scribe

Chapter 14 - A Father Made of Two Truths

Natalie’s first instinct was to defend her father.

Ellen stopped her.

“Don’t deny what we haven’t disproved.”

“But Martin is twisting it.”

“Then untwist it with facts.”

They spent two days reviewing Jonathan’s records.

The truth was uncomfortable.

Jonathan had approved three payments connected to admissions favors. He

had attended dinners where access and donations were discussed in ways

that made Natalie ashamed.

But the later transfers—the shell companies, false valuations, diverted

trust value—began after Jonathan had ordered the practice stopped.

A memo in his handwriting read:

No more quid-pro-quo treatment through Hawthorne. We built relationships

and ended up buying obedience. It stops now.

Martin had replied:

You’re becoming sentimental.

Jonathan wrote beneath it:

Maybe. Or maybe I finally understand the price.

Natalie read the exchange with tears in her eyes.

Her father was neither innocent nor the monster Martin needed him to be.

He was a man who had compromised, benefited, recognized the damage too

late, and tried to reverse it.

At dinner, Lily asked why reporters were outside the gate.

“They want to know about Grandpa.”

“Was he bad?”

Natalie put down her fork.

“He did some things I wish he hadn’t.”

“Like Ms. Price?”

“Different things.”

“Did he lie?”

“Sometimes.”

Lily considered this.

“Did you love him?”

“Very much.”

“Can you love somebody and still tell the truth about them?”

Natalie looked at her daughter.

“Yes.”

The answer became her public statement the next morning.

She acknowledged Jonathan’s role in improper influence practices and

announced that the Mercer family would cooperate fully with

investigators. She also pledged to return any provably improper benefits

to affected charitable funds.

Daniel called afterward.

“Dad would hate this.”

“I know.”

“He’d also be proud.”

“I don’t know.”

And for once, Natalie was comfortable not knowing.

That afternoon, Samuel found something in the recovered audit.

A series of initials appeared beside the largest transactions.

M.V.

C.W.

And D.M.

Natalie stared.

“Daniel Mercer?”

Samuel shook his head.

“Maybe.”

Natalie called her brother.

He denied involvement.

“I swear to you.”

“Then who is D.M.?”

Daniel went silent.

Finally he said, “There was another D.M. around Dad.”

“Who?”

“Diane Mercer.”

May you like

Natalie’s mother.

The woman who had died twelve years earlier.

Related Stories

Other posts