Chapter 2 - The Empty Chair

Rosie spent the drive home staring through the rear window of Aunt Helen’s SUV. She did not mention the ruler tap or the push. She did not mention Maddie. Instead, she counted mailboxes until the school disappeared behind the hills.
Helen Bennett, her father’s older sister, knew silence had become Rosie’s safest hiding place.
“How was school?” Helen asked.
“Fine.”
“That sounded aggressively fine.”
Rosie shrugged.
At home, the Bennett property looked almost unreal in the sunset: pale stone walls, dark shutters, broad lawns and the long drive Rosie had drawn that afternoon. The house had belonged to her father’s grandparents, then his parents. After Rosie’s mother, Anna, died, Helen moved into the guest wing so Rosie would not be raised by rotating caregivers while her father’s work took him away.
Inside, Rosie dropped her backpack beside the foyer table.
A framed photograph stood there: Captain Daniel Bennett in dress uniform, Anna laughing beside him, four-year-old Rosie on his shoulders.
Someone had turned the photograph slightly toward the wall.
Rosie turned it back.
“Who keeps doing that?” she asked.
Helen froze halfway through removing her coat.
“No one deliberately.”
“It happens all the time.”
Helen looked at the picture. “The housekeeper dusts.”
Rosie knew that answer was false. Mrs. Alvarez had worked for the family since before Rosie was born and treated photographs like museum objects.
At dinner, Rosie barely touched her chicken.
Helen finally said, “Your teacher emailed me.”
Rosie’s fork stopped.
“She said there was an incident with Madeline Foster.”
“They said Dad was a thief.”
Helen’s face tightened.
“So you knew?” Rosie demanded.
“Knew what?”
“That people say things about him.”
“I know people speculate when they don’t understand something.”
“Then tell me what to understand.”
Helen looked toward the darkened windows.
Rosie’s voice cracked. “Is Dad in prison?”
“No.”
“Did he steal something?”
“No.”
“Did he leave because he didn’t want me?”
Helen’s chair moved sharply. She knelt beside Rosie. “Never believe that.”
“Then where is he?”
“I can’t tell you everything.”
“Everyone says that!”
Rosie ran upstairs.
Helen remained beside the empty chair, eyes wet.
Outside, headlights approached the gate, then stopped.
Helen’s phone vibrated.
One message appeared from an unknown number.
I’m here. Is she awake?
Helen closed her eyes.
May you like
For the first time in nearly a year, she typed back to her brother.
Yes. And she thinks you abandoned her.