Chapter 3 - The Folded List

The object was a folded sheet of notebook paper tucked inside the inner
pocket of Ellie’s backpack.
Ms. Mercer did not open it until Dr. Pierce and Nora returned to school.
Ellie sat beside her mother in the conference room.
On the front, written in purple ink, were three words:
RULES FOR ELLIE.
Dr. Pierce unfolded it.
1. Don’t sit with us.
2. Don’t tell Mercer.
3. Bring snacks if you want us to leave you alone.
4. If you cry, we film it.
5. If you snitch, it gets worse.
Nora covered her mouth.
Ms. Mercer looked at Ellie. “Have you seen this before?”
Ellie nodded.
“When?”
“Friday.”
“Who wrote it?”
“I don’t know.”
It was technically true. Ellie had not seen the pen moving.
But she recognized Marlowe’s rounded lowercase g. She recognized
Tamsin’s habit of drawing tiny stars over the letter i. And she
remembered Briony standing behind them, saying nothing.
Nora knew her daughter’s silences.
“You know more.”
Ellie’s eyes filled.
“I don’t want them to hate me more.”
Nora reached across the table. “Their hatred is not something you have
to earn your way out of.”
Dr. Pierce explained that the school would begin a formal bullying
investigation under its student conduct policy. Parents would be
contacted. Relevant hallway camera footage would be preserved. Students
would be separated while the inquiry proceeded.
“Hallway cameras?” Ellie asked.
“Yes,” Ms. Mercer said.
A flicker of fear crossed Ellie’s face.
Not relief.
Ms. Mercer noticed.
“What is it?”
Ellie shook her head.
That evening, Nora placed Ellie’s backpack on the dining table and told
her they would buy a new one if she wanted.
“No.”
“Why not?”
Ellie ran her thumb over a worn seam.
“Dad gave me this one.”
Nora’s expression softened.
Ellie’s father, Thomas Vaughn, had died two years earlier after a sudden
cardiac event. The backpack had been one of the last ordinary gifts he
had bought her: dark navy canvas with a stitched silver moon on the
front pocket.
Nora had sometimes wondered whether Ellie’s attachment to it was making
school harder. Now she understood why the thought of strangers invading
it had felt like more than a prank.
At 7:14 p.m., Ms. Mercer called again.
The hallway footage showed Marlowe, Tamsin and Briony entering the
girls’ restroom shortly after Ellie. Six minutes later, the three girls
exited.
Ellie came out alone.
There was no camera inside the restroom.
But another camera showed Tamsin carrying a small cardboard pet-store
box into school that morning.
The box disappeared before first period.
“Does the footage show what was inside?” Nora asked.
“No.”
“Then they’ll deny it.”
“Probably.”
Ellie, listening from the doorway, whispered, “They already planned for
that.”
Nora turned.
“What do you mean?”
Ellie hesitated.
Then she walked to the dining table, picked up the folded list and
pointed to the bottom edge.
There, nearly hidden beneath the crease, someone had written a sixth
May you like
rule in pencil.
MAKE BRIONY DO IT.