

She looked suspicious.

“Can Victoria lock it?”

“No.”

“Can you?”

“Yes, because I’m the parent account.”

Her face fell.

Nathan understood.

“But I won’t use that to stop you from asking for help. And Uncle Mark is a backup contact.”

She turned the phone over in her hands.

“What if I lose it?”

“Then we replace it.”

“What if I’m bad?”

“The phone is for safety. It is not a reward.”

Cece looked up.

That distinction mattered.

Later, Nathan received another call from Detective Ruiz.

“The prosecutor has approved charges.”

Nathan stood.

“What charges?”

Ruiz explained that the exact counts would be filed based on state law and evidence, including allegations related to child neglect and cruelty. She cautioned that charging was not conviction.

“When?”

“Soon.”

Nathan looked toward Cece’s bedroom.

“Will she be arrested?”

“Arrangements are being made through counsel.”

Nathan felt no triumph.

Only heaviness.

Then Ruiz added, “Her attorney has asked whether there is a path to resolving the criminal case without trial.”

Nathan frowned.

“Is that my decision?”

“No. Prosecutors decide whether to negotiate. Victim input can be considered, but you do not carry responsibility for the outcome.”

Nathan thought of Victoria’s letter.

I became jealous.

He asked, “Does admitting part of it help her?”

“It can affect negotiations. But evidence matters more than wording.”

After the call, Nathan folded the letter and placed it in a folder.

He had once wanted an explanation that would make Victoria’s behavior understandable.

May you like

Now he saw the danger in that wish.

Understanding why someone did harm was not the same as reducing what they had done.

Related Stories

Other posts