Chapter 15 - The Missing Page

Perpetua also asked Dr. Bell to send future medical advice in duplicate: one copy to her, one to Price. The doctor raised his eyebrows but agreed without comment. It was a small administrative act, almost laughably ordinary, yet it restored something Cordelia had taken. No one person could again remove a paper and then use its disappearance as proof that Perpetua had imagined it. The solution was not trust. It was redundancy.
The missing documents made Perpetua reconsider where safety actually existed. Her bedroom had a lock, yet Cordelia possessed keys. The bank vault was miles away, yet its certified copy of the trust proved harder to erase than any paper under Perpetua's mattress. She began sending copies outward: to Price, to Samuel Reeve, and, where appropriate, to Dr. Bell. Evidence became safer when no single person controlled all of it.
This was the opposite of Cordelia's instinct. Mrs. Whitfield concentrated information because concentration created power. Perpetua distributed it because distribution created resilience. The contrast would later shape how she ran the trust, but at the time it was simply survival. She wanted enough honest people to know enough pieces that no locked dispatch box could decide reality by itself.
Perpetua checked every hiding place in her bedroom.
The account summaries remained beneath the drawer.
Horace's notes still sat behind the watercolor.
But the trust page inside the prayer book was gone.
So was Dr. Bell's written statement that he had delivered after the examination.
Someone had entered her room.
"Who has keys?" Perpetua asked Amos.
"Mrs. Whitfield. The housekeeper. Myself."
"Could the housekeeper have done it?"
Amos shook his head. "Not knowingly."
"And you?"
He looked almost offended.
"No, my lady."
"Then we know."
Perpetua felt violated in a way that was difficult to explain. The theft of papers was not merely practical. It announced that no drawer, book, bedroom, or private thought was safe under this roof.
Julian wanted to confront his mother immediately.
Perpetua stopped him.
"She wants that."
"Why?"
"Because then she will deny it, you will shout, and she will say the house has become unbearable since I began imagining conspiracies."
Julian stared at her.
"You sound like Price."
"Good. Someone in this family should."
He almost smiled, then thought better of it.
Nathaniel Price was less concerned about the missing trust page than Perpetua expected.
"We have certified copies from the bank," he said. "She cannot erase the trust by stealing paper from your prayer book."
"She also took Dr. Bell's statement."
"He can issue another."
"Then why take them?"
Price considered.
"To frighten you. Or to determine exactly what you know."
Clara's copied pages from the black notebook arrived by courier the same afternoon.
They proved Mrs. Whitfield had documented Perpetua's behavior for months.
But one detail caught Price's attention.
On a page dated two weeks earlier, beneath an entry describing Perpetua as "agitated after correspondence," Mrs. Whitfield had written:
Alden advises Mercer can act quickly if J signs. Need order before triggering event.
Triggering event.
The birth.
Price placed the copy on his desk.
"This is useful, but we still need the original notebook or a witness who saw it."
"Clara saw it."
"Her testimony matters. Mrs. Whitfield will call her a dismissed thief."
Perpetua's anger flared.
"Because she planted the brush."
"Can we prove that?"
Perpetua went quiet.
Evidence again.
That evening, Amos found her in the small library.
"I may know where the notebook is."
Perpetua turned.
"Where?"
"Mrs. Whitfield keeps a locked dispatch box in her sitting room. Mr. Alden uses it when he visits."
"Can you open it?"
"I have a master key."
Perpetua immediately shook her head.
"No."
Amos looked surprised.
"Why not?"
"Because if we steal it, she will say we manufactured whatever is inside. And because I am tired of becoming like her in order to survive her."
Amos studied her for a moment, then nodded.
"There may be another way."
The opportunity came two days later.
Mrs. Whitfield left for New York with Alden to meet bankers. Julian was already in the city. Perpetua remained at Whitfield Hall under Dr. Bell's explicit instruction not to travel unnecessarily.
Amos entered Mrs. Whitfield's sitting room with the housekeeper and two footmen as witnesses, ostensibly to investigate water leaking from an upstairs pipe.
The dispatch box had been left on a table beneath the damp section of ceiling.
To move it safely, the housekeeper asked Amos to unlock it so that its contents could be removed and protected.
He did.
Inside lay the black notebook.
No one touched it at first.
The housekeeper, Mrs. Fenwick, stared at the label on the open page.
Evidence of Nervous Unfitness — P.B.W.
Her face changed.
"What is that?"
Amos answered carefully.
"Something I believe Mrs. Beauregard-Whitfield should see."
Before anyone could move, a voice sounded from the doorway.
"Indeed she should."
Mrs. Whitfield stood there in her traveling coat.
May you like
She had returned two hours early.
And behind her was Rufus Alden.