Chapter 2 - The Girl Who Saw Everything

The first person to speak to Lily was a quiet classmate named Grace
Bell.
“Are you okay?”
Lily nodded automatically.
Grace looked at the red mark on her cheek. “No, you’re not.”
Ms. Price had stepped into the hallway, taking Lily’s phone with her.
The moment the door closed, whispers erupted.
“She hit her.”
“I saw it.”
“Are we allowed to tell?”
Grace reached into her backpack and pulled out a small school-issued
tablet. “My dad says when adults tell you something didn’t happen, write
down what happened before you forget.”
Lily stared at her.
Grace opened a notes page and typed the time: 12:16 p.m.
“What are you doing?”
“Remembering.”
When Ms. Price returned, she was composed again. “Everyone back to
lunch.”
Her gaze settled on Grace’s tablet.
“Put that away.”
Grace obeyed, but not before pressing save.
At dismissal, Lily waited beneath Hawthorne’s arched stone entrance.
Natalie’s SUV appeared at the curb. The instant Natalie saw her
daughter, she knew something was wrong.
Lily climbed in and fastened her seat belt without speaking.
Natalie touched her chin gently. “Look at me.”
Lily turned.
The faint mark was still visible.
Natalie went still. “Who did that?”
Lily’s lips trembled. “Ms. Price.”
The answer seemed too impossible to fit inside the car.
“What?”
“She took my phone. I asked if I could talk to the principal first.”
Natalie’s voice became unnaturally calm. “And then?”
“She hit me.”
Natalie closed her eyes for one second.
“Where is your phone?”
“Ms. Price has it.”
Natalie reached for the door handle.
Lily grabbed her sleeve. “Mom.”
Natalie looked back.
“She declined your call.”
That changed something.
Natalie had been angry before. Now she was alarmed.
Inside the school, Headmaster Charles Wexler received them in a paneled
office lined with framed photographs of donors and graduating classes.
Ms. Price sat across from him.
“I did confiscate the phone,” Adrienne said. “Lillian became upset. She
moved suddenly and bumped her face against the edge of a bookcase.”
Lily stared at her.
“That’s not true.”
Wexler folded his hands. “Lily, serious accusations require care.”
Natalie’s eyes hardened. “My daughter is not an accusation.”
Adrienne looked wounded. “I would never strike a child.”
The office door opened.
Grace stood there with her father, Thomas Bell.
Grace held up her tablet.
“I wrote down what happened.”
Wexler’s expression changed.
Thomas said, “And my daughter says there were twelve witnesses.”
For the first time, Adrienne looked toward the ceiling.
Natalie followed her gaze.
A black dome camera sat in the corner.
“Good,” Natalie said. “Then this should be very easy.”
Wexler did not answer.
He looked at the camera, then at Natalie.
“The classroom cameras,” he said slowly, “haven’t been recording for
several weeks.”
Natalie stared at him.
From across the room, Lily whispered, “That’s not what Ms. Price told us
yesterday.”
Everyone turned.
May you like
Lily swallowed.
“She said the cameras see everything.”