Chapter 16 - The Video of Her Father

The private video remained the hardest piece of evidence.
Ellie knew it existed on preserved school servers.
Even though access was restricted, the idea made her feel exposed.
“What if someone copies it?” she asked.
Blackwood’s technology director explained that the file had been secured
as part of the investigation and would be retained only as required
under the school’s evidence and records procedures, then deleted
according to policy and legal advice.
Ellie understood perhaps half of that.
“What I mean is, will kids see it?”
“No.”
“Promise?”
He looked at Nora before answering.
“I can promise we will not distribute it and that access is restricted.
I won’t promise something I can’t absolutely control.”
Ellie appreciated that more than false certainty.
She asked to see the clip once.
Nora hesitated.
“Are you sure?”
“Yes.”
The video showed Ellie sitting behind the gym in October, knees pulled
to her chest.
Her own voice sounded small.
“Dad, I made it through another week.”
Then she talked about a spelling test, Nora burning toast, and a blue
jay outside her bedroom window.
The recording ended after forty-three seconds.
Ellie stared at the screen.
“That’s what she used?”
“Yes,” Nora said.
Ellie’s eyes filled.
“It isn’t embarrassing.”
“No.”
“I thought it was.”
Nora squeezed her hand.
“Grief isn’t embarrassing.”
Ellie asked the technology director to close the file.
That night she made a new voice memo.
“Dad,” she said, sitting at her desk, “something bad happened at
school.”
She stopped.
Then started again.
“I kept thinking if people heard me talking to you, they’d think I was
weird. But I think maybe Marlowe needed me to believe that.”
She looked toward the navy backpack hanging from her chair.
“I screamed because there was a mouse in my bag. It was really loud.”
A tiny smile appeared.
“You would’ve laughed after checking the mouse was okay.”
She paused.
“I think I’m okay too. Not all the way.”
Downstairs, Nora heard Ellie’s voice through the ceiling but did not
interrupt.
At school the next day, Ms. Mercer found an envelope on her desk.
Inside was a copy of the class photograph from October seventeenth.
Ellie stood in the second row.
Her shoes were barely visible.
Marlowe stood three children away.
Everyone smiled for the camera.
On the back, someone had written in adult handwriting:
A photograph can show everyone smiling and still miss the truth.
It was from Adrian Vale.
Ms. Mercer pinned it inside her desk drawer where students could not
see.
She understood the lesson.
May you like
Appearances were not evidence of safety.
And silence was not evidence of peace.