scribe

Chapter 3 - A Record of Weakness

The black notebook explained several moments Perpetua had previously dismissed. Mrs. Whitfield had asked the cook whether Perpetua had left breakfast unfinished. She had questioned Clara about a handkerchief found damp. She had corrected Julian when he casually said Perpetua was tired, insisting the proper word was "agitated." At the time each correction had seemed merely severe. Now Perpetua saw someone building vocabulary around her, replacing ordinary pregnancy with terms that sounded pathological.

What frightened her most was how easy the scheme would be to believe from a distance. A wealthy pregnant woman who cried, slept badly, forgot gloves, complained of pain, and argued with her mother-in-law could be described as overwhelmed without inventing a single event. The lie lived in the arrangement of true details. Perpetua began mentally cataloging witnesses—not because she wanted a battle, but because she suddenly understood that memory alone would not protect her if everyone else's version had been written down first.

Perpetua carried the note downstairs the next morning.

Mrs. Whitfield was in the breakfast room reading financial correspondence beside a silver coffee service. She did not look up when Perpetua entered.

"You took Dr. Bell's instructions from my desk."

Mrs. Whitfield turned a page.

"Good morning, Perpetua."

"Did you take them?"

"I removed a scrap of paper you were obsessing over."

"It was medical advice."

Mrs. Whitfield finally raised her eyes.

"It was a suggestion from a provincial physician who has known you for six months. I have managed pregnancies, convalescences, deaths, and this household for longer than you have been alive."

Perpetua remained standing.

"Please return it."

"Sit."

"I would rather stand."

A tiny pause.

Mrs. Whitfield placed the letter she was reading on the table.

"You see? This is what I mean. Contradiction for its own sake. Agitation. Fixation."

Perpetua felt cold despite the fire.

"What are you writing down about me?"

Mrs. Whitfield's expression did not alter, but one finger moved over the edge of the paper before her.

Perpetua saw it then: a bound black notebook, half hidden beneath the morning post.

Mrs. Whitfield closed it.

"Your condition requires observation."

"By you?"

"By those responsible for the welfare of this family."

The phrase disturbed Perpetua more than an insult would have.

Before she could ask what it meant, Julian entered.

Mrs. Whitfield's entire manner softened by a degree.

"Your wife is distressed again."

Perpetua turned to him. "I am not distressed. I am asking why your mother has taken my doctor's instructions and is keeping notes about my behavior."

Julian frowned at the black book.

"Mother?"

"Pregnancy has exhausted her," Mrs. Whitfield said. "You have noticed it yourself. Tears. Forgetfulness. Sudden anger."

"I have not—"

Perpetua stopped.

Julian had noticed tears. He had noticed irritation. He had noticed her exhaustion.

And Mrs. Whitfield knew it.

"Julian," Perpetua said slowly, "have you discussed my health with her without me present?"

He rubbed a hand over his jaw.

"Only generally."

"What does that mean?"

"It means Mother asked if you were sleeping and I answered."

"What else?"

"Perpetua—"

"What else?"

Mrs. Whitfield poured coffee.

"Do not interrogate your husband at breakfast."

Perpetua ignored her.

Julian's discomfort became its own confession.

"She asked whether you had become more emotional," he said. "Whether you seemed overwhelmed."

"And you said?"

"That you had."

Perpetua laughed once, without amusement.

"I am eight months pregnant in a house where I need permission to stand from a piano bench. Yes, Julian. I am overwhelmed."

Mrs. Whitfield's spoon clicked against porcelain.

"There. That tone."

Perpetua looked at her and understood for the first time that every reaction could be made to prove the accusation that caused it.

She left the room.

In the corridor, Clara intercepted her.

"My lady."

"Not now."

"Please."

Something in Clara's face made Perpetua stop.

The maid led her into a linen closet and shut the door.

"I saw the notebook yesterday," Clara whispered. "Mrs. Whitfield left it open in your dressing room."

Perpetua's pulse quickened.

"What did it say?"

"Dates. Things you've done. Things you haven't done. 'Wept after supper.' 'Refused veal.' 'Raised voice to Julian.' 'Forgot gloves.' 'Complained of pain.'"

Perpetua pressed a hand to the shelf for balance.

"Why?"

"There was a heading on one page." Clara swallowed. "It said, 'Evidence of Nervous Unfitness.'"

The baby shifted under Perpetua's ribs.

She remembered Mrs. Whitfield's words: those responsible for the welfare of this family.

"Unfit for what?" she whispered.

Clara shook her head.

At the far end of the hall, a bell rang sharply.

Mrs. Whitfield's bell.

Clara opened the closet door.

Before leaving, she turned back.

"There was one more thing."

Perpetua waited.

"Your name was written beside a date six weeks from now. Underlined twice."

"What date?"

May you like

Clara told her.

It was Perpetua's expected confinement.

Related Stories

Other posts