scribe

Chapter 14 - Fathers and Daughters

Grant said no.

Rosie’s anger changed shape.

“She should.”

Daniel said gently, “That’s for her parents to decide.”

“Why? Everybody decided I should hear lies about you.”

No one had an easy answer.

Grant left shortly afterward, promising to speak with Caroline first.

The next day Maddie was absent.

Rosie watched her empty desk all morning.

At lunch she asked Ms. Price, “Is she sick?”

“I don’t know.”

Rosie suspected otherwise.

Maddie returned Wednesday with swollen eyes and no mustard headband. She sat without speaking until recess.

Then she approached Rosie beneath the oak tree.

“My dad told me.”

Rosie waited.

“He said he made my mom think your dad was in trouble because he was scared about his own job.”

“Okay.”

Maddie kicked at the mulch. “My mom says she shouldn’t have talked about it around me.”

“Okay.”

“And I shouldn’t have told everyone.”

Rosie looked at her.

Maddie began crying. “I’m sorry I said your dad taught you to steal.”

Rosie wanted to forgive her. She also wanted Maddie to hurt longer.

Both feelings existed at once.

“You knew it made me sad,” Rosie said.

Maddie nodded.

“And you kept doing it.”

“I wanted the other girls to laugh.”

“Why?”

Maddie wiped her face. “Because when they laugh at somebody else, they don’t laugh at me.”

It was not an excuse. Rosie understood that without being told.

“My dad says being scared doesn’t make what he did okay,” Maddie added.

Rosie thought of Daniel saying the same thing about her push.

“Mine says that too.”

For the first time, they shared something neither wanted.

That afternoon Ms. Price held a restorative meeting with both girls and their parents. Caroline apologized directly to Daniel and Rosie.

“I repeated assumptions,” she said. “I treated uncertainty as evidence. That was wrong.”

Rosie asked, “Did you tell other parents?”

Caroline’s silence answered.

“How many?” Daniel asked.

“I don’t know.”

“Then the correction has to travel as far as the rumor did.”

Caroline nodded reluctantly.

Headmaster Warren proposed a written statement to the grade’s parent community clarifying that rumors concerning the Bennett family were false and asking parents to stop discussing private matters around students.

But Caroline’s next words chilled the room.

“One problem,” she said. “Some parents won’t believe a school statement.”

May you like

“Why not?” Ms. Price asked.

“Because someone posted about Daniel online last night.”

Related Stories

Other posts